Entertainment Industry Legal and Ethical Issues: Common Malpractice Examples

Entertainment Industry Legal & Ethical Issues in the Philippines: Common Malpractice, Law, and Practical Fixes

This article maps the Philippine legal landscape for film, TV, music, live events, digital creators and talent managers. It is a general guide—not a substitute for tailored legal advice.


Executive takeaways

  • Most “industry problems” are just recurring patterns of IP misuse, bad contracts, labor violations, safety lapses, privacy/data breaches, defamation, misleading ads, or harassment/abuse—each already covered by existing Philippine laws.
  • Paperwork wins disputes: clean chain-of-title, written licenses/consents, clear employment status, OSHS compliance, and documented approvals are your first line of defense.
  • When in doubt, assume you need written consent (for copyrighted works, performances, likeness, personal data, minors, stunts, brand integrations) and permits (LGU, DOLE, MTRCB, etc.).
  • Build compliance into production (checklists, logs, training). It is cheaper than cure.

The legal framework (Philippine context)

Core sources

  • Civil Code (contracts, torts; abuse of rights; privacy and dignity provisions).

  • Revised Penal Code (e.g., libel, estafa, falsification).

  • Special statutes & regulators commonly engaged in entertainment:

    • Intellectual Property Code (R.A. 8293, as amended) – copyright, trademarks, related rights.
    • Data Privacy Act (R.A. 10173) – personal data handling; enforced by the National Privacy Commission (NPC).
    • Cybercrime Prevention Act (R.A. 10175) – cyber libel, unauthorized access, etc.
    • Anti-Photo and Video Voyeurism Act (R.A. 9995); Anti-OSAEC (R.A. 11930); Anti-Child Pornography Act (R.A. 9775).
    • Anti-Sexual Harassment Act (R.A. 7877) and Safe Spaces Act (R.A. 11313) – workplace and online harassment.
    • E-Commerce Act (R.A. 8792) – electronic transactions/evidence.
    • Anti-Wiretapping Act (R.A. 4200) – secret recordings.
    • Optical Media Act (R.A. 9239) and Anti-Camcording Act (R.A. 10088) – anti-piracy.
    • Consumer Act (R.A. 7394) – misleading/deceptive ads; product claims.
    • Philippine Competition Act (R.A. 10667) – anti-competitive conduct (exclusivity, foreclosure).
    • OSH Law (R.A. 11058) and DOLE OSHS – safety on sets/stages.
    • Child labor rules (R.A. 9231 amending R.A. 7610; DOLE permits for child performers).
  • Agencies & venues

    • IPOPHL (copyright/trademark enforcement; mediation).
    • MTRCB (content classification for TV and public exhibition of films).
    • FDCP (film incentives, locational permits coordination).
    • DOLE/NLRC (labor standards and disputes).
    • DTI (consumer protection; advertising).
    • NPC (data privacy).
    • OMB (optical media/piracy).
    • NTC (broadcast/telecom aspects).
    • LGUs/PNP/BFP (event permits, public safety).
    • BIR (taxes; withholding on talent/professional fees).
    • Bureau of Immigration / DOLE (AEP/SWP/visas for foreign artists).

Intellectual property & related rights

Typical malpractice patterns

  1. Uncleared music in screen content (sync use).

    • Looks like: Using popular songs in films, series, ads, vlogs without written licenses for the composition and sound recording, and without performance/public-communication clearances where applicable.
    • Risk: Injunctions, takedowns, damages, criminal liability for willful infringement.
    • Fix: Secure synchronization (composition), master (recording), and public performance licenses; keep a music cue sheet and license log.
  2. “Found on the internet” visuals, fonts, or stock without correct rights.

    • Fix: Maintain an asset register; keep invoices and license terms (scope, media, term, territory, exclusivity, derivative rights).
  3. Story rights and life rights not secured.

    • Fix: Obtain option/purchase agreements, life-story releases, and defamation/privacy waivers; fact-check to avoid false light and libel.
  4. Performer & producer related rights ignored (music and AV).

    • Fix: Written performer consents, model releases, and work-for-hire/assignment where valid; observe performers’ moral rights (attribution; integrity).
  5. Brand/trademark misuse (passing off, dilutive use).

