Deed of Sale Validity When Only a Decree of Registration Exists (No OCT) — Philippines

Big picture

In the Philippine Torrens system, a decree of registration is the final judgment of the land registration court confirming ownership over a parcel of land. After that decree becomes final, the Registry of Deeds (ROD) must issue an Original Certificate of Title (OCT) and deliver the owner’s duplicate to the adjudged owner.

A deed of sale is a private contract governed by the Civil Code. Its validity between the parties depends on consent, object, and cause—not on registration. But for registered land, dealings (sales, mortgages, etc.) bind third persons only upon registration in the ROD, which requires production of the owner’s duplicate certificate.

So when the seller only has a final decree and there is no OCT/owner’s duplicate yet:

The sale can still be valid between seller and buyer if the Civil Code requirements are met.
The buyer cannot register the transfer (and therefore cannot obtain a new title in their name) until an OCT is actually issued and its owner’s duplicate is presented.
Until registration, the buyer is vulnerable to competing claims (e.g., double sale) and lacks the full protection of the Torrens system.

The rest of this article unpacks the doctrine, requirements, risks, and practical steps.

Key legal frameworks

1) Civil Code (contracts and formalities)

Nature of sale: The sale is consensual; it is perfected by the meeting of minds on the object and price.
Form: For enforceability, a sale of real property must be in writing (Statute of Frauds). For registration and to affect third persons, it should be in a public instrument (notarized).
Effect between parties vs. third persons: Even an unregistered, notarized deed is binding between parties, but does not bind third persons without registration.

2) Property Registration Decree (PD 1529)

Decree of registration: A final judgment confirming title; after one year from entry (absent fraud petitions), the decree becomes indefeasible.
OCT issuance: The ROD has a ministerial duty to issue the OCT pursuant to the decree.
Operative act: For registered land, registration is the operative act that conveys or affects the land as to third persons.
Owner’s duplicate: Required for any voluntary dealing (sale, mortgage, lease annotation). No registration happens without it.

What the decree proves—and what it doesn’t

The decree proves: that the land has undergone original registration and that the adjudged owner has an indefeasible title (after lapse of the review period).
The decree does not by itself: (a) create or issue the OCT, (b) provide an owner’s duplicate, or (c) allow registration of a sale without first issuing the OCT. The decree is the basis; the OCT is the certificate evidencing title for dealings.

Is a deed of sale valid if only a decree exists?

Yes, between the parties. If the seller with a final decree executes a written (ideally notarized) deed of sale in favor of the buyer, the contract is valid and enforceable between them.

No, as to third persons—until registration. The buyer cannot (yet) obtain a transfer certificate of title (TCT) in their name because the ROD must first issue the OCT and release its owner’s duplicate. Only then can the buyer present that duplicate with the deed for registration, after which the ROD issues a TCT to the buyer.

What to call the instrument? Practically, lawyers often style the document as a “Deed of Absolute Sale and Assignment of Rights under Decree”, acknowledging that registration will follow after issuance of the OCT/owner’s duplicate. This avoids the appearance that the buyer is attempting to bypass the statutory sequence.

Practical implications and risks

1) Registration bottleneck

You cannot register the sale (or annotate it) without the owner’s duplicate. Until the OCT is issued and the duplicate exists, your deed sits off-title—binding only between you and the seller.

2) Exposure to double sale (Civil Code, Art. 1544)

If the land is registered: The buyer who first registers in good faith prevails.
If you cannot register because there’s no OCT yet, a later buyer who waits for the OCT and successfully registers first may defeat your unregistered purchase (assuming they acted in good faith).
If neither buyer registers, priority may hinge on possession; failing that, on dates of the deeds.

3) Tax and transfer processing

BIR CAR (Certificate Authorizing Registration), documentary stamp tax, capital gains tax, and local transfer tax are normally processed in tandem with title work. Without an OCT number, agencies may hold or sequence the processing pending issuance of the OCT, or require a particular workflow recognizing it as an initial issuance situation. Expect additional coordination and time.

4) Deal certainty

Because you cannot annotate your interest, consider escrow arrangements, holdbacks, or conditions precedent keyed to the OCT’s issuance to reduce risk.

