Closing a small business in the Philippines is not a single act. It is a sequence of legal, tax, labor, and administrative steps that must be handled in the correct order. Where the business has one employee, the labor side is simpler than in a larger enterprise, but it is still legally significant. A business owner who stops operations without completing the proper closure process can remain exposed to tax assessments, penalties, labor claims, local business tax issues, unpaid government contributions, and documentary problems long after the store or office has already shut down.
This article explains the Philippine legal framework for closing a small business with one employee, including business registration closure, employee separation, final pay, notice rules, government agency reporting, tax clearance concerns, and the practical documentation needed to reduce risk.
I. What “closing a business” means in Philippine law
In Philippine practice, business closure usually involves several separate legal events:
- Stopping actual operations
- Terminating the employee’s employment
- Cancelling or retiring national registrations, especially with the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR)
- Cancelling local registrations, such as the mayor’s permit and barangay clearance where applicable
- Closing registrations with other agencies, depending on the business form and industry
- Settling taxes, fees, contributions, books, invoices, and records
- Winding up the entity, if the business is a corporation or partnership
A sole proprietor, a one-person corporation, an ordinary corporation, and a partnership do not close in exactly the same way. The labor rules on employee termination are similar in principle, but the business-law steps differ.
II. Main Philippine laws and agencies involved
The key legal and regulatory sources generally include:
- The Labor Code of the Philippines
- The Civil Code, for certain contractual obligations
- The National Internal Revenue Code, as amended, and BIR regulations
- The Local Government Code, for local permits and local taxes
- The Social Security Act
- The PhilHealth law and implementing rules
- The Pag-IBIG Fund law and implementing rules
- The Revised Corporation Code, if the business is a corporation
- Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) rules, for corporations and partnerships
- Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) rules, for sole proprietorships
- Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE) requirements, especially where termination is due to closure of business
The government bodies commonly involved are:
- DTI for sole proprietorship business name cancellation
- SEC for dissolution of corporations and partnerships
- BIR for tax registration cancellation and authority to stop using receipts/invoices
- Local government unit (LGU) for closure of local permits and local tax accounts
- DOLE for report/notice relating to termination due to closure
- SSS, PhilHealth, and Pag-IBIG for employer account updates and remittance closure
- Sometimes industry regulators, if the business is licensed
III. First question: what kind of business is being closed?
This matters because the closure path depends on the legal form.
A. Sole proprietorship
A sole proprietorship is not separate from the owner. Closure usually involves:
- Stopping operations
- Cancelling the DTI business name registration
- Retiring BIR registration
- Cancelling LGU permits and local tax accounts
- Closing employer registrations, if applicable
- Settling all obligations
Even after closure, the owner may remain personally liable for unpaid debts, taxes, or labor liabilities because the business and owner are legally the same person.
B. Partnership
A partnership generally requires formal dissolution and liquidation steps, plus tax and local closure. SEC registration must also be addressed if registered there.
C. Corporation or one-person corporation
A corporation has a separate juridical personality. Closure usually requires formal dissolution under corporation law, and often liquidation afterward. Even if operations have stopped, the corporation continues to exist until legally dissolved, and may continue to incur compliance duties until then.
IV. Closing the business is not the same as firing the employee
Where a business has one employee, owners often think they can simply tell the employee the business is ending and then stop paying salary. That is dangerous. The employee’s separation must still comply with Philippine labor law.
If the employee is being let go because the business is shutting down, the relevant authorized cause is usually closure or cessation of business operations.
This is not a resignation. It is not abandonment. It is not dismissal for cause. It is employer-initiated termination based on business closure.
V. Closure of business as an authorized cause for termination
Under Philippine labor law, an employer may terminate employment due to the closure or cessation of operation of the establishment or undertaking.
This is an authorized cause. That classification matters because it usually carries procedural requirements and, in many cases, separation pay.
Two major distinctions are critical:
A. Closure not due to serious business losses or financial reverses
If the business is closing for reasons other than serious losses, the employee is generally entitled to separation pay.
The standard rule generally applied is:
- One month pay, or
- One-half month pay for every year of service,
whichever is higher.
A fraction of at least six months is usually counted as one whole year.
B. Closure due to serious business losses or financial reverses
If the closure is genuinely due to serious business losses or financial reverses, separation pay may not be required.
