Collecting Payment Through Post‑Dated Checks (PDCs) in the Philippines
A comprehensive legal‑practical guide
1. What a Post‑Dated Check Is
A post‑dated check is a negotiable instrument dated later than the day it is actually issued. It is payable on demand only on or after the future date indicated. Until that date it functions as a promissory note—evidence of a promise to pay—but it retains the formal requisites of a check under the Negotiable Instruments Law (NIL, Act No. 2031):
- Written and signed by the drawer.
- Contains an unconditional order to pay a sum certain in money.
- Payable on demand (although the post‑dated maturity tempers presentment).
- Drawn on a bank.
- Payable to order or bearer.
2. Governing Statutes & Regulations
Area | Key Authority | Core Rule |
---|---|---|
Negotiability, presentment, notice of dishonor | NIL (1909) | Applies to checks, including PDCs, unless special law overrides. |
Criminal liability for bounced checks | Batas Pambansa Blg. 22 (BP 22, 1979) | Makes it malum prohibitum to issue a check that is dishonored for lack of funds or credit. |
Estafa by issuance of post‑dated or worthless checks | Art. 315 ¶ 2(d), Revised Penal Code (RPC) | Requires deceit and damage; malum in se. |
Clearing & settlement | Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP) Circular Nos. 681, 681‑A, CICS Procedural Manual & PCHC rules | One‑day electronic check clearing (Check Image Clearing System). |
Consumer redress, small claims | A.M. No. 08‑8‑7‑SC (as amended) | Allows collection of up to ₱1 million via summary small‑claims procedure. |
Anti‑Money‑Laundering & KYC | RA 9160, as amended; BSP Circular 706 | Imposes thresholds and reporting duties on banks when accepting large PDCs. |
3. Lifecycle of a Post‑Dated Check
Issuance & Acceptance
- Parties may treat the PDC as partial security or as actual payment deferred until maturity.
- Best practice: obtain an acknowledgment receipt stating that failure of the check will revive the underlying obligation.
Safekeeping Pre‑Maturity
- The payee/holder should endorse “For deposit on ___” and keep the check in a fireproof location or banking facility’s PDC warehousing service.
Deposit & Presentment (Maturity Day)
- Under Sec. 75 NIL, presentment must be “within a reasonable time”; banking custom deems 30 days reasonable for checks.
- With CICS, clearing is completed T + 1 banking day; the drawee bank may mark DAIF, DAUD, Closed Account, etc.
Dishonor & Notice
- The bank electronically returns the image with the appropriate stamp.
- The holder should issue written notice of dishonor within 24 hours (practical, though NIL allows up to the next business day) to preserve recourse against indorsers.
4. Remedies When a PDC Bounces
4.1 Civil Remedies
Remedy | Forum & Procedure | Prescription |
---|---|---|
Sum of money suit | Regular trial court (MTC up to ₱2 M; RTC above) following Rules of Civil Procedure. | 6 years from cause of action (Art. 1145 ¶ 1, Civil Code). |
Small Claims | MTC under A.M. No. 08‑8‑7‑SC (simplified, no lawyer required). | 6 years. |
Extra‑judicial demand / Notarial demand | Often precedes BP 22 filing; may interrupt prescription under Art. 1155. | N/A |
Tip: Always attach (a) original check, (b) bank return slip, and (c) notice of dishonor to any complaint.
4.2 Criminal Remedies
Statute | Elements | Key Points | Prescriptive Period |
---|---|---|---|
BP 22 | (1) Drawer makes/ issues check; (2) knowledge of insufficient funds/credit; (3) check dishonored; (4) notice of dishonor & failure to pay within 5 banking days. | No intent to defraud required; each check a separate offense; penalty: up to 1 yr or fine up to double the amount (or both). | 4 years (Art. 90 RPC). |
Estafa (RPC 315 ¶ 2(d)) | (1) Post‑dated check issued; (2) intent to defraud at time of issuance; (3) reliance & damage. | Requires proof of deceit; may coexist with BP 22 but double‑jeopardy principles require different elements. | 15 years (for estafa >₱1.2 M; otherwise 10 yrs presc.). |
Practical impact: Criminal filing exerts pressure; many settlements are reached before arraignment.
