Introduction
Yes. In the Philippine context, an employee may generally claim SSS Unemployment Benefit even after receiving separation pay, provided that the employee meets the eligibility requirements under the Social Security System rules.
Separation pay and SSS unemployment benefit are not the same. They come from different legal sources, are paid by different entities, and serve different purposes. Separation pay is usually paid by the employer under the Labor Code or by agreement, while SSS unemployment benefit is paid by the Social Security System as a form of social insurance.
Receiving one does not automatically disqualify a worker from receiving the other.
What Is SSS Unemployment Benefit?
The SSS Unemployment Benefit, also known as unemployment insurance or involuntary separation benefit, is a cash benefit granted to covered SSS members who become unemployed due to involuntary separation.
It was introduced under the Social Security Act of 2018, also known as Republic Act No. 11199.
The benefit is meant to provide temporary financial assistance to workers who lose their jobs through no fault of their own.
It is not a loan. It does not have to be repaid.
What Is Separation Pay?
Separation pay is an amount paid by an employer to an employee whose employment is terminated under certain legally recognized circumstances.
Under the Philippine Labor Code, separation pay is commonly due when employment is terminated because of authorized causes, such as:
- Installation of labor-saving devices;
- Redundancy;
- Retrenchment to prevent losses;
- Closure or cessation of business not due to serious business losses;
- Disease, when continued employment is prohibited by law or prejudicial to the health of the employee or co-workers.
Separation pay may also be granted under:
- Company policy;
- Employment contract;
- Collective bargaining agreement;
- Settlement agreement;
- Court or labor tribunal decision;
- Voluntary company practice.
Separation pay is paid by the employer. SSS unemployment benefit is paid by SSS.
Main Rule: Separation Pay Does Not Bar SSS Unemployment Benefit
An employee who receives separation pay may still claim SSS unemployment benefit if the separation was involuntary and the employee satisfies the SSS requirements.
The reason is simple: the two benefits are legally distinct.
Separation pay is an employer obligation arising from labor law, contract, company policy, or equity. SSS unemployment benefit is a statutory social security benefit funded by the SSS system.
There is no general rule that says a worker must choose between separation pay and SSS unemployment benefit.
Legal Basis
The legal basis for SSS unemployment benefit is Republic Act No. 11199, or the Social Security Act of 2018.
Under this law, unemployment benefit is available to a covered employee, including kasambahay and overseas Filipino worker members where applicable, who is involuntarily separated from employment, subject to the conditions imposed by SSS.
The benefit is generally equivalent to 50% of the member’s average monthly salary credit, payable for a maximum period of two months.
Who May Claim SSS Unemployment Benefit?
A claimant must generally satisfy the following:
- The claimant must be a covered SSS member;
- The claimant must not be over the prescribed age limit;
- The claimant must have paid the required number of monthly contributions;
- The separation from employment must be involuntary;
- The claimant must not have been dismissed for just cause;
- The claimant must file within the prescribed period;
- The claimant must not have already received the benefit too recently, since the law limits how often it may be claimed.
Age Requirement
The employee must generally be not over 60 years old at the time of involuntary separation.
However, different age limits apply to certain workers:
For underground mineworkers, the age limit is generally not over 50 years old.
For racehorse jockeys, the age limit is generally not over 55 years old.
The age requirement matters because SSS unemployment benefit is intended for workers who are still within the employable age range but have lost employment involuntarily.
Contribution Requirement
To qualify, the member must have paid at least 36 monthly contributions, of which at least 12 monthly contributions must have been paid within the 18-month period immediately preceding the month of involuntary separation.
This requirement is important. Even if the employee was validly retrenched, made redundant, or separated because of closure, the claim may still be denied if the member lacks the required SSS contributions.
What Counts as Involuntary Separation?
The benefit applies only when the employee lost employment involuntarily.
Common qualifying grounds include:
- Redundancy;
- Retrenchment or downsizing;
- Closure or cessation of business;
- Installation of labor-saving devices;
- Disease, when continued employment is prohibited by law or prejudicial to health;
- Other authorized causes under labor law;
- Economic downturn;
- Natural calamity or disaster affecting business operations;
- Reorganization resulting in abolition of position, if genuinely involuntary;
- Other situations where the employee did not voluntarily resign and was not dismissed for misconduct or other just cause.
