Canceling Real Estate Purchase Contract and Transferring Payments in the Philippines

This article explains, in Philippine context, how cancellation works, what rights and liabilities attach to buyers and sellers, how “transfers of payments/rights” are done, and what to watch out for across subdivisions, condominiums, house-and-lot, and other residential transactions. It covers sales on installment, pre-selling, and already-titled properties.

1) Key Legal Foundations (What governs your rights)

  1. Civil Code

    • Article 1191 (rescission for breach): A party may rescind a reciprocal obligation (e.g., seller’s duty to deliver title vs buyer’s duty to pay) when the other substantially breaches. Judicial action is the rule; extra-judicial rescission is allowed if expressly stipulated, but remains reviewable by courts.
    • Articles 1380–1385 (rescissible contracts) and 1390–1397 (voidable contracts): Distinct from Art. 1191 rescission. Use these only where their specific grounds apply (e.g., lesion, intimidation, mistake, incapacity).
    • Article 1482 (earnest money): Earnest money is part of the price and proof of contract perfection; option money is different (payment for the option, not part of price unless stipulated).

  2. Real Estate Sales on Installment (Residential) — “Maceda Law” (RA 6552)

    • Applies to residential real estate sold on installments (subdivision lots, condos, house-and-lot). Generally not for industrial/commercial sales or rent-to-own unless structured as installment sale of residential realty.

    • Core protections:

      • If you’ve paid less than 2 years of installments: at least 60-day grace period to pay unpaid installments; if still unpaid, cancellation only after a 30-day notarized notice of cancellation is received.

      • If you’ve paid at least 2 years:

        • Grace period: 1 month per year of installments paid (to pay due installments without interest).
        • Cash Surrender Value (CSV): ≥50% of total payments made plus 5% of total payments per additional year after the second, capped at 90%.
        • Cancellation takes effect only after (a) buyer receives a notarized notice of cancellation and (b) the CSV has been paid.

      • CSV is computed on all payments actually made (down payment + installments + amortizations), excluding some charges (e.g., penalties, delinquency interest), unless the contract states otherwise and is consistent with law.

  3. Subdivision and Condominium Projects — PD 957 and related rules

    • Covers developers and brokers of subdivision lots and condo units. It mandates disclosures, licenses to sell, and developer obligations.
    • Buyers have remedies for non-development, misrepresentation, or violations of approved plans/permits. Administrative jurisdiction lies with DHSUD (formerly HLURB) and adjudication with HSAC.

  4. Financing overlays

    • Pag-IBIG/HDMF, banks, and in-house financing each impose additional contractual steps (assumption approvals, take-out conditions, cancellation fees).

2) “Cancellation,” “Rescission,” and “Forfeiture”: Don’t confuse them

  • Cancellation in developer forms typically means seller’s extra-judicial termination for buyer default under a cancellation clause. Where Maceda Law applies, cancellation cannot take effect unless its notarial notice and CSV requirements (if 2+ years paid) are met.
  • Rescission under Art. 1191 is a remedy for substantial breach by the other party (e.g., seller fails to deliver/construct). It typically requires court action unless a valid extra-judicial rescission clause exists.
  • Forfeiture of payments (down payment/earnest/instalments) is constrained by RA 6552 and by rules on penalties/liquidated damages (they must be reasonable; courts may reduce iniquitous penalties).

3) When can the buyer cancel (walk away) and recover money?

  1. Sales on installment (residential)

    • Less than 2 years paid: You can stop, but do not expect a refund. You get a 60-day grace period to pay; after that, the seller may cancel after sending a notarized 30-day notice. Contracts often forfeit prior payments at this stage.

    • 2 years or more paid: You may cancel and claim CSV. The seller must:

      1. Grant the grace period (1 month per year paid) if you want to cure, and
      2. If you elect to cancel or remain in default after grace, send notarized 30-day notice, and
      3. Pay you the CSV (≥50% of total payments + 5% per additional year up to 90%). Cancellation is ineffective until CSV is paid.

  2. Seller breach (any structure: cash or installment)

    • If the seller substantially breaches (e.g., fails to deliver the unit or title, egregious delays, non-development), the buyer may seek rescission with damages or specific performance. Evidence matters: timelines, permits, promised specs, correspondence.

  3. Misrepresentation or legal defects

    • Fraud, mistake, lack of permits, or illegal terms can justify voiding/annulling depending on facts.

4) When can the seller/developer cancel and keep payments?

  • Only per contract and law. For residential installment sales, the seller must strictly follow RA 6552 notice and CSV steps.
  • Liquidated damages/penalties must be reasonable; courts can reduce excessive forfeitures.
  • PD 957 exposure: If the developer is non-compliant (licenses, development), cancellation attempts can be struck down and developer may be ordered to refund or pay damages.

