Refund for Delayed Turnover of Condotel Unit Under PD 957 in the Philippines

I. Big Picture: Why PD 957 Matters to Condotel Buyers

Presidential Decree No. 957 (the Subdivision and Condominium Buyers’ Protective Decree) was issued to protect buyers of subdivision lots and condominium units against abuses by developers. It applies even if the condominium is a condotel (condominium units operated as hotel rooms).

So if you bought a condotel unit on pre-selling and the developer is late in turning over the unit, PD 957 is one of your main weapons to ask for:

  • Delivery of the unit plus damages; or
  • Refund (reimbursement of what you paid) plus damages, if the delay is serious enough to qualify as failure to complete as required.

PD 957 is a special law that often prevails over general rules and over contract provisions that are less favorable to the buyer.

II. Legal Framework

1. PD 957 – Key Provisions Relevant to Delay & Refund

Some of the most important provisions in the context of delayed turnover are:

  1. Section 20 – Time of Completion

    • Requires the developer to complete the project (including facilities, improvements, and structures) within the period stated in its license to sell and approved plans, subject only to valid extensions by the housing authorities.

    • If the developer fails to complete within the allowed period, the buyer is generally given the option to:

      • (a) Wait and compel completion; or
      • (b) Demand reimbursement of all amounts paid, usually including amortization interest but excluding penalties or delinquency charges, and often with legal interest and possible damages.

    • This is the main statutory anchor for a refund due to delay.

  2. Section 21 – Non-Waiver of Rights

    • Any stipulation waiving the rights granted by PD 957 is void.

    • So even if your condotel contract says:

      “Buyer waives the right to refund due to delay” that clause has no legal effect as far as PD 957 rights are concerned.

  3. Section 23 – Non-Forfeiture of Payments

    • Protects buyers who default from losing all their payments.
    • Often discussed together with the Maceda Law, but here it reminds us that PD 957 looks unfavorably on forfeiture and is buyer-protective.

  4. Section 24 & Related Provisions – Failure to Develop

    • The government (through the housing agencies) can impose sanctions, suspend or revoke licenses, or even take over the project in severe cases.
    • Useful leverage in negotiations with a developer who’s dragging its feet.

  5. Penal and Administrative Sanctions

    • Violations of PD 957 can result in:

      • Administrative fines, suspension/revocation of license to sell;
      • In some cases, criminal liability of responsible officers.

Even if you only want your money back, the fact that the developer risks sanctions can make them more willing to settle.

2. Other Laws That Interact With PD 957

  1. Civil Code (Obligations and Contracts)

    Relevant principles:

    • Parties are bound to perform obligations in good faith, in the manner agreed upon and within the time agreed.

    • Substantial breach or delay by the developer can justify:

      • Rescission (resolution) of the contract; and
      • Damages (actual, moral, exemplary, attorney’s fees) in proper cases.

    • Rescission under the Civil Code co-exists with PD 957 remedies. Often, PD 957 gives you specific, extra protections but doesn’t remove general Civil Code rights.

  2. RA 6552 – Maceda Law (Realty Installment Buyers’ Protection Act)

    • Protects buyers paying in installments from oppressive cancellation by sellers.

    • It is most relevant when the buyer is the one in default, not when the developer is delayed.

    • In projects covered by PD 957, the general view is:

      • PD 957 prevails in case of conflict;
      • Maceda Law may still supplement PD 957 where the decree is silent, but not to reduce rights already granted under PD 957.

  3. RA 4726 – Condominium Act

    • Governs condominium ownership.
    • Important for understanding your rights as a condo unit owner (voting, common areas, etc.), but the refund for delayed turnover issue is principally handled by PD 957 + Civil Code.

  4. RA 11201 – Creation of DHSUD & HSAC

    • HLURB’s regulatory functions went to DHSUD (Department of Human Settlements and Urban Development).

    • Its adjudicatory functions moved to the Human Settlements Adjudication Commission (HSAC).

