Introduction
When an employee resigns, is retrenched, dismissed, or otherwise separated from employment, one of the most common disputes that follows is the non-release or delayed release of final pay. In the Philippines, final pay is not a mere courtesy from the employer. It represents amounts already earned by the employee or amounts required by law, contract, company policy, or applicable employment regulations.
Final pay may include unpaid salary, prorated 13th month pay, cash conversion of unused leave credits if convertible, separation pay when legally due, tax refunds or adjustments, commissions, incentives, and other monetary benefits. Among these, 13th month pay is one of the most important because it is a statutory benefit generally owed to rank-and-file employees.
This article discusses what final pay means, what 13th month pay covers, when these amounts should be released, what employers may and may not withhold, and what legal remedies are available to employees in the Philippine setting.
What Is Final Pay?
“Final pay” refers to the total amount of compensation and benefits owed to an employee after the employment relationship ends. It is sometimes called last pay, back pay, or clearance pay, although these terms are often used loosely.
Final pay may include:
- unpaid wages or salary up to the last day of work;
- prorated 13th month pay;
- cash equivalent of unused service incentive leave, if applicable;
- unused vacation or sick leave credits, if convertible under company policy, contract, or collective bargaining agreement;
- separation pay, if legally required;
- unpaid commissions, incentives, or bonuses that have already vested or become demandable;
- salary differentials, overtime pay, holiday pay, rest day pay, night shift differential, or premium pay, if unpaid;
- tax refunds or adjustments, if any;
- retirement benefits, if applicable; and
- other amounts due under law, contract, company practice, or company policy.
Final pay is different from separation pay. Final pay is the umbrella term for all amounts due upon separation. Separation pay is only one possible component of final pay and is not always required.
What Is 13th Month Pay?
13th month pay is a mandatory benefit under Philippine labor law. It is generally equivalent to one-twelfth of the basic salary earned by a covered employee within a calendar year.
The basic formula is:
Total basic salary earned during the calendar year ÷ 12 = 13th month pay
For example, if an employee earned ₱240,000 in basic salary from January to December, the 13th month pay would be:
₱240,000 ÷ 12 = ₱20,000
If the employee worked for only part of the year, the 13th month pay is computed proportionately based on the basic salary actually earned during that year.
Who Is Entitled to 13th Month Pay?
As a general rule, rank-and-file employees are entitled to 13th month pay, regardless of:
- designation;
- employment status;
- method of wage payment; or
- whether they are paid monthly, daily, hourly, or on a piece-rate basis.
The key condition is that the employee must have worked for at least one month during the calendar year.
Managerial employees are generally excluded from the statutory 13th month pay requirement, unless the benefit is provided by contract, company policy, collective bargaining agreement, or established company practice.
Rank-and-File Employees vs. Managerial Employees
The distinction between rank-and-file and managerial employees matters because 13th month pay is generally required for rank-and-file employees.
A managerial employee is usually one whose primary duty consists of managing the establishment or a department or subdivision, and who has authority to hire, transfer, suspend, lay off, recall, discharge, assign, or discipline employees, or effectively recommend such actions.
Employees who do not meet this level of authority are usually considered rank-and-file or supervisory, depending on their functions. Supervisory employees are generally not managerial in the strict sense and may still be covered by 13th month pay rules if they are not truly managerial.
Job title alone is not controlling. What matters is the actual work performed and the authority exercised.
Is a Resigned Employee Entitled to 13th Month Pay?
Yes. An employee who resigned is still entitled to prorated 13th month pay for the portion of the calendar year actually worked, provided the employee is otherwise covered by the law.
Resignation does not erase earned benefits. Once salary has been earned, the corresponding proportionate 13th month pay also accrues.
For example, if an employee worked from January to June and earned ₱180,000 in basic salary during that period, the prorated 13th month pay would be:
₱180,000 ÷ 12 = ₱15,000
The employee need not be employed until December to be entitled to prorated 13th month pay.
Is a Terminated Employee Entitled to 13th Month Pay?
Generally, yes. Even if an employee was terminated, the employee remains entitled to wages and benefits already earned before the termination date, including prorated 13th month pay if covered.
The reason for termination may affect entitlement to separation pay, but it does not automatically remove entitlement to unpaid salary or prorated 13th month pay already earned.
