Allowed Rental Increases for Month-to-Month Tenancy

Allowed Rental Increases for Month-to-Month Tenancy in the Philippines

Introduction

In the Philippine legal framework, a month-to-month tenancy refers to a lease agreement where the rental period is renewed automatically each month, typically because the rent is paid monthly and no fixed term is specified in the contract. This type of tenancy is common for residential properties and is governed primarily by the Civil Code of the Philippines (Republic Act No. 386, as amended), particularly Articles 1654 to 1688 on leases. However, additional regulations apply under special laws such as the Rent Control Act of 2009 (Republic Act No. 9653), which has been subject to extensions and amendments over the years to protect tenants from excessive rent hikes.

Rental increases in month-to-month tenancies are not unrestricted; they must comply with legal limits to prevent abuse by landlords. These limits vary depending on whether the rental unit falls under rent control coverage, the duration of the tenancy, and any prevailing economic or emergency conditions (e.g., during pandemics or calamities). Unauthorized increases can lead to disputes, eviction proceedings, or penalties. This article comprehensively explores the rules, conditions, exceptions, procedures, and remedies related to allowed rental increases for month-to-month tenancies, drawing from established Philippine jurisprudence and statutes.

Legal Basis

Civil Code Provisions

The Civil Code serves as the foundational law for leases in the absence of special regulations. Key articles include:

• Article 1670: If the lease period is not fixed, it is understood to be from year to year (if annual rent), month to month (if monthly rent), week to week (if weekly), or day to day (if daily). For month-to-month tenancies, the lease renews tacitly unless terminated by notice.
• Article 1687: Courts may extend the lease period for up to one year if the tenant has occupied the property for more than one year, to prevent arbitrary terminations. This implies that landlords cannot easily end a month-to-month tenancy solely to impose a higher rent without judicial intervention.
• Article 1654: The lessee is obliged to pay the agreed rent, but changes to the rent amount require mutual consent. Without agreement, the landlord may seek to terminate the lease, but this is subject to notice and potential court-fixed extensions.

In essence, under the Civil Code alone, rent increases require the tenant's agreement. If the tenant refuses, the landlord can serve notice to vacate at the end of the month, but eviction requires a judicial process via unlawful detainer (under Rule 70 of the Rules of Court) and must not violate anti-ejectment protections.

Rent Control Act (RA 9653) and Extensions

For lower-income residential units, the Rent Control Act imposes stricter limits on increases to ensure housing affordability. Originally enacted in 2009, the law has been extended multiple times (e.g., via RA 10754 until 2015, RA 10997 until 2017, RA 11201 until 2021, and subsequent measures). As of the general legal landscape in 2025, assuming ongoing protections based on historical patterns, the key provisions are:

• Coverage: Applies to residential units in the National Capital Region (NCR) and highly urbanized cities with monthly rent not exceeding P10,000, and in other areas not exceeding P5,000. Exemptions include motels, hotels, dormitories, and units under the socialized housing program.
• Section 4 (Limit on Increases): Rent increases are capped at 7% annually (or lower in some extension periods, e.g., 4% during 2020-2021 under pandemic-related adjustments). Increases can only be imposed:
  • Once every 12 months.
  • As long as the unit is occupied by the same tenant.
• Section 5 (Rent Increase Upon Vacancy): When the unit becomes vacant (e.g., after lawful eviction or voluntary departure), the landlord may set a new rent without the 7% cap, but subsequent increases for the new tenant revert to the annual limit.
• Prohibitions: No increase is allowed if the tenant has occupied the unit for less than one year, or during periods of rent freeze (e.g., under calamity declarations or emergency laws like the Bayanihan Acts during COVID-19, which deferred increases and provided grace periods).

For month-to-month tenancies under rent control, the periodic nature does not override these caps; landlords cannot terminate the lease merely to circumvent the 7% limit, as ejectment grounds are restricted (see below).

Other Relevant Laws

• Republic Act No. 9341 (Rental Reform Act of 2005): Predecessor to RA 9653, emphasizing fair rental practices but largely superseded.
• Emergency Measures: During national emergencies (e.g., under RA 11469 and RA 11494, the Bayanihan Acts), rent increases may be frozen, and payments deferred without interest or penalties. Similar provisions could apply in future calamities via presidential proclamations.
• Local Ordinances: Some local government units (LGUs) may impose additional restrictions, but these cannot contradict national laws.
• Jurisprudence: Cases like Spouses Cruz v. Spouses Mercado (G.R. No. 171972, 2008) affirm that rent increases must be reasonable and consensual, with courts scrutinizing abusive practices.