    • Today:

      • DHSUD regulates developers, licenses to sell, registration, etc.
      • HSAC adjudicates disputes between buyers and developers under PD 957.

III. What Is a “Condotel” and Why It Matters (But Not Too Much)

A condotel (condominium hotel) is typically:

  • A condominium unit sold to an individual buyer;
  • Placed under a hotel operations program managed by the developer or a hotel operator;
  • Often marketed as an investment with projected or guaranteed rental income, pool sharing, etc.

Key point: For purposes of PD 957, it’s still a condominium project.

That means:

  • The protections of PD 957 still apply;
  • The developer can’t avoid PD 957 by simply labeling the project “condotel,” “serviced residences,” or “condo-hotel investment.”

The hotel management agreement (HMA) or leaseback scheme might be separate from the sale contract. When you seek a refund for delayed turnover:

  • You are typically attacking the sale contract (for failure to deliver the unit as promised);
  • The hotel program contract may rise and fall with it, or may need to be addressed separately, depending on its wording.

IV. When Does “Delayed Turnover” Justify a Refund?

1. Contractual Turnover Date vs. Statutory Time to Complete

You usually have two timelines:

  1. The turnover date in your Contract to Sell / Deed of Absolute Sale:

    • Often something like “on or before December 31, 2021,” with a grace period and exceptions for force majeure.

  2. The time to complete as regulated by DHSUD (previously HLURB) under PD 957 and indicated in the License to Sell and approved project timetable.

Delay for refund purposes generally means:

  • The developer has failed to complete and deliver the unit within the contractual timetable and the regulatory timetable, without valid justifications and without duly approved extensions.

The longer the delay and the weaker the justification, the stronger the buyer’s case for rescission and refund.

2. When Delay Becomes “Failure to Complete”

Some practical indicators that delay has crossed into “failure to complete” (subject to factual proof):

  • The project is far from completion long after the promised turnover date.
  • The building may be structurally complete, but no Certificate of Completion / Occupancy Permit, no operational utilities, or serious defects rendering it unfit for hotel use or occupancy.
  • Developer fails to comply with repeated DHSUD or HSAC orders to complete.
  • Developer has financial difficulties, suspend operations, or abandons the project.

At that point, under PD 957 and the Civil Code, a buyer can reasonably argue:

The obligation has been breached in a substantial manner, so I want out and I want my money back.

3. When Delay Might Not Justify Full Refund (Yet)

There are situations where the delay exists but is not yet serious enough to automatically justify rescission:

  • Short delays that can be justified by:

    • Force majeure (strong typhoons, earthquakes, pandemics, government bans, etc.);
    • Permitting issues not attributable solely to the developer;
    • Strikes or supply chain disruptions, if properly documented.

  • Delay where the developer is actively catching up and has realistic, credible steps and timelines to complete.

In these cases, the typical remedy is:

  • Specific performance: compel the developer to deliver; and/or
  • Damages for delay (rent loss, opportunity cost, etc.), instead of immediate refund.

V. What Exactly Can Be Refunded?

When rescission/refund is justified (under PD 957 Section 20 and/or Civil Code), the usual components are:

  1. Purchase Price Installments Actually Paid

    • All payments made toward the unit price should be returned.

  2. Amortization Interest Actually Paid

    • If you financed the purchase through in-house financing, and part of your payments went to contractual interest, many decisions and regulations treat those payments as refundable, because they were part of what you paid “for the unit.”

  3. Other Charges Directly Tied to the Sale

    • Sometimes buyers also seek:

      • Transfer-related fees (registration, documentary stamp tax, etc.) if already advanced;
      • VAT or percentage tax built into the price;

    • Whether these are refundable can depend on the exact facts and agreements, and on whether the sale was reversed before title transfer and tax filings.

  4. Exclusions (Typically Not Refunded) Usually not refunded:

    • Penalties or late payment charges due to buyer’s delay in paying;
    • Association dues / condo dues paid for periods when the buyer actually enjoyed possession or benefits;
    • Independent hotel program expenses not directly tied to the bare unit purchase.