Due diligence checklist (buyer and counsel)

Authenticate the decree
- Secure a certified true copy of the decree and the Entry of Judgment (or proof of finality).
- Confirm that the one-year indefeasibility period has lapsed or, if within one year, check for any pending petitions to review/annul for fraud.
Push issuance of the OCT
- Coordinate with the ROD and, where needed, the LRA for initial issuance.
- Ensure the approved survey plan, technical description, tax map declarations, and other documentary bases are complete.
Confirm there is no OCT already
- Sometimes an OCT exists but the owner’s duplicate is missing. If the owner’s duplicate is lost, the registered owner (or successor) must file a petition for issuance of a new owner’s duplicate (PD 1529, petition before the RTC). If the original in the ROD is missing but an OCT once existed, you are likely dealing with reconstitution issues (RA 26).
Establish an audit trail of ownership
- Decree holder’s identity, tax declarations (even for registered land, they’re useful corroboration), tax receipts, and possession.
- Check for adverse claims, boundary disputes, public land overlaps, or ancestral domain concerns.
Structure the deed and closing mechanics
- Use a notarized deed with clear recitals: that an original decree exists, the case number, date of decree, and that parties agree to cause OCT issuance and register the transfer thereafter.
- Consider escrow: release a portion of the price only upon proof of OCT issuance and successful registration.
- Include specific undertakings by the seller to cooperate with OCT issuance and to produce the owner’s duplicate once issued.
Plan tax/fee sequencing
- Coordinate early with BIR and LGU on the documentary set they will accept at each stage for an initial issuance then transfer workflow.

Step-by-step pathway to a clean TCT in the buyer’s name

Close the sale (notarized deed; ideally with escrow/conditions).
Secure issuance of the OCT based on the decree (ROD/LRA processing).
Obtain the owner’s duplicate of the OCT once the ROD releases it.
Present the owner’s duplicate + deed of sale for registration (voluntary dealing).
Pay DST, CGT/Withholding, transfer tax, registration fees, and obtain BIR CAR as required by the local practice.
ROD cancels the OCT and issues a TCT in the buyer’s name, releasing the owner’s duplicate of the TCT to the buyer.

Common problem scenarios & remedies

A. OCT still not issued years after the decree

The duty to issue the OCT is ministerial. If the administrative follow-through stalls despite complete papers, consider a petition for mandamus to compel issuance.

B. Owner’s duplicate cannot be produced after OCT issuance

File a petition for issuance of a new owner’s duplicate (judicial proceeding). This is distinct from reconstitution and is focused on replacing the duplicate, not the original.

C. Original OCT/TCT destroyed or missing at the ROD

That triggers reconstitution under RA 26 (administrative or judicial, depending on circumstances). After reconstitution, you can proceed to register the sale.

D. Double sale risk while waiting for OCT

Mitigate with possession, annotation of adverse claim (once OCT issues), escrow, and warranties with penalties for the seller. If the OCT is issued and someone else tries to register first, your protection depends on your ability to register ahead and on good faith.

Drafting tips for the deed (when only a decree exists)

Title: “Deed of Absolute Sale and Assignment of Rights under Final Decree of Registration”
Recitals: Identify the Land Reg. Case No., LRC/GLRO Record, date of decree, and finality.
Undertakings:
- Seller to cause issuance of the OCT and to deliver the owner’s duplicate promptly upon release.
- Parties to cooperate in tax clearances, BIR CAR, and ROD processes.
- Seller’s warranties: title free from liens, no other sales, no pending petitions to annul the decree.
Conditions: Optionally, make part of the price conditional on OCT issuance and registration in buyer’s name.
Attachments: Certified copy of decree, plan and technical description, IDs, tax docs, authority of signatories.

FAQs

Q: Can I annotate my deed on the title while there’s still no OCT? A: No. There’s no certificate yet to annotate. You need the OCT and its owner’s duplicate first.

Q: If my deed is notarized, am I protected? A: Notarization helps with enforceability and allows registration, but until you actually register, your deed does not constitute constructive notice to third persons.

Q: Is the decree enough proof of ownership to sell? A: For contracting between you and the seller, yes—especially after finality/indefeasibility. For public notice and priority, you still need OCT issuance and registration of your purchase.

Q: What if a different buyer registers first after the OCT is issued? A: In a contest between buyers of registered land, the one who first registers in good faith generally prevails. This is why you should push OCT issuance and register immediately.

Takeaways

A sale based solely on a decree (no OCT yet) is legally possible and binding between the parties, but not opposable to third persons until the transfer is registered.
The decisive practical step is to expedite OCT issuance and then register the deed so a TCT issues in the buyer’s name.
Use escrow, warranties, and conditions precedent to manage risk while the OCT is pending.
If administrative steps stall, consider mandamus (for OCT issuance) or the proper judicial remedies for missing certificates.

This framework should equip you to structure, document, and close a transaction safely when a decree exists but no OCT has yet been issued.