But the burden is on the employer to prove the losses. This is not satisfied by a bare statement that sales were low. The employer should be prepared to show credible financial evidence, such as:
- Financial statements
- Income tax returns
- Sales records
- Audit documents, where available
- Ledger or bookkeeping records
- Other proof showing substantial and real losses
For a very small business, the absence of formal audited statements may complicate proof. The smaller the enterprise, the more carefully the owner should preserve documentary evidence of losses.
VI. Notice requirements to the employee and DOLE
For closure of business as an authorized cause, the employer is generally required to give:
- Written notice to the employee, and
- Written notice to the Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE)
at least 30 days before the intended date of termination.
This 30-day notice requirement is one of the most important compliance points.
A. Notice to the employee
The notice should clearly state:
- That the business will close
- The reason for closure
- The effective date of termination
- Whether separation pay will be given
- The employee’s final pay arrangements
- Instructions on return of company property, if any
The tone should be factual and not accusatory.
B. Notice to DOLE
The DOLE notice should likewise state the business closure and the intended termination date. It is prudent to keep stamped receiving copies, courier proof, email proof if locally accepted, or any formal acknowledgment.
Failure to comply with the notice requirement can create liability even where the closure itself is valid.
VII. Is a hearing required?
For closure as an authorized cause, the process is different from termination for just cause. The classic “two-notice rule” with an opportunity to explain and hearing applies to dismissals for employee fault, such as misconduct or neglect.
In a true closure case, what is generally required is the 30-day prior notice to the employee and DOLE. A disciplinary hearing is not the core requirement because the termination is not based on employee wrongdoing.
Still, fairness and documentation remain important. A short turnover meeting and a signed acknowledgment of receipt of notice are good practice.
VIII. Separation pay: how to compute it
Where separation pay is required because the closure is not due to proven serious losses, compute it under the authorized-cause rule.
General benchmark
The employee is entitled to the higher of:
- One month salary, or
- One-half month salary for every year of service
A fraction of at least six months is usually counted as one whole year.
Example 1
Employee has worked for 2 years and 8 months. Monthly salary: PHP 18,000.
Half-month salary per year of service:
- 2 years and 8 months counts as 3 years
- PHP 18,000 ÷ 2 = PHP 9,000
- PHP 9,000 × 3 = PHP 27,000
One month salary:
- PHP 18,000
Higher amount:
- PHP 27,000
Example 2
Employee has worked for 1 year and 2 months. Monthly salary: PHP 20,000.
Half-month salary per year:
- 1 year and 2 months counts as 1 year
- PHP 20,000 ÷ 2 = PHP 10,000
One month salary:
- PHP 20,000
Higher amount:
- PHP 20,000
What is “one-half month pay”?
In labor practice, “one-half month pay” can involve nuances depending on the context and jurisprudence. Employers should compute conservatively and clearly, especially where regular allowances are treated as part of wage. In very small businesses, disputes often arise from undercounting years of service, ignoring wage components, or mishandling fractions of service.
IX. Final pay: what must be paid to the employee
Business closure does not erase accrued obligations. The employee is generally entitled to final pay, which may include:
- Unpaid salaries up to the last day worked
- Pro-rated 13th month pay
- Cash conversion of unused service incentive leave, if legally applicable
- Separation pay, where required
- Refund of deposits or salary deductions that should be returned
- Any other earned contractual benefits due under company practice or agreement
A. Unpaid salary
Pay all compensation earned through the last working day.
B. 13th month pay
This is generally due on a pro-rated basis for the portion of the year already worked, unless already fully paid.
C. Service incentive leave (SIL)
If the employee is legally entitled to SIL and has unused leave convertible to cash, that amount should be included in final pay.
D. Separation pay
Include it if closure is not due to serious losses, or if the employer chooses to pay it as a settlement measure.
E. Other benefits
Check:
- Employment contract
- Company handbook
- Established practice
- Written promises
- Commission arrangements
- Reimbursements
- Unliquidated cash advances
X. When should final pay be released?
As a practical compliance rule in the Philippines, final pay should be released within a reasonable period, and current labor guidance commonly points to payment within 30 days from separation, unless a more favorable company policy, collective agreement, or special circumstance applies.
Delays often create complaints. If there is a property-clearance process, it should be administered reasonably and not used to withhold undisputed wages.
