Are Acquired Employees Entitled to the Same Benefits After a Company Merger in the Philippines?
This article explains what happens to employee benefits when companies in the Philippines merge or are acquired. It surveys the governing legal rules, leading doctrines, and practical outcomes for statutory and company-granted benefits, with checklists for HR and employees.
The Short Answer
Whether acquired employees keep the same benefits depends on the deal structure:
Merger or stock (share) acquisition: The employer-entity usually remains the same (or is succeeded by a “surviving corporation”). As a rule, employment continues without interruption; existing terms and benefits must not be diminished except as allowed by law and valid agreements. CBAs bind the successor until expiry.
Asset acquisition / business transfer with closure of the seller: The buyer is not legally required to absorb employees, and the seller may legally terminate them under an authorized cause (closure/reorganization). The seller must pay separation pay (unless due to serious losses). If the buyer re-hires, it may set new terms, but watch out for “non-diminution” risks where continuity is implied or where there is a CBA/assumption undertaking.
Legal Foundations
1) Security of Tenure and Authorized Causes
Philippine law guarantees security of tenure. Employees may be dismissed only for a just or authorized cause and with due process (30-day written notice to both DOLE and affected employees for authorized causes; final pay/separation pay as applicable).
- Closure/cessation or reorganization (not due to serious losses) → separation pay of at least one (1) month pay or one-half (1/2) month pay per year of service, whichever is higher (a fraction of six months is rounded up to a whole year).
- Closure due to serious business losses → no separation pay required (but the employer bears a heavy proof burden).
- Redundancy or installation of labor-saving devices → separation pay of at least one (1) month pay or one (1) month pay per year of service, whichever is higher.
2) Non-Diminution of Benefits
Benefits that are established, consistent, and deliberate—whether by policy, practice, or contract—cannot be withdrawn or reduced unilaterally. This applies to both statutory and company-granted benefits. Harmonization after a merger is lawful only if:
- there is no diminution in aggregate; or
- changes are supported by valid consent, CBA negotiation, or lawful business necessity that does not impair vested rights (commonly achieved through “grandfathering” or red-circling).
3) Substitutionary/Successorship Doctrines
- Stock sale or merger: a mere change in corporate control does not sever employment; the employer remains and is bound by existing CBAs and policies until lawful modification or CBA expiry. Past liabilities generally stay with the original employer, but the surviving corporation in a merger typically assumes obligations by operation of corporate law.
- Asset sale: there is no duty for the buyer to absorb employees. The seller must pay separation benefits; the buyer may prefer former employees but may set fresh terms.
4) CBAs and Union Rights
A valid Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) binds the successor employer (in a stock sale or merger) until its expiration. The recognized bargaining unit and representation status persist. Any reduction of CBA benefits is invalid absent proper negotiation and ratification.
What “Benefits” Are We Talking About?
A. Statutory (Government-Mandated) Benefits
These must continue regardless of merger or acquisition:
- 13th-Month Pay (at least 1/12 of basic salary earned in a calendar year). In mid-year transitions, employers typically prorate based on months of service under each employer, ensuring the minimum is met for the full year.
- Service Incentive Leave (at least 5 days for eligible employees), overtime/night shift differentials, holiday pay, wage orders, minimum wage compliance.
- Social Insurance: SSS, PhilHealth, Pag-IBIG coverage and contributions must be continuous (with the correct employer ID updates).
- Maternity/Paternity/Parental Leaves, Solo Parent, VAWC, Magna Carta for Women, Expanded Maternity, Safe Spaces, Paternity, Calamity, Election, Special Leaves, etc., as applicable by law.
- Retirement Pay (RA 7641, as amended): minimum statutory retirement benefits apply if no better company plan exists; company plans that are more favorable must be honored under non-diminution.
B. Company-Granted (Contractual/Policy) Benefits
Examples: HMO coverage, supplemental life/accident insurance, allowances (rice, transportation, communications), variable pay/bonuses, stock options, leave credits above statutory minimums, flexible work arrangements, car plans, education subsidies, wellness budgets.