For example, an employee dismissed for just cause may not be entitled to separation pay, but may still be entitled to unpaid salary, prorated 13th month pay, and other earned benefits.
When Should Final Pay Be Released?
Under Philippine labor standards guidance, final pay should generally be released within thirty days from the date of separation or termination of employment, unless there is a more favorable company policy, individual agreement, or collective bargaining agreement.
The thirty-day period is commonly applied to allow the employer to complete clearance procedures, compute unpaid amounts, process tax matters, and verify accountabilities.
However, employers should not use clearance as an excuse for unreasonable delay. The process must be conducted in good faith and within a reasonable period.
When Should 13th Month Pay Be Released?
For employees who remain employed through the year, 13th month pay should generally be paid not later than December 24 of every year.
For employees who resign or are separated before the regular payout date, the prorated 13th month pay is usually included in the final pay and should be released together with it.
An employer should not deny prorated 13th month pay simply because the employee is no longer connected with the company when the usual December payout date arrives.
What Is Included in “Basic Salary” for 13th Month Pay?
13th month pay is generally based on basic salary. Basic salary usually means the regular wage or salary paid by the employer for services rendered.
Generally excluded from the computation are items such as:
- cost-of-living allowances;
- profit-sharing payments;
- cash equivalents of unused leave credits;
- overtime pay;
- premium pay;
- night shift differential;
- holiday pay;
- commissions, unless treated as part of basic salary or integrated into the wage structure; and
- other allowances and monetary benefits not considered part of basic salary.
However, the treatment of commissions, allowances, and incentives may depend on how they are structured. If a payment is actually part of the employee’s basic wage or is regularly integrated into compensation, it may raise legal or factual issues.
Is 13th Month Pay Different from a Christmas Bonus?
Yes. 13th month pay is a statutory benefit. A Christmas bonus is generally discretionary unless it has become demandable by contract, company policy, collective bargaining agreement, or long-established company practice.
An employer cannot treat a discretionary Christmas bonus as a substitute for 13th month pay unless the benefit already satisfies the legal requirements for 13th month pay.
If a company gives both 13th month pay and a Christmas bonus, the 13th month pay remains mandatory for covered employees, while the bonus depends on the source of the obligation.
Can an Employer Withhold Final Pay Because Clearance Is Not Yet Completed?
Employers commonly require separated employees to go through a clearance process. This may involve returning company property, settling cash advances, turning over documents, surrendering IDs, and completing exit procedures.
A clearance process is generally allowed. Employers have a legitimate interest in ensuring that company property and accountabilities are settled.
However, clearance should not be used to indefinitely delay final pay. If there are no valid accountabilities, the employer should release the final pay within the applicable period. If there are accountabilities, the employer should identify and substantiate them.
A vague statement that the employee has “pending clearance” is usually not enough to justify indefinite withholding.
Can an Employer Deduct from Final Pay?
An employer may be able to deduct certain amounts from final pay, but deductions must be legally and factually justified.
Common examples include:
- unliquidated cash advances;
- loans or salary advances;
- value of unreturned company property, if properly documented;
- legally authorized deductions;
- deductions consented to by the employee in writing, where required;
- tax withholding; and
- other lawful deductions under company policy, contract, or applicable law.
Employers should be careful with deductions. They should not impose arbitrary penalties, inflated charges, or unsupported claims. Deductions should be based on clear evidence, proper computation, and lawful authority.
Can an Employer Withhold Final Pay Because the Employee Did Not Render 30 Days’ Notice?
Under Philippine labor law, an employee who resigns without just cause is generally expected to give at least one month’s advance written notice. This allows the employer to prepare for turnover.
If the employee fails to give proper notice, the employer may have a potential claim for damages if actual damage can be proven. However, this does not automatically mean the employer may confiscate all final pay or refuse to release earned wages and statutory benefits.
The employer must distinguish between amounts already earned and any separate claim it may have. Unpaid salary and prorated 13th month pay are not automatically forfeited merely because the employee failed to complete a notice period.
Can an Employer Refuse to Release Final Pay Because of a Bond or Training Agreement?
Some employers require employees to sign training bonds or employment bonds. These agreements usually require the employee to stay for a minimum period or reimburse training costs if the employee resigns early.
