Here’s a practitioner-style explainer on the Real Estate Developer vs Contractor distinction under Philippine law—what each is, who regulates them, what licenses they need, and how liabilities, warranties, and buyer remedies differ. It’s written for owners, buyers, project managers, and SME builders. This is general information—not legal advice for your exact facts.
1) Core definitions (who is who)
Real estate developer (a.k.a. project owner/subdivider/condominium developer)
- A person or entity that conceives, owns, finances, and sells a subdivision or condominium project.
- Covered primarily by PD 957 (Subdivision and Condominium Buyers’ Protective Decree) and its IRR, related standards (e.g., BP 220 for socialized/low-cost housing), Condominium Act (RA 4726), and the regulatory powers of the Department of Human Settlements and Urban Development (DHSUD) (formerly HLURB).
- The developer registers the project, secures a License to Sell (LTS), markets units/lots, and bears statutory duties to buyers (infrastructure completion, amenities, disclosures, turnover, association formation).
Contractor (construction contractor)
- A service enterprise that undertakes construction (buildings, siteworks, utilities) for a price, either as general contractor or specialty trade, for public or private clients.
- Governed by RA 4566 (Contractors’ License Law) and the PCAB (Philippine Contractors Accreditation Board) under CIAP/DTI.
- Must hold a PCAB license (category/field) to legally contract and build. May hire subcontractors and is subject to technical, safety, and labor regulations.
Rule of thumb: Developers sell real estate to end-buyers; contractors sell construction services to developers (and sometimes to owners who are not developers).
2) Regulatory map (who polices whom)
Topic | Developer | Contractor |
---|---|---|
Primary regulator | DHSUD (project registration, LTS, compliance; buyer complaints via adjudication) | PCAB/CIAP (DTI) for licensing & discipline |
Planning & land | LGU (zoning, development permits), DHSUD (minimum standards) | — (but must build per approved plans and permits) |
Building permits | OBO/City Engineer: structural/sanitary/mech/electrical approvals for the project | Same permits apply to works they execute |
Environment | DENR/EMB (ECC/CNC) as required | Must comply with ECC conditions during construction |
Fire & life safety | BFP (FSEC/FSIC for common areas) | Same, for the works handed over |
Construction safety | — (owner duty to ensure compliance) | DOLE: OSH Law (RA 11058), CSHP approval, safety officers |
Labor compliance | Buyer-side: not applicable | Labor Code; wage/benefit compliance; solidary liability nuances with principal |
Marketing & sales | DHSUD pre-clearance of ads; LTS required before selling | Not applicable (can market services, not real estate) |
3) Licenses and papers (baseline)
Developer must have:
- Project registration with DHSUD and a License to Sell (LTS) before any advertising or selling.
- Development Permit from LGU planning/zoning; building permits for vertical works; ECC/CNC where required.
- Approved plans/standards (e.g., road widths, drainage, open spaces; BP 220 or PD 957 minimums).
- Master Deed and Declaration (for condos); subdivision plan (for land projects).
- Performance securities/escrows, where required in practice (to secure completion/use of buyer payments per PD 957 rules).
Contractor must have:
- PCAB license (General Building/Engineering or Specialty) with appropriate category (e.g., AAA, AA, A, B, C, D) based on financial/track record.
- DOLE Construction Safety and Health Program (CSHP) approval before mobilization; safety officer(s); toolbox meetings; incident logs.
- Insurance/bonds often required by contract: Contractor’s All-Risk/Erection All-Risk, Performance Bond, Payment Bond, Third-Party Liability.
Contracting without a PCAB license is an offense; contracts may be void or unenforceable against the public interest, with administrative sanctions.
4) What each one is legally responsible for
Developer statutory duties to buyers (PD 957 / RA 4726 highlights)
- No pre-selling without LTS.
- Timely completion of roads, drainage, utilities, and amenities as promised in DHSUD-approved plans.
- Truth-in-advertising: brochures/ads form part of the sales representations; material deviations can be actionable.
- Non-mortgage or disclosure: restrictions on mortgaging the project/units that prejudice buyers; required disclosures/annotations.
- Formation/turnover of Homeowners’ Association (HOA) or Condominium Corporation; conveyance of open spaces/common areas per law.
- After-sales service and handling of complaints via DHSUD adjudication.
Contractor core obligations to the owner (developer)
- Build as per contract, plans, specs, codes, within time and price (subject to variations/force majeure).
- Professional standard of care; defects rectification during Defects Liability Period (DLP).