5) Step-by-Step: Buyer-initiated cancellation (installment, residential)

  1. Pull the paperwork: Contract to Sell/Reservation Agreement, Official Receipts, SOA, Developer correspondence, financing approvals.

  2. Compute your standing: Total months/years paid; determine whether RA 6552 tier (<2 data-preserve-html-node="true" yrs vs ≥2 yrs) applies; identify penalties charged.

  3. Choose your path:

    • Cure within grace period; or
    • Cancel and claim CSV (if ≥2 yrs), or
    • Rescind for seller breach (build evidence).

  4. Send a formal notice: A written demand stating your chosen remedy. For rescission, cite Art. 1191 grounds. For CSV, cite RA 6552 and request payment of CSV.

  5. Receive/serve notarized instruments:

    • Seller’s notarized notice of cancellation (if they cancel), or
    • Your notarized cancellation/rescission notice (good practice), and
    • If CSV applies, insist that CSV be paid as a condition to effective cancellation.

  6. Handover & releases: Turn over unit/keys (if any), sign Quitclaim/Release only after CSV is computed and tendered (or escrowed).

  7. Escalation: If refused, file with HSAC (administrative adjudication) or court (for Art. 1191 rescission/damages).

6) Computing the Cash Surrender Value (CSV) under RA 6552

  • Total payments made = Down payment + all monthly installments actually paid + any lump sums (usually excluding delinquency interest/penalties/processing fees).
  • Base CSV = 50% of total payments.
  • Add-on = 5% of total payments for each full year after the 2nd year, capped so that CSV ≤ 90% of total payments.

Example (illustrative):

  • Total paid over 5 years: ₱1,000,000
  • Base CSV: 50% = ₱500,000
  • Add-on years after 2nd: 3 years × 5% = 15% → ₱150,000
  • CSV = ₱650,000 (still ≤ 90%, so allowed)

Tip: Demand a written breakdown and verify each receipt. Query any deduction for penalties or “admin fees” that reduces CSV below statutory minimums.

7) Transferring Payments / Assigning the Contract (substituting buyers)

This is common when the original buyer wants out but prefers to transfer rights (and the value of payments already made) to a new buyer instead of canceling.

7.1 What “transfer” usually means

  • Before title is issued (pre-selling/CTS stage): The original buyer (“Assignor”) executes a Deed of Assignment of Rights in favor of the new buyer (“Assignee”), with developer’s consent. The developer cancels the old Contract to Sell (CTS) and issues a new CTS to the Assignee, crediting prior payments (sometimes less transfer/admin fees).

  • After title is issued (TCT/CCT already in buyer’s name): It’s a regular sale via Deed of Absolute Sale (DOAS). Taxes/fees shift to the typical conveyance regime (see 7.4).

  • If property is mortgaged (bank or Pag-IBIG): The transfer becomes an Assumption of Loan/Mortgage or Loan Take-Out/TIE-in by the Assignee, subject to lender’s credit approval.

7.2 Typical documents

  • Deed of Assignment of Rights (or Deed of Transfer and Assumption)
  • Deed of Cancellation among Assignor–Developer (to cancel the old CTS)
  • Developer’s Consent and New CTS with the Assignee
  • Statement of Account and Payment Ledger (showing credited payments)
  • Waiver/Quitclaim by Assignor upon full settlement
  • If financed: Bank/Pag-IBIG forms for assumption and consent of mortgagee

7.3 Fees & charges commonly encountered

  • Transfer/Assignment fee (developer admin charge)
  • Documentation/notarial fees
  • Processing fee for re-issuance of CTS and buyer records
  • If financed: lender assumption fee and updated MRI/FCI premiums

Practice point: Ask the developer for written policy on transfer fees and the cut-off after which transfer is disallowed or heavily penalized (some restrict near turn-over).

7.4 Taxes and costs (overview)

  • At CTS/assignment stage (pre-title): Developers typically handle VAT (if applicable) on the primary sale; a buyer-to-buyer assignment may or may not trigger income/CGT/CWT/DST depending on whether the Assignor is a dealer and the structure of consideration. Many assignments are processed as administrative transfers with fees, while the developer continues the original tax posture. Obtain a written tax treatment from the developer or a tax opinion if the Assignor gains.

  • At deed of sale stage (titled property):

    • Capital Gains Tax (CGT) (or Creditable Withholding Tax if seller is a corporation/dealer)
    • Documentary Stamp Tax (DST)
    • Local transfer tax and registration fees
    • Unpaid real property tax/Association dues (pro-rated at closing)

7.5 Practical sequence for a smooth transfer

  1. Check the CTS for assignment clauses, fees, and consent requirements.
  2. Collect the ledger and official receipts (amount to be credited).
  3. Agree on consideration between Assignor and Assignee (how much the Assignee pays the Assignor for the equity already paid).
  4. Secure developer consent in writing; book a schedule for documentation.
  5. Process lender consent if a loan is involved (assumption underwriting).
  6. Sign and notarize the Deed of Assignment, Cancellation, and New CTS.
  7. Update records (billing address, SOA, tax IDs). Keep certified copies.

