Introduction
A woman employee in the Philippines does not lose her right to resign simply because she is pregnant, on maternity leave, or has just given birth. Maternity leave protects her employment and benefits during a legally protected period, but it does not imprison her in the job. She may still choose to resign, subject to the ordinary rules on resignation, company clearance, and the settlement of final pay.
At the same time, resignation during maternity leave creates practical and legal questions that many employees and employers misunderstand:
- Can an employee resign while she is still on maternity leave?
- Does she need to report back to work first?
- Will she lose SSS maternity benefits?
- Can the employer refuse to accept the resignation?
- Is she still entitled to final pay, unused leave credits, 13th month pay, and a certificate of employment?
- What if the employer pressures her to resign because she gave birth or became inconvenient to retain?
Under Philippine law, the short answer is this: yes, an employee may resign during maternity leave, but the legal consequences depend on when she resigns, how she resigns, whether the maternity benefit has already vested, and whether the resignation is truly voluntary.
This article explains the legal framework in full, using Philippine labor law concepts and the Expanded Maternity Leave rules as the backbone.
I. The basic legal framework
The topic sits at the intersection of several Philippine labor law sources:
- The Labor Code of the Philippines, especially the rules on resignation, wages, benefits, and post-employment obligations.
- The Expanded Maternity Leave Law (Republic Act No. 11210) and its implementing rules, which govern maternity leave entitlement and pay.
- SSS law and social security rules, because part or all of maternity benefit funding may come through the Social Security System, depending on the employee’s status.
- Constitutional and statutory protections for women, including the prohibition against discrimination on account of sex, pregnancy, and maternity.
- General rules on final pay and employment documents, including release of wages and certificate of employment.
To understand resignation during maternity leave, three principles should be kept separate:
- The right to take maternity leave
- The right to receive maternity benefits
- The right to resign from employment
These rights overlap, but they are not the same.
II. Can a woman legally resign during maternity leave?
Yes.
A pregnant employee or a woman already on maternity leave may resign from employment. Philippine law does not require her to wait until she has physically returned to work. Maternity leave is a protected leave period, but it does not suspend her freedom to terminate the employment relationship by resignation.
In other words:
- She may submit a resignation letter before the leave starts.
- She may submit it while she is on leave.
- She may make the resignation effective during the leave period or after the leave period.
- She does not need to report back for one day merely to make the resignation valid.
What still applies is the ordinary rule on resignation: as a rule, an employee who resigns without just cause should give written notice at least 30 days in advance. That is the general Labor Code rule.
So the real legal questions are not whether she can resign, but:
- whether she gave proper notice,
- whether there is a just cause for immediate resignation,
- whether the resignation affects maternity benefits already claimed or still being processed,
- and whether the resignation was truly voluntary.
III. The general rule on resignation under the Labor Code
Under the Labor Code, an employee may terminate employment by serving a written notice on the employer at least one month in advance.
This is the standard resignation rule.
Why the 30-day notice exists
The notice period protects the employer’s operations by allowing time to:
- find a replacement,
- transfer pending work,
- process payroll and clearances,
- and avoid disruption.
The employer generally cannot force the employee to continue forever, but the law recognizes that an orderly exit is required.
Is employer acceptance needed?
As a rule, resignation is a unilateral act of the employee. If the employee clearly communicates her intent to resign and gives the required notice, the employer does not have the power to negate that choice by merely “not accepting” the resignation.
What employers often “accept” in practice is the effective date, turnover, and clearance mechanics. But the right to resign itself does not depend on grace or permission.
What if the employee wants to leave immediately?
The law also recognizes resignation for just cause, which allows the employee to leave without the 30-day notice period. This becomes relevant if the maternity leave situation is mixed with mistreatment, humiliation, or an unsafe or impossible work environment.
IV. Immediate resignation for just cause
An employee may resign without serving the 30-day notice if there is a legally sufficient reason. Classic examples under labor law include:
- serious insult by the employer or the employer’s representative to the honor and person of the employee;
- inhuman and unbearable treatment;
- commission of a crime or offense by the employer or the employer’s representative against the employee or her immediate family;
- and other analogous causes.