Whether a bond is enforceable depends on its terms and surrounding circumstances. A bond may be questioned if it is unreasonable, oppressive, excessive, unsupported by actual training cost, or operates as a penalty rather than a legitimate reimbursement.
If there is a valid and enforceable bond, the employer may assert it as an accountability. Still, the employer should be able to show the agreement, the computation, and the basis for the amount claimed.
An employee may challenge an unreasonable deduction before the appropriate labor forum.
Can an Employer Forfeit 13th Month Pay?
As a rule, 13th month pay already earned by a covered employee should not be forfeited. It is a statutory monetary benefit.
Company policies that impose forfeiture of statutory benefits are generally vulnerable to challenge. An employer cannot defeat a mandatory labor standard by internal policy.
Even if the employee violated company policy, resigned without notice, or was dismissed for cause, prorated 13th month pay already earned should generally remain payable to a covered employee.
Is Final Pay Required Even for Probationary Employees?
Yes. Probationary employees are employees. If they are separated from employment, they are entitled to unpaid wages and benefits already earned, including prorated 13th month pay if they worked for at least one month and are otherwise covered.
Probationary status does not remove the right to statutory labor standards.
Is Final Pay Required Even for Project-Based, Seasonal, Casual, or Fixed-Term Employees?
Generally, yes. Employment classification may affect the nature and duration of employment, but it does not automatically remove entitlement to earned wages and statutory benefits.
If the worker is an employee and is covered by labor standards laws, unpaid wages and prorated 13th month pay may be due upon completion of the project, season, term, or employment period.
The actual relationship matters. Some employers label workers as “consultants,” “independent contractors,” “project hires,” or “freelancers,” but if the facts show an employer-employee relationship, labor standards may still apply.
What If the Employer Claims the Worker Is an Independent Contractor?
Independent contractors are generally not entitled to employee benefits such as 13th month pay, unless the contract provides otherwise. However, the label used in the contract is not conclusive.
Philippine labor law looks at the reality of the relationship. Important indicators include whether the company controls not only the result of the work but also the means and methods by which the work is performed.
If the company controls work schedule, processes, tools, discipline, reporting structure, and manner of performance, the worker may be considered an employee despite being called an independent contractor.
If an employer misclassifies an employee as an independent contractor to avoid labor standards, the worker may file a labor complaint and seek recognition of employee status and corresponding benefits.
What If the Employer Says the Company Has No Funds?
Financial difficulty does not automatically excuse non-payment of wages or statutory benefits. Salaries and statutory labor benefits are not ordinary favors; they are legal obligations.
An employer experiencing financial distress may explain delay, but it does not erase the employee’s claim. If the company closes, becomes insolvent, or undergoes liquidation, employees may need to pursue claims through the proper labor or insolvency process.
What If the Employer Closed or Stopped Operations?
If the employer has closed, employees may still have claims for unpaid wages, prorated 13th month pay, and, in some cases, separation pay, depending on the reason and circumstances of closure.
Closure due to serious business losses may affect separation pay. Closure not due to serious losses may result in separation pay obligations.
Employees should gather records quickly because enforcement can become more difficult when a business has ceased operations, transferred assets, or become insolvent.
What If the Employer Is a BPO, Agency, Contractor, or Manpower Provider?
In arrangements involving agencies or contractors, the direct employer is usually the agency or contractor. However, the principal or client may have solidary liability in certain labor-only contracting or contracting arrangements, especially for unpaid wages and labor standards violations.
If the employer is a manpower agency and the employee’s final pay or 13th month pay is not released, the employee may need to identify both the agency and, depending on the facts, the principal or client company.
The legality of the contracting arrangement may become relevant.
What If the Employee Was Hired Remotely or Worked from Home?
Remote work does not eliminate entitlement to final pay or 13th month pay if the worker is an employee under Philippine law.
For employees working from home, final pay may still include unpaid salary, prorated 13th month pay, reimbursable expenses if agreed upon, and other earned benefits.
For remote workers hired by foreign companies, jurisdiction and enforcement may be more complicated. If the employer has a Philippine entity, local office, agent, or registered business presence, remedies may be more practical. If the employer has no presence in the Philippines, enforcement may require additional legal strategy.
What Documents Should an Employee Gather?