The key idea is that the employee lost the job through circumstances not attributable to the employee’s own fault.
What Separations Usually Do Not Qualify?
SSS unemployment benefit generally does not apply when the employee’s separation is due to:
- Voluntary resignation;
- Retirement;
- End of a fixed-term contract, depending on the circumstances;
- Dismissal for serious misconduct;
- Willful disobedience of lawful orders;
- Gross and habitual neglect of duties;
- Fraud or willful breach of trust;
- Commission of a crime or offense against the employer, employer’s family, or duly authorized representative;
- Other analogous just causes under the Labor Code.
A worker dismissed for just cause is generally not entitled to SSS unemployment benefit because the unemployment is considered attributable to the employee’s own act or fault.
Separation Pay and Authorized Causes
The strongest overlap between separation pay and SSS unemployment benefit occurs in authorized-cause termination.
For example, an employee terminated due to redundancy may receive separation pay from the employer and may also qualify for SSS unemployment benefit.
The same is true for many retrenchment and closure situations, assuming all SSS requirements are met.
Redundancy
If a position becomes unnecessary because of business restructuring, automation, merger of functions, or other legitimate business reasons, the employee may be terminated for redundancy.
In such a case, the employee is usually entitled to separation pay from the employer. Since redundancy is involuntary, the employee may also qualify for SSS unemployment benefit.
Retrenchment
Retrenchment is a cost-cutting measure used to prevent or minimize business losses.
An employee retrenched due to genuine financial difficulty may be entitled to separation pay. Because the loss of employment is involuntary, the employee may also claim SSS unemployment benefit, subject to SSS requirements.
Closure or Cessation of Business
If an employer closes the business, employees may be separated. If the closure is not due to serious business losses, separation pay is typically due. If closure causes involuntary unemployment, the employee may also qualify for SSS unemployment benefit.
Where closure is due to serious business losses, separation pay may not always be legally required under labor law. However, the absence of separation pay does not necessarily prevent an SSS unemployment claim, provided the SSS requirements are met.
Disease
If an employee is terminated because continued employment is prohibited by law or prejudicial to the health of the employee or co-workers, separation pay may be due. Since the termination is not the employee’s fault, SSS unemployment benefit may also be available.
Does Receiving Separation Pay Count as “Employment Income”?
No. Separation pay is not the same as continued employment income.
It is a payment arising from the end of employment. It does not necessarily mean the employee remains employed. Therefore, receipt of separation pay should not, by itself, defeat a claim for unemployment benefit.
The relevant question for SSS is not simply whether the employee received money from the employer. The relevant question is whether the employee was involuntarily separated and satisfies the statutory and documentary requirements.
Is There Double Recovery?
Ordinarily, claiming both separation pay and SSS unemployment benefit is not considered double recovery.
Double recovery usually refers to being compensated twice for the same legal obligation by the same party or for the same cause of action.
Here, the benefits are different:
| Item | Separation Pay | SSS Unemployment Benefit |
|---|---|---|
| Paid by | Employer | SSS |
| Legal source | Labor Code, contract, company policy, CBA, settlement, or judgment | Social Security Act |
| Purpose | Compensation for legally recognized termination or contractual entitlement | Temporary social insurance for involuntary unemployment |
| Based on | Length of service, salary, applicable termination ground, agreement, or policy | SSS contributions and average monthly salary credit |
| Repayable? | No, unless paid by mistake or subject to valid agreement | No |
Because the sources and purposes differ, the employee may receive both if legally qualified.
Can SSS Deny the Claim Because the Employer Already Paid Separation Pay?
SSS should not deny a claim solely because the employer paid separation pay.
However, SSS may deny the claim if:
- The separation was voluntary;
- The employee was dismissed for just cause;
- The member lacks the required contributions;
- The claim was filed late;
- The documents do not prove involuntary separation;
- The employee already claimed unemployment benefit within the restricted period;
- The claimant is beyond the applicable age limit;
- The supporting documents are inconsistent;
- The employer reported a different reason for separation;
- The claimant is not an eligible covered employee.
Thus, the issue is not the receipt of separation pay itself, but whether the separation and the member’s SSS record satisfy the rules.
How Much Is the SSS Unemployment Benefit?
The benefit is generally equivalent to 50% of the member’s average monthly salary credit, payable for a maximum of two months.