- In a merger/stock sale, these generally carry over; reducing them risks diminution or constructive dismissal claims.
- In an asset sale with re-hiring, the buyer may offer a different package; however, prior promises (e.g., vested stock options) remain a claim against the former employer, unless expressly assumed.
Deal Structure Determines Benefit Continuity
1) Merger (Surviving Corporation)
- The surviving corporation assumes assets and liabilities, typically including employment contracts.
- Employment continues; seniority and tenure are preserved.
- CBAs continue until expiry.
- Harmonization is permissible but not if it diminishes vested or regularized benefits. Use grandfathering: employees keep whichever is more favorable between legacy and new plans (or are “red-circled” at current levels with no decreases).
2) Stock (Share) Purchase
- The employer entity is unchanged; only ownership changes.
- All existing benefits and policies remain unless lawfully modified (e.g., through CBA negotiation or valid consent).
3) Asset Purchase / Business Transfer
The seller may lawfully close and terminate employees under authorized cause, with separation pay and notices.
The buyer may re-hire on new terms; old benefits need not carry over unless:
- the buyer assumes them in the asset purchase agreement;
- there is successor liability by law/fact; or
- the rehiring arrangement implies continuity (risking claims of single employer or subterfuge to defeat rights).
Specific Benefit Issues in M&A
Seniority, Tenure, and Rank
- Merger/stock sale: seniority and tenure should carry forward. Any demotion or material downgrade in grade/pay may be constructive dismissal.
- Asset sale: new employer may set fresh seniority systems, but avoid misrepresentations that imply continuity without honoring tenure.
Leave Balances
- Statutory SIL continues; above-minimum leave is subject to non-diminution in mergers/stock sales. Harmonize by carrying over or cashing out with employee consent.
- Sick/HMO waiting periods should not reset in a merger if continuity is represented.
Bonuses and Variable Pay
- Guaranteed or regularized bonuses (paid over time with clear patterns) are protected under non-diminution.
- Discretionary bonuses remain discretionary but cannot be withheld arbitrarily if they have matured under announced conditions.
- In transition years, use pro-rata rules and clear written cut-off dates.
Retirement Plans, ESOP, and Long-Term Incentives
- Statutory retirement cannot be reduced.
- Company retirement plans and ESOP/RSU vesting follow the plan rules. In mergers, common outcomes include assumption, tender for cash, or rollover. Vested interests are protected; unvested awards depend on plan terms and change-in-control provisions.
HMO/Insurance
- In a merger/stock sale, coverage continuity is expected; lapses or higher employee co-pays can be challenged as diminution if the prior benefit was definite and consistent.
- If changing providers, ensure no gap in coverage, honor pre-existing conditions, and communicate equivalent or better benefit ceilings.
Pay Harmonization
Allowed if overall package is equal or better. Typical tools:
- “No-loss” rule (no one gets less cash comp).
- Red-circling (freeze current above-range pay; no cuts).
- Grandfathering (preserve select legacy benefits for incumbents).
- Cash-out of legacy allowances with tax-aware structuring.
Work Location and Role Changes
- Transfers are part of management prerogative but must be reasonable, non-discriminatory, and not tantamount to demotion or diminution. Material adverse changes can constitute constructive dismissal.
Data Privacy and Records
- Employee data transfers must comply with the Data Privacy Act (lawful basis, data-sharing agreements, privacy notices, retention rules). Maintain integrity of SSS/PhilHealth/Pag-IBIG records and BIR registration updates (RDO, forms 1905/2316 continuity).
What Employers and HR Should Do (Compliance Playbook)
Map the Deal Type
- Merger/stock sale → plan for continuity of employment and benefits; prepare assumption of CBAs.
- Asset sale → plan authorized cause terminations, separation pay, and potential re-hire offers.
Audit All Benefits
- Statutory vs. company-granted; identify regularized benefits.
- Flag anything at risk of non-diminution.