In the maternity context, this matters when the employee is subjected to conduct such as:
- being pressured to resign because she is pregnant or has given birth;
- being told her job is no longer secure because she took maternity leave;
- being threatened with demotion or hostility upon return;
- being harassed for having taken legally protected leave;
- being forced to choose between motherhood and continued employment.
If the employer’s conduct makes continued employment genuinely intolerable, the issue may no longer be an ordinary resignation. It may be resignation for just cause, or even constructive dismissal.
V. Resignation versus constructive dismissal during or after maternity leave
This is one of the most important legal issues.
An employee may appear to have “resigned,” but if the employer’s actions effectively forced her out, the law may treat the situation as constructive dismissal, not voluntary resignation.
What is constructive dismissal?
Constructive dismissal happens when the employer makes continued employment impossible, unreasonable, humiliating, or unlikely, such that the employee has no real option except to leave. The test is not whether the employer used the word “terminated,” but whether the employee was pushed out in substance.
Maternity-related examples
A resignation may be challenged as involuntary if the employer:
- tells the employee not to return after maternity leave;
- removes her position because her leave was inconvenient;
- demotes her upon return without legal basis;
- drastically reduces pay or duties;
- assigns her to a hostile or punitive environment because she gave birth;
- refuses to honor maternity-related rights and then pressures her to leave;
- makes discriminatory remarks tying her value as an employee to her pregnancy or childcare responsibilities.
When that happens, the employer cannot hide behind a resignation letter if the letter was obtained through pressure, coercion, deceit, or an atmosphere of no real choice.
Why this matters
If the resignation is not voluntary, the employee may pursue claims for:
- illegal dismissal or constructive dismissal,
- backwages,
- reinstatement or separation pay in lieu of reinstatement where appropriate,
- damages,
- and other relief depending on the facts.
So in maternity situations, voluntariness is critical. A genuine personal decision to resign is valid. A resignation extracted because the employee became pregnant or took leave is legally suspect.
VI. Does maternity leave itself continue if the employee resigns?
This depends on timing and how the benefit accrued.
The phrase “maternity leave” can mean two connected but distinct things:
- The protected leave from work, meaning the period during which the employee is excused from service.
- The maternity benefit/pay, meaning the money she is entitled to receive under law.
If the employment relationship ends by resignation, the employee obviously no longer has an ongoing future relationship with the employer after the effective separation date. But that does not automatically erase maternity benefits that have already accrued or vested.
The real question is whether her entitlement to the maternity benefit had already attached under the law and whether the claim was properly supported.
VII. Effect of resignation on maternity benefits
A. Core rule
A resignation during maternity leave does not automatically forfeit maternity benefits, especially where entitlement had already arisen and legal conditions had been met.
The employer cannot simply say: “You resigned, so you lose maternity benefit.” That is too simplistic and often wrong.
Why
Maternity benefit under Philippine law is not merely a company favor. It is a statutory right linked to childbirth, qualifying contributions, notice requirements, and employment status at the relevant time.
If the employee was qualified and the leave/benefit had already attached, a later resignation does not necessarily cancel what had already become due.
B. If the employee resigns after the maternity leave has started
This is the clearest case for protecting the employee’s benefit.
If the employee was already on maternity leave and then resigns during that leave period, the stronger legal view is that the maternity benefit for that covered contingency should not be defeated merely by her resignation, assuming she was qualified and the leave was properly claimed.
Why? Because the childbirth and the leave entitlement have already occurred. The protected event has happened. The benefit is tied to that event, not to a requirement that she remain indefinitely employed afterward.
C. If the employee resigns before the leave starts but after qualifying
This can be more fact-sensitive.
If an employee resigns before the start of the leave but the childbirth-related contingency is already imminent and the legal requisites have otherwise been satisfied, the entitlement question may turn on the exact employment and SSS status at the relevant time.
In practice, the closer the employee was to the protected event and the more complete the compliance with notice and contribution requirements, the stronger the claim that maternity benefits should still be honored under the applicable rules.
D. If the employee resigns long before childbirth
This is a different case.
If employment ended well before the maternity contingency, the employee’s claim may no longer be governed as a regular employee-employer leave issue. At that point, any maternity entitlement may depend more directly on SSS rules for a separated member, assuming the contribution requirements are still met.
That becomes less a “resignation during maternity leave” issue and more a “maternity claim of a separated employee” issue.