    • Fix: Clear brand appearances; blur or obtain permission for centerpiece use; avoid implying endorsement if none exists.
  6. No chain-of-title for films/series.

    • Fix: Aggregate all assignments and licenses from authors (script, direction, music, artwork) and performers; keep notarized/witnessed copies; buy E&O insurance.

Practice checklist

  • Rights audit early in development; keep cue/asset sheets.
  • Written waivers/assignments for commissioned works (default rule: creators retain rights unless assigned; employer ownership may apply to works in the course of employment).
  • Distinguish economic rights (license/assign) from moral rights (need explicit waiver/consent for edits that prejudice honor/reputation).
  • For music: separate licenses for composition, recording, public performance, and mechanical uses where relevant.
  • Use collective management organizations for blanket performance rights when appropriate.

Content regulation, speech, and reputation

Defamation (including cyber libel)

  • Publishing imputations that injure reputation (even in shows, podcasts, social posts) can trigger criminal and civil actions.
  • Common malpractice: “Blind items,” mockumentaries portrayed as fact, or marketing copy that asserts unverified misconduct.
  • Fixes: Fact-checking, legal review, fair comment framing for opinion, corrections/updates policy, and E&O coverage.

Privacy, right to likeness, and publicity-style claims

  • Civil Code protects privacy, dignity, and against intrusion or public disclosure of private facts.
  • Common malpractice: Using a person’s face/voice in ads without consent; doxxing creators or fans.
  • Fix: Model/voice releases; avoid implying endorsements without a contract; minimize and secure personal data.

Voyeurism, intimate content, and minors

  • Criminal liability attaches to creating or sharing intimate images without consent, or any sexualized content involving minors (including deepfakes).
  • Fix: Strict consent protocols, age verification, and zero-tolerance moderation on productions and platforms.

Secret recordings

  • The Anti-Wiretapping Act generally prohibits recording private communications without consent.
  • Fix: Obtain recording consents on reality/behind-the-scenes shoots; conspicuous notices at venues; treat one-on-one calls as private unless clearly announced.

MTRCB classification & sensitive content

  • Films/TV for public exhibition require classification; content restrictions apply (e.g., explicit sex/violence may be disallowed for certain ratings).
  • Fix: Script vetting, advisory slates, and plan for edits to meet ratings.

Advertising & endorsements

  • Common malpractice: Misleading “before/after” claims; undisclosed paid endorsements; health claims without substantiation.
  • Fix: Substantiate claims; disclose material connections; align with self-regulatory ad standards; keep copy approval trails.

Labor, talent management, and workplace safety

Misclassification: employee vs. independent contractor

  • Pattern: Treating regular crew as “talents” to avoid benefits, or imposing employee-like control while issuing pro-forms.
  • Risk: Back wages, benefits (13th month, SSS/PhilHealth/Pag-IBIG), penalties; NLRC cases.
  • Fix: Align actual control and integration with the contract label; use true project-based agreements where appropriate; enroll statutory benefits for employees.

Pay, hours, and overtime

  • Pattern: Unpaid overtime or “all-in” rates without clear breakdowns.
  • Fix: Timekeeping; overtime approvals; night differential/holiday pay compliance.

Safety on sets and stages (OSH)

  • Pattern: Stunts without risk assessments; electrocution/fire at venues; fatigue-induced driving after shoots.
  • Fix: OSH plans, competent safety officers, toolbox talks, stunt/fight coordinators, medical standby, incident reporting.

Sexual harassment, bullying, discrimination

  • Pattern: “Open secret” quid pro quo for roles; hostile sets; misogynistic or SOGIE-based slurs.
  • Fix: Written anti-harassment policies, confidential reporting, impartial investigations, sanctions, and training—applies to cast, crew, and managers.

Child performers

  • Pattern: Children on set without DOLE permits, excessive hours, or unsafe scenes.
  • Fix: Secure DOLE permits, observe hour limits and schooling, guardian presence, dedicated welfare officer, and appropriate trust arrangements for earnings.