  5. Legal Interest

    Courts and adjudicatory bodies often award legal interest on the refundable amount, computed from:

    • Either the date of judicial or extrajudicial demand for refund; or
    • Dates of payment, depending on the case.

    The legal interest rate and the exact computation can change over time by Supreme Court policy; that’s something usually argued in the case.

  6. Damages

    You can also claim:

    • Actual damages (e.g., lost rental income you reasonably expected to earn, alternative housing, etc., if adequately proven);
    • Moral and exemplary damages in cases of bad faith, fraud, or oppressive conduct;
    • Attorney’s fees, in proper cases.

VI. How to Enforce Your Right to Refund (Step-by-Step)

This is the usual practical path if your condotel unit was not turned over on time:

Step 1: Gather and Organize Documents

At minimum:

  • Reservation agreement / Contract to Sell / Deed of Sale
  • Hotel and leaseback agreements (if any)
  • Official receipts / proof of payments
  • Developer brochures, flyers, and emails referencing turnover dates
  • License to Sell number (can be seen in marketing materials or contract)
  • Any letters or emails from the developer admitting or explaining the delay

Step 2: Compute the Delay

  • Compare:

    • Promised turnover date in the contract; and
    • Actual status of the project (e.g., still under construction, no occupancy permit).

  • Note any formal notices from the developer changing the turnover date, and whether you explicitly agreed to those changes.

Step 3: Send a Formal Demand Letter

A typical demand letter would:

  1. Invoke PD 957 and the Civil Code;

  2. State the promised turnover date and the period of delay;

  3. Explain that the delay is unreasonable and unjustified;

  4. Choose your remedy:

    • Either completion + damages; or
    • Rescission + full refund + interest + damages;

  5. Give a reasonable deadline for the developer to respond.

Even if you end up filing a case, the demand letter:

  • Shows good faith;
  • Establishes the date of extrajudicial demand (relevant for interest);
  • Can be attached as evidence in HSAC or court.

Step 4: File a Case With HSAC (or Court)

If negotiation fails, you may:

  1. File a complaint with the Human Settlements Adjudication Commission (HSAC) (the successor adjudicatory body to HLURB) if your case is within its jurisdiction (which it usually is for PD 957 buyer–developer disputes); or

  2. File a civil case in the regular courts (Regional Trial Court), especially if:

    • You are claiming large damages, or
    • There are complex legal issues beyond the usual PD 957 scope.

In HSAC-type proceedings, typical remedies sought include:

  • Rescission of the sale contract for your condotel unit;
  • Refund of all payments (plus interest);
  • Damages;
  • Administrative sanctions against the developer, where applicable.

Step 5: Enforcement / Execution

If you win:

  • A decision will order the developer to pay you the refund (plus interest and damages, if awarded).
  • You may need to enforce it through writs of execution, garnishment, or other enforcement measures if the developer does not voluntarily comply.

VII. Issues Unique to Condotel Arrangements

Condotels introduce extra layers beyond ordinary condo sales:

  1. Hotel Management Agreement (HMA) or Leaseback

    • Often you sign a separate contract allowing the developer or a hotel operator to use your unit for hotel guests.

    • When you rescind the sale, this hotel contract usually:

      • Either automatically terminates; or
      • Has to be separately terminated/settled.

    • You may need to clarify things like:

      • Apportionment of income already earned;
      • Responsibility for wear and tear, furnishings, etc.

  2. Guaranteed Rental Income / Investment Promises

    • Many condotels are sold with income projections or guarantees.

    • If the unit is never turned over or the project never becomes operational, you might have claims not only for refund but also for:

      • Lost expected rental income;
      • Possibly fraud or misrepresentation, if the investment returns were grossly exaggerated or impossible from the start.