XI. Certificate of Employment
Upon request, an employee is generally entitled to a Certificate of Employment (COE). This usually states:
- Employee’s name
- Position
- Inclusive dates of employment
- Sometimes a brief statement that employment ended due to business closure
A COE is not a quitclaim. It is a separate employee right.
XII. Quitclaims and releases
Many employers ask the departing employee to sign a quitclaim and release in exchange for final pay. In the Philippines, quitclaims are not automatically invalid, but they are scrutinized closely.
A quitclaim is more likely to be respected if:
- The employee signed voluntarily
- The terms are clear
- The employee received a reasonable and fair amount
- There was no fraud, coercion, intimidation, or deception
- The employee understood the document
A quitclaim cannot safely be used to justify paying less than what is legally due. Underpayment may still be challenged.
XIII. What if the employee refuses to sign?
The employer should still pay what is legally due. If the employee refuses to sign a quitclaim but accepts payment, document the release. If the employee refuses to receive payment, the employer should preserve proof of tender and consider formal consignation or other documented means of showing readiness to pay, especially where a dispute is brewing.
Never make signature on a quitclaim a condition to release of clearly due wages.
XIV. Illegal dismissal risk even if the business really closes
A genuine closure can still result in labor liability if the employer mishandles the process. Common mistakes include:
- No 30-day notice
- No DOLE notice
- No proof that the business truly closed
- Claiming “serious losses” without evidence
- Nonpayment or underpayment of final pay
- Backdating documents
- Reopening immediately under another name with the same operations and claiming the employee was lawfully terminated
- Targeting only one employee while the business continues
If the business is not truly closing, but only replacing the employee or changing labels, the dismissal may be attacked as illegal.
XV. Temporary closure versus permanent closure
There is a legal and factual difference between:
- Temporary suspension of operations
- Retrenchment
- Redundancy
- Permanent closure or cessation
If the owner only intends to pause operations and reopen soon, the labor implications may differ. Calling it “closure” while actually continuing the business later can undermine the employer’s position.
If the closure is permanent, keep records showing that operations truly ceased:
- Lease termination
- Notice to customers
- Inventory liquidation
- Final utility bills
- BIR retirement filings
- Permit cancellations
- Photos of vacated premises
- Closure board resolutions, if a corporation
XVI. Tax obligations do not end just because operations stop
Many business owners stop selling and assume the tax side is over. It is not. Until registrations are properly retired, the business can continue to accumulate compliance exposure.
Common tax-related closure issues
- Open tax types remain registered
- Returns may still be expected
- Books and invoices remain on record
- Failure to retire receipts/invoices may create problems
- Unresolved tax liabilities may block closure
- Loose ends with withholding taxes, VAT, percentage tax, or income tax may remain
The BIR side is often the most tedious part of closure.
XVII. BIR closure or retirement of registration
For most businesses, BIR closure generally involves retiring the taxpayer registration and business registration details.
Although documentary requirements can vary by taxpayer type, revenue district, and current BIR practice, closure often involves some combination of the following:
- Application for cancellation of registration
- Surrender of certificate of registration, if applicable
- Surrender or inventory of unused invoices/receipts
- “Ask for receipt” notices and related permits, where applicable
- Books of accounts for examination or closure notation
- Final returns and payment of outstanding taxes
- Tax clearance-related review or verification
- Proof of closure from LGU, DTI, or SEC, depending on entity type
Important practical point
The BIR may review whether all tax returns have been filed and taxes paid up to the date of closure. A business may need to settle:
- Income tax
- VAT or percentage tax
- Expanded withholding tax
- Withholding tax on compensation
- Documentary stamp tax where relevant
- Registration fees or related compliance issues from prior periods
If the business had one employee, withholding tax on compensation may still matter even if the employee’s compensation was below taxable thresholds, depending on filing history and payroll setup.
XVIII. Invoices, official receipts, and books of accounts
A closing business should not simply throw away unused receipts or books.
A. Unused receipts/invoices
They generally must be properly accounted for and surrendered or reported as part of retirement procedures, depending on current BIR requirements and the invoicing system used.
B. Books of accounts
Keep books and accounting records properly. The BIR may require them for audit or verification prior to closure.