Foreign performers and crew

  • Pattern: Performing on tourist visas or without DOLE/immigration clearances.
  • Fix: Obtain AEP/SWP/appropriate visas, tax registrations, and local permits before publicity or ticket sales.

Contracts & commercial dealings

Recurring clauses that cause disputes

  • Vague scope/term/territory. Spell out platforms (FTA, cable, SVOD/AVOD/FAST, social), territories (PH/worldwide), languages, and term + renewals.
  • Overbroad “in perpetuity in all media now known or hereafter devised” without fair consideration. Negotiate reversion or MFN protection.
  • Morality clauses that are one-sided. Balance triggers (final judgment vs. mere allegation), cure windows, proportional remedies.
  • Ambiguous exclusivity/non-compete. Define category, geography, duration; carve-outs for prior obligations.
  • Royalty/recoupment math black boxes. Demand audit rights, transparent waterfall and caps on cross-collateralization.
  • No approvals matrix. Define what needs whose sign-off (scripts, edits, music, publicity, brand placements).
  • No force majeure/cancellation plan. Address pandemics, government bans, artist illness, and ticket refunds.
  • No dispute-resolution path. Choose venue/law; consider IPOPHL mediation for IP, or arbitration for multi-party co-prods.

Common malpractice examples (and fixes)

  • “Work-for-hire” labels used where law doesn’t recognize them. → Use express written assignment from authors.
  • Talent “exclusivity” that blocks livelihood with minimal pay. → Add guaranteed minimums, scope limits, and reasonable duration.
  • Hidden brand integrations.Contracted disclosures and ASC-compliant executions.
  • No image/likeness rights for poster/trailer/social.Explicit publicity rights clause covering stills/BTS/merch windows.

Finance & tax touchpoints

  • Withholding taxes often apply to talent/professional fees; determine VAT or percentage tax status; secure BIR-registered official receipts.
  • Foreign artists: tax treaty relief (if any) and final withholding considerations.
  • Local amusement taxes may apply to ticketed events depending on LGU ordinances.
  • Keep gross-to-net statements, escrow requirements (if any), and audit-ready books.

Digital, data, platforms & AI

Data Privacy Act compliance

  • Malpractice: Collecting fan or audience data (raffles, ticketing, newsletters, biometrics at backstage) without consent or safeguards; doxxing by team members.
  • Fix: Privacy notices, lawful basis (consent/contract), data minimization, security controls, vendor DPAs, breach response playbook; appoint a DPO when required.

Platforms and takedowns

  • Use documented takedown notices (copyright, impersonation, privacy). Keep an evidence pack: URLs, timestamps, rights docs, and correspondence.

Generative AI, deepfakes, voice cloning

  • Risks: Infringing training inputs; moral rights/integrity issues; passing off a person’s voice/likeness; deceptive ads.
  • Fix: Contractual consents for synthetic uses, watermarking/disclosures, and review for defamation/privacy. Avoid training on datasets you don’t have rights to.

Competition & trade practices

  • Exclusivity and block-booking between networks, venues, or ticketing that forecloses rivals can raise issues under the Philippine Competition Act.
  • No-poach arrangements among producers may be viewed as anti-competitive.
  • Fix: Conduct competition law review for long exclusivities, MFNs, or bundling; document pro-competitive justifications.

Events, venues, and permits

  • LGU permits, crowd control, noise curfews, and BFP fire safety clearances for concerts and festivals.
  • Insurance: public liability, weather, cancellation/non-appearance, and E&O.
  • Ticketing: transparent T&Cs, refund policies compliant with consumer law, accessible seats/refunds for material changes.

From malpractice to prevention: a production-ready toolkit

1) Pre-production

  • Rights clearance plan; chain-of-title file; music & image licensing grid.
  • Child-work, stunts, pyrotechnics and high-risk scenes flagged for permits and specialist coordinators.
  • Draft codes of conduct (anti-harassment, privacy), speak-up channels, and cast/crew onboarding.
  • Contracts with clear scope/term/territory, approvals matrix, deliverables, and payment calendars.

2) Production

  • Daily OSH checks, incident log, and rest rules.
  • Consent logs (appearance, recording, BTS, minors).
  • Asset log updates as creative choices change.