4.3 Banking Counter‑Remedies by Drawer
- Stop Payment Order (SPO). BSP allows SPO for lost/ stolen checks or presentment before agreed date. However, issuing an SPO on an account‑funds‑deficiency ground does not bar BP 22 prosecution.
- Verification of Indorsements. Drawer may contest forged endorsements; burden shifts to collecting bank.
5. Defenses Commonly Raised by the Drawer
- Full payment or novation after issuance.
- Lack of consideration (e.g., check issued only as guarantee). SC jurisprudence holds that absence of consideration is a personal defense ineffective against a holder in due course (Sec. 28 NIL) but good against payee if proved.
- Alteration or forgery of amount/date/signature.
- No notice of dishonor (relevant to civil recourse against indorsers).
- Violation of drawer’s constitutional right vs. imprisonment for debt. BP 22 penalties have been consistently upheld as punitive for the act of issuing a worthless check, not for non‑payment of debt.
6. Jurisprudential Highlights
Case | G.R. No. | Doctrine |
---|---|---|
Llamado v. CA (1995) | 111461 | BP 22 liability attaches even if checks were issued as guarantee; what the law punishes is the act of issuing a worthless check. |
Nierras v. Dacanay (2014) | 211224 | The five‑day grace to make good the check runs from actual receipt of written notice; verbal notice is insufficient. |
Pe v. People (2018) | 220855 | Failure of bank to stamp “Insufficient Funds” does not exonerate accused if prosecution proves the fact of insufficiency. |
Domagsang v. CA (2002) | 131646 | Civil action for sum of money may proceed independently of BP 22; acquittal does not bar recovery of civil liability unless expressly so declared. |
7. Practical Tips for Creditors
- Diligent KYC. Verify drawer identity, credit history, and bank of account.
- Staggered PDC schedules. Collect multiple smaller PDCs rather than a single large one to minimize risk.
- Time‑stamped receipt. Acknowledge each check with its serial number and amount.
- Calendaring system. Automate reminders 1–2 days before maturity.
- Early bank inquiry. Philippine banks allow Funds Inquiry one day before deposit; though non‑binding, it is an early warning.
- Preserve evidence. Keep original check, bank return slips, registered‑mail receipts of notices.
8. Best Practices for Drawers
- Maintain a checkbook register and reconcile weekly.
- Fund the account at least one banking day before maturity to account for memo‑item debits.
- Avoid issuing PDCs purely as security; instead execute a Deed of Assignment or Chattel Mortgage if collateral is intended.
- In case of unavoidable insufficiency, communicate early and offer alternative payment to mitigate criminal exposure.
9. Emerging Issues
- Electronic Checks & Digital Signatures. BSP’s pilot programs envision fully digital presentment; current laws on e‑commerce (RA 8792) will interplay with NIL principles.
- Check truncation & image clearing disputes. Forgery detection is now image‑based; jurisprudence is evolving on the evidentiary weight of “check images” versus originals.
- Rise of InstaPay/PESONet. Courts may in the future reassess whether civil/criminal sanctions for PDCs remain proportional given electronic alternatives.
10. Compliance Checklist (For Businesses)
- Standard credit application with PDC Agreement Clause.
- Board/partners’ resolution authorizing designated signatories.
- Secure storage (dual‑control vault) of PDCs.
- Regular audit of expiries (check becomes stale after 6 months; bank may refuse).
- Template demand letters for BP 22 and civil actions.
Conclusion & Disclaimer
Collecting through post‑dated checks remains widespread in Philippine commerce even as electronic payments gain ground. The legal framework intertwines negotiable‑instrument doctrine, criminal sanctions designed to protect the banking system, and civil recovery mechanisms that prioritize efficiency (e.g., small claims). Holders can maximize recovery by following strict procedural steps—timely presentment, documented notice, and properly chosen remedies—while drawers must manage cash flow meticulously to avoid both civil and criminal exposure.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Specific situations may require consultation with a Philippine attorney or compliance professional.