C. Record retention
Even after closure, records should be preserved for the legally relevant retention period. Closure does not erase the government’s ability to review prior transactions within the applicable prescriptive periods.
XIX. Final tax returns and the “last period” problem
A business closing midyear may still need to file returns for the final taxable periods and annual filings for the relevant year, depending on timing and BIR treatment.
This area is often mishandled. The owner should identify all open tax types and determine:
- Which returns are still due before closure
- Which returns cover the final month, quarter, or year
- Whether there are zero-transaction filings still needed before registration is retired
- Whether payroll-related reports remain due
XX. Local government closure: mayor’s permit and local taxes
Stopping operations at the physical site does not automatically end LGU obligations.
The business usually needs to deal with:
- Mayor’s permit cancellation or retirement
- Barangay clearance issues, depending on local practice
- Business tax retirement
- Clearance for unpaid local taxes, fees, or penalties
- Closure of sanitary, building, fire, or other local permits where applicable
Each city or municipality may have its own process and forms. Some require:
- Affidavit of closure
- Pictures of the closed establishment
- Lease termination
- Tax bill settlement
- Latest permit
- Proof of national registration closure or intention to close
An owner who ignores the LGU may later discover unpaid local business taxes or penalties attached to the account.
XXI. DTI cancellation for sole proprietorships
For a sole proprietorship, the business name registration with DTI should be cancelled or allowed to lapse, but mere expiration of the name does not substitute for proper tax and local closure. The owner should still actively close the BIR and LGU accounts.
DTI business name cancellation is administrative, but important for clean records.
XXII. SEC dissolution for corporations and partnerships
If the business is a corporation or partnership, stopping operations is not enough. The entity must go through proper dissolution.
Depending on the circumstances, dissolution may involve:
- Board approval
- Stockholder or member approval
- Submission of dissolution documents to the SEC
- Settlement of creditors
- Liquidation of assets
- Filing of final reports
Where there are outstanding liabilities, assets, or disputes, dissolution becomes more technical.
For a one-person corporation, the process is still formal because the corporation remains a separate legal person.
XXIII. Winding up and liquidation
For entities with juridical personality, dissolution is often followed by liquidation. This means:
- Collecting receivables
- Selling or distributing assets
- Paying creditors
- Settling taxes
- Settling employee claims
- Closing bank accounts as appropriate
- Completing final reports
The order of payment matters where assets are insufficient. Labor claims can be especially sensitive.
XXIV. SSS, PhilHealth, and Pag-IBIG obligations
If the business had one employee, it likely had employer obligations with:
- SSS
- PhilHealth
- Pag-IBIG
Closure should include:
- Payment of all outstanding employer and employee share remittances
- Submission of required reports, if any remain pending
- Updating employer status
- Closure or deactivation steps for the employer account, consistent with each agency’s process
Non-remittance is a serious issue. Amounts deducted from employee salary but not remitted can create liability beyond simple bookkeeping error.
XXV. Payroll records and remittance proof
Before closing, organize:
- Payroll summaries
- Payslips
- Time records
- Remittance receipts
- Alphalist and BIR payroll filing records, if applicable
- Government contribution transmittals
These records help answer future questions from the employee, DOLE, BIR, or social agencies.
XXVI. Special issue: employee on probationary, fixed-term, project, or regular status
Even with only one employee, status matters.
A. Regular employee
Closure rules clearly apply.
B. Probationary employee
A probationary employee may still be terminated due to closure. Authorized-cause rules and notice requirements remain relevant.
C. Fixed-term employee
If the contract is genuinely fixed-term and simply expires, that is one issue. But if the business closes before expiration, closure may still need to be handled as employer-initiated termination.
D. Project or seasonal employee
The real nature of employment matters more than labels. Misclassification can turn into a labor claim.
XXVII. Employee with pending accountabilities or company property
If the employee has unreturned property, such as:
- Keys
- Laptop
- Phone
- Cash advances
- Inventory
- Documents
the employer may run a clearance process. But wages and legally due benefits should not be withheld arbitrarily. Only lawful, documented, and properly established deductions should be made.
Employers should avoid self-help deductions unsupported by consent or law.