For example, if the member’s average monthly salary credit is ₱20,000, the benefit may be ₱10,000 per month for up to two months, or ₱20,000 total.
The actual amount depends on the member’s SSS contribution record and applicable salary credit.
How Often Can It Be Claimed?
SSS unemployment benefit is not a recurring monthly benefit that may be claimed every time a person is jobless.
It is subject to a frequency limitation. Generally, it may be claimed only once within a prescribed period, commonly understood as once every three years, subject to SSS rules.
This means that even if an employee is involuntarily separated more than once, the employee may not always be able to claim the benefit again immediately.
Filing Period
A claim for SSS unemployment benefit must be filed within the prescribed period from the date of involuntary separation.
In practice, claimants should file as soon as possible after separation because late filing may result in denial.
The date of separation should be consistent across the employer’s documents, Department of Labor and Employment certification, and SSS records.
Documentary Requirements
The claimant usually needs documents proving both identity and involuntary separation.
Common requirements include:
- Valid government-issued ID;
- SSS number and active My.SSS account access;
- Proof of involuntary separation;
- Employer’s termination notice or certificate of separation;
- DOLE certification or other recognized certification confirming involuntary separation;
- Supporting employment documents, if requested;
- Bank or disbursement account details enrolled with SSS.
The specific documentary process may vary depending on SSS implementation rules and the filing channel.
Role of DOLE Certification
A DOLE certification is commonly required to confirm the nature and date of involuntary separation.
This certification helps SSS determine whether the unemployment was due to an authorized or qualifying cause.
For local employees, the certification is usually secured from the appropriate DOLE office.
For overseas Filipino workers, the relevant certification process may involve Philippine Overseas Labor Offices, Department of Migrant Workers mechanisms, or other authorized offices, depending on the worker’s circumstances and current procedures.
What If the Employer Refuses to Issue Documents?
If the employer refuses to issue a certificate of separation or states the wrong cause of termination, the employee may still try to support the claim through other documents.
Possible supporting documents include:
- Notice of termination;
- Notice of retrenchment, redundancy, closure, or disease termination;
- Employment contract;
- Payslips;
- Company memorandum;
- Email or written communication confirming termination;
- Clearance documents;
- Final pay computation;
- Separation pay computation;
- DOLE filings or notices;
- Labor complaint documents, if any.
The employee may also seek assistance from DOLE if the employer refuses to provide necessary documentation or mischaracterizes the separation.
What If the Employee Signed a Quitclaim?
Signing a quitclaim does not automatically bar an SSS unemployment benefit claim.
A quitclaim usually settles claims between the employer and employee. SSS unemployment benefit is a statutory benefit from SSS, not a direct employer liability.
However, the contents of the quitclaim matter.
If the quitclaim states that the employee voluntarily resigned, but the actual facts show retrenchment or redundancy, this inconsistency may cause problems. SSS or DOLE may rely on the written documents submitted.
Employees should avoid signing documents that falsely describe the separation as voluntary resignation if the actual cause was redundancy, retrenchment, closure, or another involuntary ground.
What If the Separation Pay Was Given Under a Settlement?
A settlement payment does not automatically prevent an SSS unemployment claim.
The controlling question remains whether the employee was involuntarily separated.
However, if the settlement documents describe the separation as voluntary resignation or mutual separation, the SSS claim may become more difficult.
The safer approach is for the settlement agreement to clearly and truthfully state the nature of separation. If the employment ended because of redundancy, retrenchment, closure, or another authorized cause, the documents should say so.
What If the Employee Was Asked to Resign?
This is a common problem.
Some employers ask employees to submit a resignation letter even though the real reason is retrenchment, redundancy, or closure.
For SSS unemployment benefit purposes, a resignation letter may be treated as evidence of voluntary separation. This can lead to denial.
If the employee did not truly resign, the employee should avoid signing a resignation letter. Instead, the employee should request a termination notice stating the actual authorized cause.
If a resignation letter has already been signed under pressure, the employee may need to explain the circumstances and provide evidence that the separation was actually involuntary.
Constructive Dismissal and SSS Unemployment Benefit
Constructive dismissal occurs when an employee resigns because continued employment has become impossible, unreasonable, or unlikely, often due to the employer’s unlawful acts.
Whether constructive dismissal qualifies for SSS unemployment benefit can be more complicated than ordinary redundancy or closure.