- Compliance with NSCP, Fire Code, Sanitary/Plumbing/Mechanical/Electrical codes, and permit conditions.
- OSH compliance; proper employment of workers; remittance to SSS/PhilHealth/Pag-IBIG; wage laws.
Civil Code long-tail liability (Art. 1723)
- Architects/engineers/contractors are liable for 10 years for ruin of a building due to defects in construction or defects in the ground, and 5 years for defects in other works; the action must be brought within 10 years counted from completion. Developers can be sued on warranty and misrepresentation; contractors and design professionals face statutory decennial liability.
5) The contract chain (and how risk flows)
Typical structure
- Developer (Owner) ↔ General Contractor ↔ Specialty Subcontractors (structural, MEPF, finishes) ↔ Suppliers.
- Design professionals (Architect/Structural/MEP) contract with either Owner or Design-Build Contractor.
- Construction/project management (CPM) may be separate.
Risk allocation tools
- FIDIC/PICE-based or bespoke construction contracts (time, variations, EOT, liquidated damages, warranties).
- Performance bonds and retentions (e.g., 10% retention; release partially at TOC, balance after DLP).
- Indemnities (contractor indemnifies for workmanship/safety issues; developer indemnifies for site/legal title issues).
- Insurance layers: CAR/EAR during works; property & liability post-TOC; professional indemnity for designers.
6) Labor law overlay (common developer–contractor pitfalls)
- Legitimate job contracting vs labor-only contracting: In construction, licensed contractors with substantial capital/equipment and control are legitimate. If the developer exercises control over workers and the “contractor” is a mere manpower supplier, it can be labor-only contracting → developer becomes the employer by law.
- Solidary liability: Even with legitimate contracting, the principal (developer) may be solidarily liable for unpaid labor standards in the work contracted, to protect workers.
- OSH penalties: Accidents trigger DOLE enforcement; both owner and contractor can attract sanctions if CSHP and safety officer requirements are ignored.
7) Sales and buyer remedies (where developers and contractors get dragged in)
Before sale
- No LTS, no selling. Buyers can rescind and complain to DHSUD; administrative fines and criminal liability may follow.
After sale
- Maceda Law (RA 6552) protections for buyers on installment (cancellation limits, grace periods, refunds).
- PD 957 adjudication: buyers can seek completion, refund, damages, or specific performance if amenities/roads/utilities promised are not delivered.
- Defects/structural issues: buyers/associations may sue developer for breach of sale/warranty and implead the contractor and design professionals under Art. 1723.
- Condo Act: the Condominium Corporation (common areas) and unit owners have remedies for defects and non-turnover of titles/common areas.
8) Taxes (high-level orientation)
- Developers: Sale of lots/units is generally VATable (subject to thresholds/exemptions) and subject to income tax. They handle withholding tax on commissions to brokers/agents; buyers do documentary stamp tax on deeds/mortgages.
- Contractors: Construction services are VATable when registered; subject to creditable withholding tax by clients; must enroll workers in SSS/PhilHealth/Pag-IBIG and comply with payroll/withholding. (Rates, thresholds, and exemptions change—confirm current figures before contracting.)
9) Compliance lifecycle (side-by-side)
Developer
- Land due diligence → zoning, title, liens, encumbrances, easements.
- Concept & approvals → Development Permit, ECC/CNC, utilities MOAs.
- DHSUD → Project registration & LTS; ad approvals.
- Procurement → choose PCAB-licensed contractor(s).
- Construction oversight → CPM, QA/QC, safety audits.
- Sales & collections → contracts compliant with PD 957/Maceda; escrow arrangements as applicable.
- Turnover → TCT/CCT delivery; HOA/condo corp creation & conveyance of common areas; BFP FSIC; Certificate of Occupancy.
- Post-turnover → punch-list rectifications; buyer complaint handling; DHSUD compliance.
Contractor
- PCAB license & category upkeep; renewal.
- Bid/contract → scope, price, schedule, bonds, CAR insurance.
- Permits (CSHP) → mobilize with safety officers and OSH plan.
- Build → QA/QC, inspections, variation/change orders.
- Testing & commissioning → as-builts, manuals, training.
- Turnover → punch-list, DLP management, release of retention.
- Close-out → tax clearances, warranties, final accounts.
10) Warranties and limitation periods (what lasts, how long)
- Contractual DLP: commonly 12 months from TOC for workmanship defects (longer for waterproofing/M&E as negotiated).
- Art. 1723 decennial liability: 10 years for ruin/major structural failure (and 5 years for other works), counted from completion; action must be brought within the same period.