  3. Use Restrictions

    • Because the unit is part of a hotel operation, there may be strict rules on personal use, alterations, or independent leasing.
    • Those restrictions usually do not cancel your rights under PD 957 to get out of the contract if the project is not delivered as promised.

VIII. Common Developer Defenses (and How They Are Usually Assessed)

Developers often raise the following defenses:

  1. Force Majeure / Fortuitous Events

    • Example: natural calamities, government lockdowns, pandemics.

    • Courts and adjudicators examine:

      • Was the event truly unforeseeable and unavoidable?
      • Did the developer act diligently to minimize delay?
      • Has the delay gone beyond what can reasonably be attributed to that event?

  2. Buyer’s Alleged Default

    • Developer may say: turnover was delayed because you were late in payments.

    • It becomes important to:

      • Show receipts and payment schedules;
      • Establish that you were substantially compliant or that any delay on your part was minor compared to the developer’s failure.

  3. Project Is Already Substantially Complete

    • Sometimes the unit is technically complete, but:

      • No occupancy permit;
      • No hotel operations; or
      • Serious defects exist.

    • The question becomes: is it really “completed” in the sense contemplated by PD 957 and the contract?

  4. Buyer’s Acceptance or Waiver

    • Developer may argue you waived rights by signing amendments or accepting new turnover dates.

    • But remember Section 21 (Non-waiver):

      • You cannot validly waive rights granted to you by PD 957 through contract clauses that reduce your protection.
      • Still, your conduct can affect what remedies (and damages) are reasonable.

IX. Tax and Financial Considerations of Refunds

When a refund is granted:

  • The original sale may be treated as rescinded.

  • Some practical issues:

    • If title was already transferred and taxes (DST, CGT, etc.) were paid, further steps may be needed at the BIR and Registry of Deeds to reverse or annotate the rescission.
    • For VAT-registered developers, they may issue credit notes or adjustments for refunded sales.

  • From the buyer’s perspective, the core concern is usually:

    • Get the money back (refund + interest), and
    • Make sure you are no longer on the hook for future charges (association dues, real property tax, etc.) once rescission is effective.

Because tax consequences can be technical and situation-specific, this part is usually handled with the assistance of counsel and sometimes an accountant.

X. Practical Tips for Condotel Buyers Facing Delayed Turnover

  1. Document Everything Early

    • Save all emails and Viber/WhatsApp messages where the developer:

      • Admits delays;
      • Promises new turnover dates;
      • Offers concessions.

  2. Join or Coordinate With Other Buyers

    • If many investors are similarly affected, a group complaint or coordinated negotiations can be more effective.

  3. Be Clear on Your Goal

    • Decide if you really want:

      • To keep the unit and just get compensated for delay; or
      • To walk away completely with a refund.

    • Your chosen remedy shapes your legal strategy.

  4. Don’t Be Intimidated by “Fine Print”

    • Many condotel contracts are written to appear heavily one-sided.
    • Under PD 957, buyer-protective statutory rights override unfair contract clauses.

  5. Consult a Philippine Lawyer Early

    • PD 957 disputes can get technical and fact-intensive.

    • A local lawyer can:

      • Review your contracts;
      • Draft a strong demand letter;
      • Represent you before HSAC or the courts.

XI. Summary

  • PD 957 applies to condotel projects because they are still condominium projects.

  • Delayed turnover, when serious and unjustified, can amount to failure to complete under PD 957 and substantial breach under the Civil Code.

  • In such cases, a buyer can seek:

    • Rescission of the sale contract;
    • Refund of all payments (including financing interest, in many cases);
    • Legal interest and damages.

  • Contracts and “investment” disclaimers cannot waive PD 957 rights.

  • Enforcement is typically pursued through HSAC (formerly HLURB’s adjudicatory function) or regular courts, supported by a well-documented record of delay and demands.

This is a general legal discussion for the Philippine setting. For any specific condotel project or contract, it’s essential to get tailored advice from a Philippine lawyer who can review your documents and the actual status of the development.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login