On one hand, constructive dismissal is not truly voluntary. On the other hand, SSS may require clear proof that the separation was involuntary.
A final labor ruling, settlement, DOLE finding, or employer documentation confirming involuntary separation may help. Without such proof, the claim may be difficult.
Illegal Dismissal and SSS Unemployment Benefit
If an employee is illegally dismissed, the separation may be involuntary.
However, an SSS claim may still depend on available documentation and how the separation is classified.
If the employer claims the employee was dismissed for just cause, SSS may be reluctant to grant unemployment benefit unless there is evidence showing that the dismissal was not for a valid just cause.
If a labor tribunal later rules that the dismissal was illegal, the worker may have stronger grounds to argue that the separation was involuntary and not due to employee fault.
Fixed-Term, Project, and Seasonal Employees
The treatment of fixed-term, project, or seasonal employment can be fact-specific.
If the employment naturally ends because the agreed term, project, or season has ended, SSS may not always treat the separation as the kind of involuntary unemployment contemplated by the benefit.
However, if the worker is terminated before the end of the term, project, or season due to redundancy, retrenchment, closure, or other authorized cause, the claim may be stronger.
The documents should clearly state the reason for separation.
Probationary Employees
A probationary employee may qualify if involuntarily separated for a qualifying reason and if the contribution requirement is met.
However, if the probationary employee is dismissed for failure to meet reasonable standards made known at the time of engagement, the case may be treated as a valid employer-initiated termination but not necessarily as a qualifying involuntary separation for unemployment benefit purposes.
If the probationary employee is separated due to redundancy, closure, or retrenchment, the claim is stronger.
Resignation With Separation Pay
Sometimes an employee voluntarily resigns but still receives money labeled as “separation pay,” “financial assistance,” “ex gratia payment,” or “goodwill pay.”
In that situation, the employee may not qualify for SSS unemployment benefit because the separation was voluntary.
The label of the payment is not controlling. A voluntary resignation usually disqualifies the claimant, even if the employer gave a generous final payment.
Thus, the key question is not: “Did the employee receive separation pay?”
The key question is: “Was the employee involuntarily separated for a qualifying reason?”
Termination for Just Cause With Financial Assistance
An employee dismissed for just cause generally does not qualify for SSS unemployment benefit.
This remains true even if the employer gives financial assistance or a settlement amount.
For example, if an employee is dismissed for serious misconduct, fraud, or gross neglect of duty, the claim may be denied even if the employee receives some payment upon separation.
Again, the reason for unemployment matters more than the payment received.
Separation Pay in Lieu of Notice
Employers sometimes pay an amount in lieu of notice or as part of final pay. This does not necessarily disqualify the employee.
If the underlying separation is involuntary and qualifying, such as redundancy or retrenchment, the employee may still claim SSS unemployment benefit.
Final Pay vs. Separation Pay vs. SSS Unemployment Benefit
These three are often confused.
Final Pay
Final pay refers to amounts already earned by the employee, such as unpaid salary, prorated 13th month pay, unused leave conversions if applicable, commissions, and other earned benefits.
Separation Pay
Separation pay is compensation due because of termination under authorized causes or under contract, policy, settlement, or company practice.
SSS Unemployment Benefit
SSS unemployment benefit is a statutory cash benefit from SSS for qualified members who are involuntarily unemployed.
An employee may receive final pay, separation pay, and SSS unemployment benefit, provided the legal requirements for each are satisfied.
Tax Treatment
Separation pay may be tax-exempt in certain cases, especially when paid because of death, sickness, physical disability, or causes beyond the employee’s control, subject to tax rules and documentation.
SSS benefits are generally treated differently from ordinary compensation because they arise from social security law.
However, tax treatment can depend on the nature of the payment, documentation, and current tax regulations. Employees receiving substantial separation packages should review the tax treatment carefully.
Employer Obligations During Authorized-Cause Termination
For authorized-cause termination, employers generally must observe procedural due process.
This usually includes:
- Written notice to the employee;
- Written notice to DOLE;
- Observance of the required notice period;
- Payment of separation pay, when required;
- Payment of final pay;
- Issuance of employment documents, such as certificate of employment and separation-related documents.
Proper documentation helps the employee claim SSS unemployment benefit.