- Sales law warranties: fit for purpose and as described; misrepresentations in ads/plans are actionable under PD 957 and Civil Code.
- Condo common areas: claims by Condominium Corporation/HOA may proceed against developer and contractor; keep as-builts, test certificates, and turnover inventories.
11) Practical procurement & contracting tips
For developers/owners
- Hire only PCAB-licensed contractors whose category matches project size.
- Require named key personnel (PM, safety, QA/QC, licensed engineers) and right to approve substitutions.
- Bake in liquidated damages for delay (per day), performance bond, retention, and step-in rights for serious default.
- Demand as-builts, O&M manuals, test reports, and warranty certificates at turnover.
- Flow down your DHSUD commitments (amenities specs, completion dates) into the construction contracts.
For contractors
- Clarify scope (exclusions/inclusions), site conditions, and owner-supplied items to avoid change-order wars.
- Secure timely progress payments with a clear valuation protocol; protect cash flow with retention caps and bond limits.
- Confirm permit responsibilities (who procures which permit) and utility availability.
- Keep OSH paperwork and daily site logs impeccable; they are your first line of defense in claims.
12) Common dispute patterns (and how they resolve)
- Pre-selling without LTS → DHSUD sanctions; buyers get rescission/refund; developer liable for damages.
- Amenities not delivered → buyers/HOA sue developer for specific performance; developer back-charges contractor if within scope/time.
- Structural leaks/failures → developer and contractor jointly sued; Art. 1723 and contract warranties kick in; experts decide causation.
- Change orders/delays → arbitrate/litigate under contract dispute clause; EOT vs liquidated damages are fact-driven.
- Labor claims → workers claim unpaid wages/benefits; developer may be solidarily liable if contractor is labor-only or for certain labor standards under the Code.
13) “What am I?” quick tests
- You sell titles or condo units to the public → you’re a developer; get DHSUD project registration + LTS.
- You pour concrete and install MEPF for a price → you’re a contractor; get a PCAB license.
- You’re both (design-build developer) → you wear two legal hats; comply with both regimes (DHSUD for selling; PCAB for building).
14) Sample clause snippets (orientation only)
Developer → Contractor: flow-down of statutory duties
“Contractor acknowledges Owner’s commitments to DHSUD, including completion of [list amenities/roads/utilities] by [date]. Time is of the essence. Delay liquidated damages of ₱[x]/day apply, capped at [y]% of Contract Price, without prejudice to Art. 1723 statutory liabilities.”
Defects Liability & security
“A retention of 10% shall be withheld from progress payments, reduced to 5% upon TOC and released at the end of the 12-month DLP, subject to clearance of all punch-list and latent defects.”
Safety & labor compliance
“Contractor shall secure DOLE CSHP approval and maintain required safety officers. Contractor warrants full compliance with the Labor Code; Owner may withhold sums to satisfy verified wage/benefit deficiencies.”
15) FAQs
Q: Can a developer self-build without a PCAB license? A: If the developer directly contracts out works, the builder must be PCAB-licensed. A developer that acts as its own contractor to build for another party or repeatedly offers construction services is expected to be PCAB-licensed.
Q: Is it illegal to sell without an LTS? A: Yes—selling or advertising subdivision lots or condo units before DHSUD issues an LTS violates PD 957 and invites administrative/criminal penalties and buyer rescission.
Q: Who fixes post-turnover defects—developer or contractor? A: Buyers deal with the developer (seller). The developer, in turn, enforces warranty/DLP against the contractor. For major failures, Art. 1723 allows actions directly against the contractor and design pros.
Q: Are contractors liable for design errors? A: If design-build, yes, for both design and construction. If build-only, contractor is mainly liable for workmanship but can be faulted for obvious design errors they failed to flag.
Q: Can the HOA/Condo Corp sue the contractor directly? A: Yes, particularly for common area defects and under Art. 1723; typically, they also sue the developer.
Bottom line
- A developer is the seller/owner of the project—regulated by DHSUD/PD 957/RA 4726—with statutory duties to complete and deliver precisely what’s been approved and advertised.
- A contractor is the builder—regulated by PCAB/RA 4566—and must be licensed, safe, and code-compliant; it owes warranties and carries decennial liability for major defects.
- Projects succeed when contracts flow down the developer’s legal obligations, safety and QA/QC are non-negotiable, and buyers’ rights are respected from LTS to turnover.
If you share your role (developer, contractor, or buyer), project type (subdivision vs condo), and where you are in the cycle (pre-sell, under construction, turnover), I can draft a tailored compliance checklist and contract rider for your side.