An employee claiming unpaid final pay or 13th month pay should gather:
- employment contract;
- appointment letter or job offer;
- company handbook or policies;
- payslips;
- payroll records;
- bank credit records showing salary payments;
- certificate of employment, if available;
- resignation letter or termination notice;
- clearance forms;
- email or chat correspondence about final pay;
- proof of returned company property;
- computation sent by the employer, if any;
- proof of unpaid commissions, incentives, or reimbursements;
- attendance records or timekeeping records; and
- any written demand already sent.
The more complete the records, the easier it is to prove the claim.
How Should an Employee Demand Final Pay?
Before filing a complaint, an employee may send a written demand to the employer. The demand should be polite, clear, and specific.
It should state:
- the employee’s name and former position;
- employment period;
- last working day;
- amounts being requested;
- request for computation;
- request for release of final pay and prorated 13th month pay;
- request for explanation of any deductions;
- deadline for response; and
- statement that the employee reserves all legal rights.
Written communication is important because it creates a record.
Sample Demand Letter
Subject: Request for Release of Final Pay and Prorated 13th Month Pay
Dear [Employer/HR/Payroll],
I was formerly employed as [position] from [start date] until [last working day]. I am writing to respectfully follow up on the release of my final pay, including my unpaid salary, prorated 13th month pay, and other amounts due to me under law, company policy, and my employment terms.
Kindly provide a written computation of my final pay and advise when the amount will be released. If there are any deductions or alleged accountabilities, please provide the details, supporting documents, and legal or contractual basis for the deductions.
I respectfully request that my final pay be released within the applicable period. I reserve all rights and remedies available under Philippine labor law.
Thank you.
Sincerely, [Name]
Where Can an Employee File a Complaint?
An employee may seek assistance from the Department of Labor and Employment through its labor dispute settlement mechanisms. Many money claims begin with a request for assistance or a mandatory conciliation-mediation process.
If settlement fails, the claim may proceed to the proper labor forum, depending on the nature and amount of the claim and whether there are related issues such as illegal dismissal.
For many employees, the practical first step is to file a request for assistance with DOLE. This may lead to a conference where the employee and employer are asked to discuss settlement.
If the claim involves illegal dismissal, reinstatement, damages, or more complex labor disputes, the case may fall under the jurisdiction of the National Labor Relations Commission.
DOLE, SEnA, and Money Claims
The Single Entry Approach, commonly known as SEnA, is a mandatory conciliation-mediation mechanism designed to provide a speedy and inexpensive settlement of labor issues.
Through SEnA, the employee and employer may be called to a conference before a desk officer. The goal is to settle the dispute without full-blown litigation.
If settlement is reached, the parties may sign an agreement. If no settlement is reached, the employee may pursue the appropriate complaint before the labor arbiter or other proper office.
Final pay and 13th month pay disputes are common subjects of SEnA proceedings.
When Should the Employee File?
Employees should act promptly. Money claims under the Labor Code generally have prescriptive periods. Delay can weaken a claim, especially if documents are lost, witnesses become unavailable, or the employer becomes harder to locate.
Even if the employee first sends a demand letter, it is best not to wait too long before filing the appropriate complaint if the employer does not respond or refuses payment.
Can the Employee Claim Attorney’s Fees?
In labor cases, attorney’s fees may be awarded in certain circumstances, particularly when the employee is compelled to litigate or incur expenses to recover wages or benefits unlawfully withheld.
However, attorney’s fees are not automatic. They depend on the findings of the labor tribunal or court.
Can the Employee Claim Moral or Exemplary Damages?
Moral and exemplary damages may be awarded in labor cases, but they require specific factual and legal basis. Mere delay in payment does not automatically result in damages.
Damages may be considered if the employer acted in bad faith, fraudulently, oppressively, or in a manner contrary to morals, good customs, or public policy.
The employee must prove the basis for damages.
Can the Employer Require a Quitclaim Before Releasing Final Pay?
Employers often ask employees to sign a quitclaim, release, or waiver when receiving final pay.
Quitclaims are not automatically invalid. However, they are viewed carefully in labor law. A quitclaim may be invalid if the employee signed it under pressure, if the consideration is unconscionably low, if the employee did not understand the waiver, or if it waives statutory rights without fair settlement.
An employer should not use a quitclaim to force an employee to waive valid claims in exchange for amounts already legally due.
Employees should read any quitclaim carefully before signing. If the computation is incomplete or disputed, the employee may write “received under protest” or seek legal advice before signing, depending on the circumstances.