Practical Examples
Example 1: Redundancy With Separation Pay
Maria worked for a company for six years. Her position was abolished because her department was reorganized. She received separation pay.
She may still claim SSS unemployment benefit if she meets the age, contribution, filing, and documentary requirements.
Example 2: Retrenchment Due to Losses
Ben was retrenched because his employer suffered financial losses. He received separation pay.
He may claim SSS unemployment benefit because retrenchment is involuntary, assuming he has enough SSS contributions and files properly.
Example 3: Voluntary Resignation With Financial Assistance
Carla resigned to pursue another job. Her employer gave her financial assistance equivalent to one month’s pay.
She likely cannot claim SSS unemployment benefit because her separation was voluntary.
Example 4: Dismissal for Misconduct
Dan was dismissed for serious misconduct but received a settlement amount.
He likely cannot claim SSS unemployment benefit because dismissal for just cause is generally excluded.
Example 5: Closure of Business
Lina’s employer closed its branch and terminated all employees. She received separation pay.
She may claim SSS unemployment benefit if qualified.
Example 6: Forced Resignation
Ramon was told to resign or be removed because the company was downsizing. He signed a resignation letter but later received a redundancy computation.
His SSS claim may be complicated because the resignation letter suggests voluntary separation. He should gather documents proving that the true cause was redundancy.
Common Reasons Claims Are Denied
SSS unemployment claims may be denied for reasons such as:
- Insufficient SSS contributions;
- Voluntary resignation;
- Dismissal for just cause;
- Late filing;
- Missing DOLE certification;
- Inconsistent employer documents;
- Incorrect separation date;
- Employer reported resignation instead of redundancy or retrenchment;
- Claimant exceeded the age limit;
- Claimant already claimed the benefit within the restricted period.
How to Strengthen a Claim
A claimant who received separation pay and intends to claim SSS unemployment benefit should ensure that documents clearly show:
- The separation was involuntary;
- The reason was a qualifying cause;
- The date of separation is correct;
- The employer issued a proper notice or certificate;
- DOLE certification matches the employer’s documents;
- SSS contributions are sufficient;
- The claim is filed within the required period.
Consistency is critical. The termination notice, employer certificate, DOLE certification, final pay documents, and SSS application should not contradict each other.
Important Documents to Keep
Employees should keep copies of:
- Notice of termination;
- Certificate of employment;
- Certificate of separation, if issued;
- DOLE certification;
- Final pay computation;
- Separation pay computation;
- Payslips;
- SSS contribution records;
- Employer communications;
- Clearance documents;
- Quitclaim or release documents, if signed;
- Bank disbursement confirmation.
These documents may be useful not only for the SSS claim but also for labor, tax, and future employment purposes.
The Importance of the Stated Cause of Separation
The stated cause of separation is often decisive.
A worker who was actually retrenched should not allow the documents to say “resigned.” A worker whose position was abolished should not sign papers saying the separation was purely voluntary.
For SSS unemployment benefit, the documentary trail matters.
Even if the employee received separation pay, SSS will still look for proof that the unemployment was involuntary and covered by the law.
Can the Employer Oppose the SSS Claim?
The employer does not “pay” the SSS unemployment benefit directly. However, employer documents and reports can affect the claim.
If the employer reports the separation as voluntary resignation or just-cause dismissal, the claim may be denied or delayed.
If the employer truthfully reports redundancy, retrenchment, closure, or another authorized cause, the claim is more straightforward.
What If the Employer Misclassified the Separation?
If the employer misclassified the separation, the employee may consider:
- Requesting correction from the employer;
- Asking for an amended certificate of separation;
- Seeking DOLE assistance;
- Filing a labor complaint, if warranted;
- Submitting other documents showing the real cause of separation;
- Explaining the inconsistency to SSS or DOLE.
A misclassification can be serious because it may affect not only SSS unemployment benefit but also separation pay, final pay, tax treatment, and future employment records.
Does the Employee Need to Be Actively Looking for Work?
SSS unemployment benefit is intended for involuntarily unemployed workers. The law’s focus is on the fact of involuntary unemployment and the member’s contribution record.
Unlike some unemployment systems in other countries, the Philippine SSS unemployment benefit is limited in duration and amount. It is not a long-term unemployment allowance requiring continuous periodic proof of job search in the same way some foreign systems do.