8) Special scenarios & pitfalls

  • Reservation Agreement vs CTS: Reservation fees are often non-refundable if no CTS follows, unless covered by a promo or specific clause. Once a CTS exists and installments begin, RA 6552 may apply.
  • “No-refund” clauses: Not enforceable to the extent they contravene RA 6552 or constitute unconscionable penalties.
  • Late delivery/turn-over: Check for liquidated damages clauses; buyers may pursue Art. 1191 rescission or damages for delay.
  • Developer default (permits, amenities): PD 957 liabilities and administrative sanctions can support refunds and rescission.
  • Notarial notice strictness: For installment cancellations, the notarized 30-day notice is substantive; defects can invalidate cancellation.
  • CSV timing: Insist that CSV is paid (or placed in escrow) before effectivity of cancellation (≥2-year tier).
  • Association dues/real property taxes: Clarify cut-off liabilities at cancellation/transfer.
  • Data/privacy: Ensure buyer records are properly updated; avoid sharing IDs/receipts without consent.

9) Seller-side checklist (developers/owners)

  • Verify applicable regime (RA 6552 vs not)
  • Send notarized demand and observe grace periods
  • Compute CSV accurately where applicable; tender payment prior to effectivity of cancellation
  • Document turnover/possession, meter readings, keys
  • Use escrow where there’s a dispute over CSV or damages
  • For assignments, keep a standard policy on fees, cut-offs, and documentary requirements

10) Buyer-side checklist (quick reference)

  • Gather CTS, receipts, SOA, communications
  • Determine years paid and CSV eligibility
  • Decide: cure, cancel (CSV), or rescind for breach
  • Prepare formal demand/notice (and request for CSV, if any)
  • Insist on notarial 30-day notice and CSV tender before cancellation
  • For transfer: obtain developer & lender consent, compute fees, execute assignment
  • Keep certified copies of all notarized documents and proof of receipt

11) Sample clauses/snippets (for guidance; tailor to your facts)

Buyer’s CSV demand (installment ≥2 years):

“Pursuant to RA 6552, I elect to cancel my purchase and demand payment of my cash surrender value equal to not less than 50% of my total payments plus 5% per year after the second year, not exceeding 90%. Kindly provide your computation and arrange payment prior to cancellation effectivity, together with your notarized notice of cancellation.”

Developer’s notarial cancellation (installment <2 data-preserve-html-node="true" years):

“This notarized notice gives you 60 days to cure your default. If unpaid, the sale will be cancelled 30 days from your receipt of this notice, consistent with the contract and applicable law.”

Assignment consent:

“The Developer hereby consents to the assignment by [Assignor] in favor of [Assignee] and undertakes to credit all payments recorded in the buyer’s ledger to the Assignee, subject to payment of standard transfer fees and execution of a new CTS.”

12) Frequently asked questions

Q: Can the seller cancel without going to court? A: If the contract allows extra-judicial cancellation and the seller complies with RA 6552 (if applicable) and other legal requirements, yes—subject to later judicial/administrative review if challenged.

Q: I paid 3 years of installments; can the seller forfeit everything? A: No. You’re generally entitled to CSV under RA 6552. Cancellation is ineffective until CSV is paid and notarial notice requirements are met.

Q: Can I transfer my payments to a friend buying the same unit? A: Typically yes, through a Deed of Assignment with developer consent, payment of transfer fees, and if applicable, loan assumption approval.

Q: Does the Maceda Law apply if I bought in cash? A: It specifically protects installment buyers. Cash purchases fall outside it, but you may rely on Civil Code remedies and PD 957 protections (for projects under its scope).

Q: Who resolves disputes quickly? A: HSAC handles many project/buyer disputes administratively; you may also sue in court for Art. 1191 rescission/damages.

13) Practical templates & schedules (quick math)

CSV quick formula (≥2 yrs): CSV = min[ 90%, 50% + 5% × (YearsPaid − 2) ] × (TotalPaymentsMade)

Grace period:

  • <2 data-preserve-html-node="true" yrs: 60 days
  • ≥2 yrs: 1 month × YearsPaid

14) Final notes

  • Always read the CTS and reservation agreement—they control many details subject to statutory protections.
  • For assignment/transfer, align developer consent, lender approvals, and tax posture before you exchange money.
  • If disputes arise on CSV computation, penalties, or delivery delays, consider escrow and seek professional review of figures and documents.

This article is informational and aims to help you navigate cancellation and transfers in Philippine real estate transactions. Apply the rules to your specific facts and documents.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login