VIII. Employer-paid differential and the effect of resignation
Under the Expanded Maternity Leave regime, many private-sector employers are required to pay not only the SSS-based component but also, where applicable, a salary differential so that the employee receives her full pay during the maternity leave period, subject to recognized exceptions.
This creates another important question:
If the employee resigns during maternity leave, does she still get the salary differential?
Generally, if the maternity leave period had already legally begun and the employee was entitled to full maternity leave compensation, the employer should not use resignation as an excuse to deny the salary differential for the covered leave period that had already vested.
The employer’s obligation depends on the law and applicable exemptions, not on whether the employee later decided not to return after leave.
However, the employer would not ordinarily owe “salary differential” for periods after the employment relationship has validly ended if those periods are no longer part of a vested maternity leave entitlement under the governing rules.
The safe legal distinction is this:
- Vested maternity pay for the covered leave period is protected.
- Ordinary future wages after employment has ended are not.
IX. Can the employer require the employee to return the maternity benefit if she resigns?
As a rule, no, not merely because she resigned.
If the employee was lawfully entitled to maternity benefits and there was no fraud, false claim, duplicate recovery, or improper overpayment, the employer generally has no right to claw back the maternity benefit simply because the employee decided not to return to work after maternity leave.
A common misconception is that maternity leave is like a scholarship bond or training reimbursement. It is not. Maternity leave is a statutory benefit, not a conditional privilege dependent on post-leave loyalty.
That said, repayment issues can arise if:
- the employee was not actually qualified;
- there was a payroll overpayment;
- the company advanced an amount beyond what the law or policy required;
- the employee signed a valid, lawful, and non-prohibited reimbursement arrangement unrelated to the maternity benefit itself;
- or there was fraud or material misrepresentation.
But resignation alone is not enough to justify reimbursement.
X. Is a woman required to return to work after maternity leave before resigning?
No law generally requires a token return-to-work day to make resignation valid.
This is a frequent HR myth. A woman employee may:
- resign with effect during maternity leave, or
- submit notice during leave and make the resignation effective at the end of the notice period, even if that means she never physically returns.
What matters is lawful resignation procedure, not ceremonial reappearance.
Of course, if she still has company property, pending reports, accountabilities, or a turnover obligation, those must still be addressed through practical means. But these are administrative issues, not conditions for the existence of the right to resign.
XI. Is the employee considered absent without leave if she does not return after maternity leave?
Not if she properly resigns.
If the employee simply disappears after maternity leave without notice, the employer may characterize the situation as unauthorized absence or even abandonment, depending on the facts. But if she submits a clear resignation letter and identifies her intended effective date, the non-return should not be treated as abandonment.
Best practice
To avoid conflict, the employee should send a resignation notice that states:
- that she is currently on maternity leave,
- that she is resigning,
- the intended effective date,
- whether she is serving the 30-day period during leave,
- and how company property and clearance will be handled.
A resignation made in writing is much easier to defend than silence.
XII. Can the employer reject the resignation because the employee is on maternity leave?
Generally, no.
The employer may insist on compliance with the notice period or pursue damages if a legally unjustified immediate resignation caused provable harm. But the employer cannot force the employee to remain in the job against her will merely because she is on maternity leave.
An employer may say:
- “Observe the 30-day rule,” or
- “Complete turnover and clearance.”
But the employer cannot validly say:
- “You are on maternity leave, so you are not allowed to resign,” or
- “Your resignation is invalid unless you return to work first.”
Those positions are difficult to sustain under labor law principles.
XIII. Notice requirements during maternity leave
A. Ordinary resignation
The standard rule remains: 30 days’ written notice.
Nothing in maternity leave status by itself erases this requirement. So if an employee wants a clean, low-conflict resignation, the ideal approach is to serve notice in writing and count the 30 days from receipt by the employer.
This can be done:
- by email,
- by registered mail or courier,
- by company HR portal,
- or by any other reliable written means recognized by the employer.
B. Can the 30-day notice run while the employee is on maternity leave?
Yes, in principle.
There is no reason the notice period cannot run during maternity leave, so long as the resignation notice is validly communicated. That means the employee may submit a resignation while on leave and let the 30-day period lapse during that leave.
This is often the most practical route when the employee has already decided not to return.