Still, the claimant should ensure that all SSS filing requirements are satisfied.
Can OFWs Claim SSS Unemployment Benefit?
Covered SSS members who are overseas Filipino workers may be eligible if they satisfy the requirements and can prove involuntary separation.
However, the process and documentary certification may differ depending on whether the employment was local or overseas, and depending on the applicable government office handling certification.
The OFW must still meet contribution, age, filing, and involuntary separation requirements.
Can Kasambahays Claim?
Kasambahays who are covered SSS members may be eligible if they are involuntarily separated and satisfy the legal requirements.
As with other employees, the issue is whether the separation was involuntary and whether the member has the necessary contributions and documents.
Interaction With Other Benefits
SSS unemployment benefit may exist alongside other benefits, such as:
- Final pay;
- Separation pay;
- 13th month pay balance;
- Leave conversion, if applicable;
- Retirement benefits, where applicable;
- Company financial assistance;
- DOLE or government assistance programs, where available.
However, retirement and unemployment are different concepts. A person who retired may not be treated as involuntarily unemployed for purposes of the unemployment benefit.
What Employees Should Avoid
Employees should be careful about the following:
- Signing a resignation letter when the real cause is redundancy or retrenchment;
- Signing a quitclaim that falsely states voluntary resignation;
- Failing to secure copies of termination documents;
- Waiting too long before filing;
- Assuming separation pay automatically means SSS approval;
- Assuming SSS unemployment benefit is automatic;
- Ignoring contribution requirements;
- Failing to check employer-reported SSS records;
- Submitting inconsistent documents;
- Treating financial assistance as proof of involuntary separation when the documents say otherwise.
What Employers Should Do
Employers implementing authorized-cause termination should:
- State the true ground for termination;
- Issue proper written notices;
- Notify DOLE where required;
- Pay correct separation pay, if due;
- Release final pay in accordance with applicable rules;
- Provide accurate employment and separation documents;
- Avoid pressuring employees to sign resignation letters for employer convenience;
- Ensure consistency between company records, DOLE filings, and employee documents.
Accurate documentation protects both employer and employee.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Can I claim SSS unemployment benefit if I already received separation pay?
Yes, provided your separation was involuntary and you meet the SSS requirements.
2. Is separation pay deducted from SSS unemployment benefit?
Generally, no. Separation pay is paid by the employer, while SSS unemployment benefit is paid by SSS. They are separate benefits.
3. Can I claim if I resigned but received separation pay?
Usually no. Voluntary resignation generally disqualifies a claimant, even if the employer gave financial assistance or a payment called separation pay.
4. Can I claim if I was retrenched?
Yes, retrenchment is generally a qualifying involuntary separation, subject to SSS requirements.
5. Can I claim if I was declared redundant?
Yes, redundancy is generally a qualifying involuntary separation, subject to SSS requirements.
6. Can I claim if the company closed?
Yes, closure or cessation of business may qualify, provided the separation was involuntary and requirements are met.
7. Can I claim if I was dismissed for misconduct?
Generally no. Dismissal for just cause usually disqualifies the claimant.
8. Can I claim if I signed a quitclaim?
Possibly. A quitclaim does not automatically bar the claim, but if it states that you voluntarily resigned, it may make the claim difficult.
9. Can I claim if my employer refuses to issue a certificate?
You may still try to support the claim with other documents and seek DOLE assistance, but lack of employer documentation can delay or complicate the claim.
10. Can I claim if I was forced to resign?
Possibly, but the claim may be difficult if the documents show voluntary resignation. Evidence proving forced or involuntary separation will be important.
Key Legal Takeaway
Receiving separation pay does not, by itself, prevent an employee from claiming SSS unemployment benefit.
The decisive issues are:
- Whether the employee was involuntarily separated;
- Whether the reason for separation is a qualifying cause;
- Whether the employee has sufficient SSS contributions;
- Whether the employee meets the age and filing requirements;
- Whether the employee can submit proper supporting documents.
In Philippine labor practice, a worker who is terminated due to redundancy, retrenchment, closure, disease, or other qualifying authorized cause may receive separation pay from the employer and still claim SSS unemployment benefit from SSS.
The safest rule is this: separation pay answers the employer’s obligation; SSS unemployment benefit answers the worker’s social security protection. One does not automatically cancel the other.