XXVIII. What documents should the business owner prepare?
A careful business owner typically prepares a closure file containing:
- Written decision to close the business
- Board resolution or owner’s written declaration, as applicable
- 30-day notice to employee
- 30-day notice to DOLE
- Proof of receipt of both notices
- Final payroll and final pay computation
- Separation pay computation
- COE
- Quitclaim and release, if used
- Inventory of business assets
- Proof of closure of premises
- Lease termination or landlord correspondence
- BIR closure documents
- LGU closure documents
- DTI or SEC closure documents
- SSS/PhilHealth/Pag-IBIG proofs
- Latest tax returns and payment receipts
- Unused receipt/invoice inventory and surrender documents
- Books and accounting records
Good documentation is often what separates a clean closure from a long-running problem.
XXIX. Can the owner just stop renewing permits instead of formally closing?
That is risky. Non-renewal is not the same as proper closure.
Possible consequences include:
- Taxes or fees still being assessed
- Open BIR registration remaining active
- Future notices and penalties
- Inability to prove exact closure date
- Labor dispute complications
- Problems opening another business later
Formal closure is far safer than silent abandonment.
XXX. Can the owner reopen later?
Yes, but reopening later does not erase how the prior closure was handled. If the owner reopens the same or similar business shortly afterward, especially in the same location, with the same customers and same functions, the former employee may argue that the prior “closure” was not genuine.
That does not make every reopening illegal, but it increases litigation risk. The facts must support a real cessation.
XXXI. What if the owner is bankrupt or has no money to pay?
Lack of cash does not automatically excuse legal obligations. The issue becomes more complex if the business is truly suffering serious losses. As noted, separation pay may not be due if serious losses are proven. But unpaid wages already earned, remittance obligations, and tax duties do not simply disappear.
If liabilities exceed assets, the owner should still document the situation honestly and avoid concealment or preferential conduct that could trigger more liability.
XXXII. Does the employee need to consent to the closure?
No. An employer can close the business even without the employee’s consent, provided the closure is lawful and the authorized-cause requirements are followed.
The employee’s consent is not what makes the termination valid. The legality depends on:
- Genuine closure
- Proper notice
- Proper payment
- Good-faith compliance
XXXIII. Is the business owner required to get DOLE permission before closing?
Generally, closure is not treated as something requiring prior DOLE approval in the ordinary sense. But notice to DOLE is generally required for authorized-cause termination due to closure. In practice, owners should not confuse “notice” with “permission.” Still, compliance with the notice requirement is essential.
XXXIV. Difference between closure and retrenchment
Some businesses close because income has declined; others reduce manpower without fully closing.
- Closure means cessation of operations of the establishment or undertaking.
- Retrenchment means reduction of workforce to prevent losses while the business continues.
If the business truly has only one employee and intends to stop operating entirely, closure is usually the more accurate framework. Mislabeling the action can complicate the defense in a labor case.
XXXV. Industry-specific licenses and regulated businesses
If the business is regulated, additional closure steps may apply. Examples include businesses licensed by agencies overseeing food, health, transport, finance, education, telecoms, or other specialized sectors.
The owner should check whether there are:
- Surrender requirements
- Notice obligations
- Bond or escrow issues
- Client notification duties
- Data retention duties
- Consumer refund obligations
XXXVI. Data privacy and records after closure
If the business collected personal data of customers, employees, or suppliers, closure does not eliminate data protection responsibilities. Records should be retained, archived, or disposed of in a lawful manner, with attention to:
- Confidential employee records
- Payroll records
- Taxpayer information
- Customer personal data
- Medical or sensitive data, if any
Improper disposal can create a separate compliance issue.
XXXVII. Lease, suppliers, utilities, and private contracts
Business closure can also trigger private-law obligations outside labor and tax law, including:
- Lease pretermination liability
- Security deposit disputes
- Supplier contract termination
- Utility account closure
- Loan default or acceleration clauses
- Franchise or distribution agreement termination
- Equipment rental return obligations
These are not the same as government closure requirements, but they are part of lawful winding down.
XXXVIII. Common mistakes of small business owners
The most frequent errors are:
- Informally telling the employee not to report to work anymore
- Giving less than 30 days’ notice
- Not notifying DOLE
- Refusing separation pay without proof of serious losses
- Paying final pay late
- Failing to close BIR registration
- Ignoring local permit retirement
- Failing to remit government contributions
- Throwing away unused receipts or books
- Thinking DTI expiration alone closes the business
- Assuming one employee means labor law does not matter
- Using a forced quitclaim to hide underpayment
XXXIX. Suggested sequence of closure steps
A practical order is usually:
- Decide whether closure is permanent and document the reason.