Allowed Rental Increases

For Units Under Rent Control (Low-Rent Residential)

• Maximum Increase: 7% per year (e.g., if current rent is P8,000, the maximum new rent is P8,560).
• Frequency: Only once per 12-month period, calculated from the last increase or the start of tenancy.
• Conditions for Implementation:
  • The tenant must have occupied the unit for at least one year.
  • Written notice must be given at least 30 days in advance (common practice, though not explicitly stated in RA 9653; derived from Civil Code fairness principles).
  • The increase must not result in rent exceeding the coverage threshold (P10,000 in NCR), or the unit may lose rent control protection.
• Calculation Example: For a month-to-month tenancy starting January 1, 2024, at P5,000/month:
  • No increase until January 1, 2025.
  • On January 1, 2025, maximum increase to P5,350 (7% of P5,000).
  • If the tenant stays, next increase on January 1, 2026, to no more than P5,724.50 (7% of P5,350).

For Units Not Under Rent Control (Higher-Rent or Non-Residential)

• No Statutory Cap: Increases are negotiated freely between landlord and tenant.
• Implementation:
  • Requires mutual agreement; if the tenant disagrees, the landlord may terminate the month-to-month tenancy with notice.
  • Notice Period: Typically 15-30 days, aligned with the monthly cycle (e.g., notice by end of month for increase or termination next month).
  • If no agreement, the landlord can initiate ejectment for "expiration of lease period," but courts may extend under Article 1687 if the tenant has long occupancy.
• Reasonableness Requirement: Increases must not be unconscionable (Civil Code Article 1409); excessive hikes (e.g., 100%+) could be challenged as void for public policy reasons.

Special Cases

• Inflation Adjustments: No automatic inflation-linked increases; all hikes must fit within the 7% cap for controlled units.
• Improvements by Landlord: If the landlord makes capital improvements (e.g., renovations), they may justify a higher increase, but only with tenant consent or HUDCC (Housing and Urban Development Coordinating Council) approval for controlled units.
• Utilities and Additional Charges: Increases in utilities (e.g., water, electricity) passed to tenants are allowed if stipulated in the lease, but not considered "rent" for control purposes.

Conditions and Procedures

• Notice Requirements: Always in writing, specifying the new rent amount, effective date, and justification. Verbal notices are insufficient for enforcement.
• Tenant Response: Tenants can accept, negotiate, or refuse. Refusal may lead to termination notice, but for controlled units, eviction requires one of the grounds in RA 9653 Section 9 (e.g., non-payment, subleasing without consent, legitimate owner need, or major repairs).
• Prohibited Practices:
  • Increasing rent to force eviction (violates RA 9653 Section 10).
  • Multiple increases within 12 months.
  • Increases during lease disputes or calamity periods.
• Documentation: Leases should be in writing (though oral month-to-month tenancies are valid), with receipts for all payments to track increases.

Exceptions and Limitations

• Non-Applicable Units: Commercial properties, high-rent residences (>P10,000 in NCR), transient accommodations, and government-owned units are exempt from rent control.
• Force Majeure: During declared states of calamity (e.g., typhoons, pandemics), increases may be suspended by executive order.
• New Constructions: Units built after the law's effectivity may have temporary exemptions.
• Subleases: Sublessees inherit the same rent control protections.

Penalties and Remedies

• For Landlords: Violating rent control (e.g., excessive increase) incurs fines of P25,000 to P50,000 per violation (RA 9653 Section 12), plus potential criminal charges for estafa or refund orders. Tenants can file complaints with the HUDCC or barangay.
• For Tenants: Non-payment of agreed increases can lead to ejectment after demand.
• Dispute Resolution:
  • Barangay Conciliation: Mandatory first step for amounts under P200,000.
  • Metropolitan Trial Court: For ejectment cases.
  • Appeals: To Regional Trial Court, then higher courts.
• Tenant Remedies: Sue for refund of overpayments, damages, or injunction against increases. Organizations like the Department of Human Settlements and Urban Development (DHSUD, successor to HUDCC) provide free legal aid.

Conclusion

Allowed rental increases for month-to-month tenancies in the Philippines balance landlord rights with tenant protections, particularly under rent control for affordable housing. For covered units, the 7% annual cap ensures stability, while non-covered units rely on negotiation and reasonableness. Tenants facing unlawful increases should document everything and seek barangay or DHSUD assistance promptly. Landlords must provide clear notice and adhere to limits to avoid penalties. As laws evolve (e.g., potential new extensions or reforms), consulting updated statutes or legal counsel is advisable for specific cases. This framework promotes fair housing amid economic pressures.

Disclaimer: Grok is not a lawyer; please consult one. Don't share information that can identify you.