C. Immediate resignation
If there is just cause, the employee may resign without the 30-day period. But if the reason is simply personal preference or family planning, the ordinary notice rule still technically applies.
In practice, many employers waive the 30-day period, especially where the employee is already on maternity leave and active work turnover is minimal. But that is an HR accommodation, not an automatic legal rule.
XIV. Personal reasons, childcare, and family priorities as a reason for resignation
Many women resign during maternity leave because:
- they wish to focus on newborn care,
- they lack childcare support,
- they are recovering physically or mentally,
- they want to relocate,
- they need a different work arrangement,
- or they have reassessed work-life priorities after childbirth.
These are real and understandable reasons. But under strict Labor Code analysis, they are usually not “just cause” grounds for immediate resignation in the technical statutory sense. They are usually treated as voluntary resignation for personal reasons, which means the 30-day notice rule ordinarily applies unless waived.
So there is a difference between:
- a morally compelling reason, and
- a legal just cause for immediate resignation.
That distinction matters if the employer later argues that the employee left without proper notice.
XV. Are pregnancy and maternity protected from discrimination?
Yes.
Philippine labor law and women-protective legislation strongly disfavor discrimination based on pregnancy and maternity. An employer cannot lawfully penalize an employee for becoming pregnant, giving birth, or using maternity leave rights.
Examples of unlawful conduct
Potentially unlawful conduct includes:
- refusing to continue employing a woman because she became pregnant;
- treating maternity leave as disloyalty or inconvenience deserving punishment;
- withholding benefits because of pregnancy or childbirth;
- pressuring the employee to resign because she is now a mother;
- singling her out for lesser opportunities because she took leave.
If the employee “resigns” in this atmosphere, the resignation may later be attacked as involuntary.
XVI. What if the employer pressures the employee to resign during maternity leave?
Then the case may cease to be about ordinary resignation and become one about labor standards violation, discrimination, coercion, or constructive dismissal.
Warning signs of forced resignation
A resignation may be legally suspect where the employer:
- drafts the letter for the employee,
- insists she sign immediately,
- says she will not be allowed to return anyway,
- threatens to withhold final pay unless she resigns,
- says the company no longer wants mothers with small children,
- tells her maternity leave made her unreliable,
- or presents resignation as the only alternative to humiliation or baseless charges.
A resignation must be clear, categorical, and voluntary. If there is coercion, it may be invalid.
XVII. Final pay after resignation during maternity leave
A woman who resigns during maternity leave remains entitled to whatever is legally due upon separation.
Final pay may include, as applicable:
- unpaid salary up to the effective resignation date,
- earned but unpaid maternity-related amounts that are already due,
- prorated 13th month pay,
- cash conversion of unused service incentive leave or other convertible leave credits if company policy or law provides,
- unpaid reimbursements,
- and other contractual or policy-based benefits that have accrued.
Separation pay is different
A resigning employee is not generally entitled to separation pay unless:
- it is provided by company policy,
- by contract,
- by collective bargaining agreement,
- or by a specific equitable or exceptional rule recognized in particular cases.
Ordinary voluntary resignation does not usually carry statutory separation pay.
XVIII. 13th month pay after resignation during maternity leave
Yes, a resigning employee is generally entitled to proportionate 13th month pay for the part of the year she rendered service and for earnings included under the governing rules.
Whether particular maternity-related amounts are included in the 13th month base can depend on how the amounts are legally characterized under applicable rules and payroll treatment. But as a general matter, resignation does not wipe out prorated 13th month pay already earned.
The key point is simple: resignation during maternity leave does not forfeit all year-to-date statutory benefits.
XIX. Unused leave credits
Maternity leave itself is a statutory leave and is not the same as vacation leave or service incentive leave.
If the employee has unused leave credits, whether they are convertible to cash depends on:
- the Labor Code minimum rules,
- company policy,
- employment contract,
- CBA if any,
- and the nature of the leave credits.
Convertible leave credits already earned are generally part of final accounting and should be settled according to law and policy.
XX. Certificate of employment
A resigning employee remains entitled to a certificate of employment. The employer cannot lawfully refuse to issue it merely because the employee resigned during maternity leave or chose not to return after giving birth.
The certificate of employment is not a commendation letter. It is a formal document reflecting the fact and period of employment and, where appropriate, the nature of the work.