Can the Employer Delay Final Pay Until the Employee Signs a Quitclaim?
An employer may require acknowledgment of receipt or clearance documents, but it should not improperly condition payment of undisputed statutory benefits on a broad waiver of all claims.
If the amount being released is merely what the employee is already legally entitled to receive, the employer should not use it as leverage to obtain an unfair waiver.
What If the Employer Gave an Incorrect Computation?
The employee should ask for a detailed breakdown. A proper final pay computation should show:
- unpaid salary period;
- basic salary rate;
- prorated 13th month pay computation;
- leave conversion, if any;
- separation pay, if any;
- deductions;
- tax withholding or refund;
- loans or accountabilities;
- net amount payable; and
- expected release date.
If the computation is wrong, the employee should dispute it in writing and explain the correction.
Common Employer Defenses
Employers commonly raise the following defenses:
- the employee has not completed clearance;
- the employee has unreturned company property;
- the employee has unpaid loans or cash advances;
- the employee resigned without proper notice;
- the employee is not entitled to separation pay;
- the employee is managerial and not entitled to 13th month pay;
- the worker is an independent contractor, not an employee;
- the employee already signed a quitclaim;
- the amount has already been paid;
- the claim has prescribed;
- the employee was dismissed for cause; or
- the benefit claimed is discretionary.
Some defenses may be valid, but they must be supported by evidence and law. They do not automatically defeat claims for unpaid wages and statutory benefits.
Common Employee Mistakes
Employees often make mistakes that weaken their claims, such as:
- relying only on verbal follow-ups;
- failing to keep payslips or employment records;
- signing quitclaims without reading the computation;
- assuming that all benefits are automatically payable;
- confusing final pay with separation pay;
- waiting too long to file a complaint;
- failing to document returned company property;
- not asking for a written breakdown of deductions;
- posting defamatory statements online; or
- refusing to attend settlement conferences.
A calm, documented, and legally focused approach is usually more effective.
Final Pay vs. Separation Pay
Final pay and separation pay are often confused.
Final pay refers to all amounts due to the employee after separation. It may be due regardless of the reason for separation.
Separation pay is a specific benefit required only in certain cases, such as authorized causes, qualifying closure, retrenchment, redundancy, installation of labor-saving devices, disease, or when provided by contract, company policy, or equity-based rulings.
An employee who resigns voluntarily is generally not entitled to separation pay unless it is granted by contract, company policy, collective bargaining agreement, established practice, or the employer’s voluntary act.
However, a resigning employee may still be entitled to final pay, including prorated 13th month pay.
Final Pay in Cases of Illegal Dismissal
If the employee claims illegal dismissal, the monetary claims may be broader. The employee may seek reinstatement, full backwages, separation pay in lieu of reinstatement when appropriate, unpaid wages, prorated 13th month pay, damages, and attorney’s fees, depending on the facts.
In illegal dismissal cases, the unpaid final pay may be only one part of a larger claim.
Are Company Policies Less Favorable Than Labor Law Valid?
No. Company policies cannot reduce statutory labor standards. If the law grants a benefit, the employer cannot remove it through a handbook, memo, contract, or clearance form.
However, company policies may provide benefits more favorable than the law. For example, a company may voluntarily provide 14th month pay, expanded leave conversion, or separation pay even in cases where the law does not require it.
Favorable company policy, once established and consistently applied, may become enforceable.
Tax Treatment of Final Pay and 13th Month Pay
Final pay may have tax consequences. Some amounts may be taxable, while others may be excluded or subject to specific tax rules.
13th month pay and certain other benefits are subject to tax treatment under Philippine tax law, with exclusions up to the applicable statutory threshold. Amounts beyond the exclusion may be taxable.
Employers usually handle withholding and year-end tax adjustment. Employees should request a breakdown if taxes are deducted from final pay.
What If the Employer Does Not Give a Certificate of Employment?
A certificate of employment is separate from final pay. An employee may request a certificate of employment showing the dates of employment and position held. Employers are generally expected to issue it upon request within a reasonable period.
The employer should not refuse to issue a certificate of employment merely because the employee has a final pay dispute, although the certificate need not contain statements beyond the employee’s service record unless required by policy or agreement.