- Identify business form: sole proprietorship, partnership, corporation, OPC.
- Gather financial records, especially if claiming serious losses.
- Prepare 30-day notice to employee.
- Prepare 30-day notice to DOLE.
- Continue lawful operations during the notice period, or manage turnover properly.
- Compute final pay, 13th month, SIL conversion, and separation pay if due.
- Prepare COE and release documents.
- Pay all wages and benefits due.
- Settle SSS, PhilHealth, Pag-IBIG, and payroll-related filings.
- Retire BIR registration and account for invoices/receipts and books.
- Close LGU permits and local tax accounts.
- Cancel DTI business name or dissolve SEC entity, as applicable.
- Keep records and proof of closure for future audits or claims.
XL. Documentary proof is often the heart of the case
If a labor complaint or tax issue arises later, the owner will need to prove what happened. The strongest closure cases usually have:
- A definite closure date
- Written notices
- Clear financial records
- Proof of payment
- Proof of agency filings
- Proof that operations genuinely stopped
In the Philippines, unsupported verbal explanations are weak protection.
XLI. A note on serious business losses
This is the most misunderstood issue in small-business closure. Owners often assume they can avoid separation pay merely by saying the business was losing money. That is not enough. The losses must be serious, and they must be provable.
A business that closes for personal reasons, relocation, change of plans, exhaustion, or modest underperformance will usually have a harder time invoking the no-separation-pay exception.
Where proof is weak, many employers choose to pay separation pay anyway to reduce dispute risk.
XLII. What if the employee files a complaint?
The employee may go to the labor authorities and claim:
- Illegal dismissal
- Nonpayment of separation pay
- Nonpayment of wages
- Nonpayment of 13th month pay
- Underpayment of final pay
- Failure to release COE
- Damages or attorney’s fees in some cases
The employer’s defense will usually rest on documents. Missing notice or missing payment records can seriously weaken the case.
XLIII. Practical computation checklist for one employee
Before release of final pay, verify:
- Last date worked
- Monthly or daily rate
- Unpaid days worked
- 13th month pay earned for the year
- Unused leave convertible to cash
- Separation pay basis
- Deductions that are lawful and documented
- Net amount payable
- Date and mode of payment
- Signed acknowledgment of receipt
XLIV. Checklist by business type
Sole proprietorship
- DTI cancellation
- BIR closure
- LGU closure
- Employee termination compliance
- SSS/PhilHealth/Pag-IBIG closure steps
- Settle debts and contracts
Corporation/OPC
- Board/shareholder action as required
- SEC dissolution steps
- Employee termination compliance
- BIR closure
- LGU closure
- Government contributions and payroll cleanup
- Liquidation and final winding up
Partnership
- Partner approvals
- SEC or relevant dissolution steps
- Employee termination compliance
- BIR and LGU closure
- Settlement of partnership liabilities
XLV. Minimum best-practice file for a one-employee closure
Even for the smallest business, keep at least these:
- Closure decision memo or resolution
- Financial records showing reason for closure
- Employee notice dated at least 30 days before termination
- DOLE notice dated at least 30 days before termination
- Final pay computation sheet
- Separation pay computation sheet
- Proof of payment
- COE
- Remittance proofs
- BIR retirement papers
- LGU retirement papers
- DTI/SEC papers
- Archive of books and receipts/invoices
XLVI. Bottom line
To legally close a small business with one employee in the Philippines, the owner must handle both business closure and lawful employee separation. The core labor rule is that termination due to closure is an authorized cause, which generally requires 30 days’ prior written notice to the employee and DOLE, plus separation pay unless the closure is due to proven serious business losses or financial reverses. On top of that, the owner must properly close out BIR, LGU, and, depending on the entity type, DTI or SEC, while settling SSS, PhilHealth, and Pag-IBIG obligations and preserving records.
The biggest mistakes are informal shutdowns, missing notice, unsupported claims of losses, and failure to retire tax and permit registrations. A business may physically close in one day, but a legally clean closure takes documentation, orderly payment, and proper filings.