3) Post-production

  • Legal/standards review cut (defamation/privacy/ads).
  • Final music cue sheet, stock roll-ups, and E&O insurance certificate.
  • Data minimization (delete excess PII), archive policy.

4) Distribution & marketing

  • Platform/legal clearances, ratings compliance, ad disclosures, and takedown SOPs.
  • Territory windowing and geo-rights checks.

Red flags: quick spotter’s guide

  • “We’ll fix the paperwork later.”
  • “It’s fair use because we changed 10 seconds.” (No general 10-second rule.)
  • “Everyone here is a freelancer, but report to me 9–9.”
  • “We can’t disclose it’s an ad—it will perform worse.”
  • “Use that viral clip; the internet is public domain.”
  • “Child’s mom said it’s fine; no need for permits.”
  • “We didn’t test the rig, but we’re late—roll camera.”

Sample clause ideas (adapt to your contracts)

IP Warranty & Indemnity Producer warrants it owns or has secured all rights, licenses, waivers, and consents necessary for the Work as exploited in the Territory/Media/Term defined, and will indemnify and hold harmless the Distributor from third-party claims arising from breach of this warranty, subject to negotiated caps and procedures.

Publicity & Likeness Consent Talent grants Producer the right to use Talent’s name, image, likeness, and voice in connection with advertising and exploitation of the Work (including BTS and promotional materials) in the Territory for the Term, excluding uses that constitute commercial endorsement outside the Work unless separately agreed.

Morals Clause (balanced) Either Party may suspend or terminate if the other is convicted of, or admits to, a crime or conduct that results in material public scandal reasonably expected to cause significant reputational harm to the Work or counterparty; provided that mere allegations shall trigger good-faith consultation and a cure/suspension period.

Data Protection Each Party shall comply with the Data Privacy Act; process personal data only as necessary for the engagement; implement appropriate security measures; and execute data processing agreements with sub-processors.


Who handles what (rule-of-thumb routing)

  • IP infringement / piracy: IPOPHL (civil/admin), OMB (physical media), NBI/PNP (criminal), platform takedowns.
  • Defamation/privacy: civil courts; possible criminal complaints (libel/voicemail).
  • Labor/safety: DOLE inspections; NLRC for disputes.
  • Harassment: internal grievance + barangay/PNP complaint; DOLE for workplace policy enforcement.
  • Advertising disputes: DTI consumer protection; self-regulatory review.
  • Ratings/classification: MTRCB.
  • Data breaches: NPC notification (where thresholds are met).
  • Event permits: LGU, PNP, BFP; venue codes.

Frequently asked “is this legal?” (short answers)

  • Using 5–10 seconds of a song without permission? Usually not safe. Clear it.
  • Hidden paid endorsements by influencers? Risky. Disclose material connections.
  • Filming strangers in public for commercial ads? Safer with location notices plus model releases for identifiable featured individuals.
  • Recording a phone call for a documentary without telling the other party? Generally prohibited by anti-wiretapping laws.
  • Paying radio/playlist gatekeepers for spins (“payola”)? Risks breach of ethics, contract, fraud, and advertising rules—avoid.

Practical first steps if something has already gone wrong

  1. Stop the harm (pause distribution, pull ads, secure the set).
  2. Preserve evidence (footage, emails, contracts, call sheets).
  3. Map rights and exposures (who owns what; who approved what).
  4. Engage counsel early; consider without-prejudice discussions.
  5. Notify insurers (E&O, public liability), platforms, regulators as required.
  6. Remediate (retroactive licenses, corrections/apologies, make-good spots, safety retraining).
  7. Close the loop (update templates, checklists, and training so it doesn’t recur).

Closing note

The Philippines already has robust laws that, when operationalized through good paperwork, safe sets, respectful workplaces, and truthful marketing, cover most entertainment-industry risks. The malpractice you actually see tends to be process failure, not legal ambiguity. Build the process once—then keep rolling.

If you want, tell me what sector you’re in (film/TV, live events, music, streaming, influencer marketing) and I’ll tailor these checklists and sample clauses to your workflows.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.