Practical Steps for Employees
An employee whose final pay or 13th month pay has not been released may take the following steps:
- check the employment contract, handbook, and company policy;
- compute the estimated amount due;
- complete reasonable clearance requirements;
- return company property and keep proof of turnover;
- request a written computation from HR or payroll;
- send a formal written demand;
- ask for the basis of any deduction;
- avoid purely verbal follow-ups;
- preserve all documents and messages;
- file a request for assistance with DOLE if unresolved;
- proceed to the appropriate labor forum if settlement fails; and
- seek legal advice for complex cases.
Practical Steps for Employers
Employers should:
- maintain clear final pay policies;
- process final pay within the applicable period;
- provide written computations;
- avoid unsupported deductions;
- document accountabilities;
- conduct clearance in good faith;
- separate undisputed amounts from disputed claims where possible;
- release statutory benefits promptly;
- avoid coercive quitclaims;
- keep payroll and employment records;
- train HR personnel on labor standards; and
- resolve disputes early through settlement where appropriate.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. I resigned. Can my employer refuse to give my 13th month pay?
Generally, no. If you are a covered employee and worked for at least one month during the calendar year, you are generally entitled to prorated 13th month pay based on the basic salary you earned.
2. I was terminated for cause. Do I still get 13th month pay?
Generally, yes, if you are otherwise covered. Dismissal for cause may affect separation pay, but it does not automatically erase earned wages or prorated 13th month pay.
3. My employer says I must finish clearance first. Is that valid?
A reasonable clearance process is valid, but it should not be used to delay final pay indefinitely. The employer should identify any specific accountabilities and process final pay within a reasonable period.
4. Can my employer deduct the cost of a laptop I did not return?
Possibly, if the laptop was company property, the employee was accountable for it, and the amount deducted is properly supported. The deduction should be reasonable and documented.
5. Can my employer deduct penalties from my final pay?
Arbitrary penalties are questionable. Deductions must have a lawful, contractual, or factual basis. Unsupported penalties may be challenged.
6. Is separation pay automatic when I resign?
No. Voluntary resignation generally does not entitle an employee to separation pay unless provided by contract, company policy, collective bargaining agreement, established practice, or employer discretion.
7. Is final pay automatic when I resign?
Yes, to the extent that it consists of amounts already earned or legally due, such as unpaid salary and prorated 13th month pay.
8. Can I file with DOLE even if the amount is small?
Yes. Labor mechanisms are designed to assist employees with money claims, including relatively small claims.
9. Do I need a lawyer to file a complaint?
Not always. Many employees begin with DOLE assistance or SEnA without a lawyer. However, legal advice is helpful for complex disputes, large claims, illegal dismissal, quitclaims, or contractor misclassification.
10. Can I post about my employer online?
Be careful. Public accusations may expose the employee to defamation, cyberlibel, confidentiality, or data privacy issues. It is usually safer to pursue formal remedies and keep communications documented and professional.
Key Legal Principles
Several principles guide final pay and 13th month pay disputes in the Philippines:
- earned wages must be paid;
- statutory benefits cannot be waived by unfair or coercive agreement;
- 13th month pay is mandatory for covered rank-and-file employees;
- resigned or separated employees may still be entitled to prorated 13th month pay;
- final pay should be processed within a reasonable period;
- employers may require clearance but may not use it for indefinite delay;
- deductions must be lawful, documented, and reasonable;
- separation pay is not the same as final pay;
- job titles do not control employee classification;
- substance prevails over form in determining employment relationships; and
- employees have administrative and legal remedies for non-payment.
Conclusion
The non-release of final pay and 13th month pay is not merely an HR inconvenience. It can involve enforceable labor rights. In the Philippines, employees who resign, are dismissed, or are otherwise separated from employment remain entitled to compensation and benefits already earned. For covered rank-and-file employees, this usually includes prorated 13th month pay.
Employers may impose reasonable clearance procedures and deduct valid accountabilities, but they should not withhold final pay indefinitely or deny statutory benefits without legal basis. Employees, on the other hand, should document their claims, request a written computation, communicate formally, and pursue DOLE or labor remedies if the matter remains unresolved.
The best approach for both sides is prompt, transparent, and documented settlement. When the employer refuses to release final pay or 13th month pay despite demand, the employee may elevate the matter through the appropriate Philippine labor process.