Design a Harmonization Package (for mergers/stock sales)
- Use grandfathering/red-circling; match or exceed legacy benefits.
- Document equivalency matrices (e.g., HMO limits, leaves, allowances).
Manage CBAs and Union Relations
- Confirm automatic assumption until expiry.
- Open lawful renegotiations only within allowed windows.
Observe Due Process
- For any separations: 30-day notices to DOLE and employees; compute separation pay correctly; issue COE and final pay within statutory timelines; pay pro-rated 13th-month and unused leave encashment per policy/law.
Protect Pay Continuity
- Ensure no payroll gaps, correct withholding tax, and continuous government remittances under the correct registration.
Communicate Early and Clearly
- Written FAQs explaining what changes, what doesn’t, and effective dates.
- Individual benefit comparison letters for incumbents.
What Employees Should Watch
- Deal structure: Ask if it’s a merger/stock sale (benefits should continue) or asset sale (new terms likely).
- Your package: Compare pre- and post-deal benefits; keep payslips, policies, HMO certificates, bonus memos.
- CBA status: If unionized, confirm CBA carryover and consult your union.
- Separation pay: If you’re separated due to closure/redundancy, check the formula and notice.
- Constructive dismissal: Material downgrades in pay, benefits, or rank without valid basis may be actionable.
- Government records: Verify SSS/PhilHealth/Pag-IBIG remittances and BIR 2316 at year-end.
- Data privacy: Review updated privacy notices and who holds your personnel file.
Illustrative Outcomes
Merger of A into B (surviving corp B): Employees of A become employees of B automatically; all regularized benefits and CBA continue. B may harmonize but cannot reduce established benefits without lawful basis—grandfather as needed.
100% Share Purchase of C by D: Employer remains C. Nothing changes by default; changes require valid processes (e.g., CBA bargaining, policy updates without diminution).
Asset Purchase of E’s business by F; E closes: E may terminate with separation pay and notices. F may hire anew with new benefit terms; prior E-only benefits do not automatically carry over unless assumed.
FAQs
1) “My HMO cap decreased after our merger. Is that legal?” If the change reduced an established benefit in a merger/stock sale, it risks violating non-diminution unless offset by equal or better benefits or validly agreed upon.
2) “Do I keep my seniority?” Yes, in a merger/stock deal. In an asset deal, a new employment relationship usually means seniority resets, unless expressly preserved.
3) “Who pays my 13th-month if the merger occurred in July?” You must receive at least the statutory minimum for the full calendar year; employers often prorate based on service months before and after the effective date.
4) “Our CBA was due to expire next year. Does it still bind the buyer?” Yes, in a merger/stock sale, the successor is typically bound until expiry.
5) “Can the buyer refuse to hire us in an asset sale?” Yes. However, the seller must comply with separation pay and notice rules; the buyer may prefer affected employees but is not required to absorb them.
Practical Checklists
For Employers (M&A Team and HR)
- Determine deal type (merger/stock vs. asset).
- Inventory all benefits; flag regularized ones.
- Draft harmonization with no-loss rules.
- Confirm DOLE notices, separation pay where applicable.
- Ensure CBA assumption and union engagement.
- Secure data sharing agreements and privacy notices.
- Align payroll/BIR/SSS/PhilHealth/Pag-IBIG registrations.
For Employees
- Get written benefit comparison pre- and post-deal.
- Keep copies of policies, handbooks, and HMO cards.
- Verify final pay items (separation/encashments) if separated.
- Track seniority and grade continuity (if merged/stock deal).
- Review new contracts carefully (if asset deal re-hire).
Bottom Line
- In mergers and stock acquisitions, continuity is the rule: same employer (or legally substituted one), same benefits (at least no diminution), same CBA until expiry.
- In asset deals, employment may end with separation pay, and any subsequent re-hire is on new terms unless benefits are expressly assumed.
When in doubt, examine (1) the transaction structure, (2) your CBA/contract/policies, and (3) whether the change reduces an established benefit—that’s where Philippine law draws the line.