XXI. Clearance and turnover obligations
Even where resignation is valid, the employee may still be required to complete reasonable clearance processes, such as:
- returning laptop, ID, keys, SIM, files, or records;
- settling accountabilities;
- endorsing passwords or work materials through approved channels;
- completing exit forms.
However, clearance is not supposed to be used abusively to defeat vested wages and benefits. Employers may verify accountabilities, but they cannot indefinitely withhold what is clearly due without lawful basis.
For employees on maternity leave, clearance may be handled remotely where feasible.
XXII. Can the employer withhold final pay because the employee resigned while on maternity leave?
Not lawfully, if the amounts are already due and there is no legitimate, specific basis for withholding or lawful deduction.
Employers often delay final pay because of clearance procedures. Some delay may occur administratively, but the law does not allow employers to use maternity status or resignation timing as a punishment.
The fact that a woman resigned during maternity leave does not strip her of the right to be paid what is legally hers.
XXIII. Can the employer deduct damages because the employee did not finish the 30-day notice?
Potentially, but not automatically.
If the employee resigns without serving the required 30-day notice and without legal just cause, the employer may theoretically claim damages if it can prove actual loss caused by the abrupt departure. In practice, employers do not automatically get to deduct arbitrary amounts from final pay without lawful basis.
Important limits apply:
- deductions must be legally defensible,
- actual damage should be shown,
- company policy cannot override mandatory labor protections,
- and employers cannot invent penalties that are punitive and unsupported.
In maternity situations, employers should be especially careful. Using notice-period arguments as retaliation for childbirth-related resignation can create bigger legal problems.
XXIV. Resignation during maternity leave versus end of fixed-term employment
Another distinction matters.
If the employee is on a valid fixed-term contract that naturally expires during maternity leave, the employment may simply end by expiration of term, not by resignation.
That is different from voluntary resignation.
Likewise, for project employees, seasonal employees, probationary employees, or employees under special arrangements, the analysis may differ depending on the nature of their employment and whether the separation is due to resignation, term expiration, project completion, or valid non-regular status.
Still, maternity rights cannot be erased simply by relabeling the employment action.
XXV. Probationary employees
A probationary employee who goes on maternity leave also retains the right to resign.
However, maternity leave does not automatically guarantee regularization, and resignation during probation ends the employment relation in the same basic manner as with a regular employee.
But the employer cannot exploit probationary status to discriminate on account of pregnancy or maternity. A probationary employee is still protected against unlawful discrimination and coercive resignation.
XXVI. Managerial employees and rank-and-file employees
The right to resign during maternity leave applies to both rank-and-file and managerial employees.
The main difference in practice lies in:
- the complexity of turnover,
- the sensitivity of accounts and information,
- possible confidentiality obligations,
- and contractual post-employment restrictions.
But maternity status does not diminish the fundamental right to resign.
XXVII. What happens to health insurance, HMO, and related benefits?
This depends mainly on company policy and plan rules.
Once the employment relationship ends, employer-sponsored benefits such as:
- HMO coverage,
- group life insurance,
- allowances,
- communications support,
- and other employee-only privileges
may also end, subject to the plan terms and any run-out or extension features.
This is not specific to maternity leave; it is the ordinary consequence of separation from employment. The employee should therefore review:
- the effective date of resignation,
- the benefit cut-off date,
- and whether dependents’ coverage ends immediately or at month-end.
This practical issue is often as important as the labor law issue.
XXVIII. SSS maternity benefit and separated employment status
Where maternity benefits are SSS-linked, what matters greatly is whether the employee had the necessary contribution record and qualifying status under the applicable rules.
A woman who resigns does not necessarily lose the ability to claim a maternity benefit tied to a covered childbirth, especially if the qualifying contributions are already present and the claim falls within the recognized framework for an employed or recently separated member, as the case may be.
The crucial point is that SSS entitlement is not identical to active payroll status on every day of the maternity leave period. Entitlement depends on legal qualification, not merely on whether the employee stayed with the company after childbirth.
Still, the documentary route and payor mechanism may differ depending on whether the woman is still treated as employed at the relevant time or already separated.
XXIX. Common misconceptions
1. “You cannot resign while on maternity leave.”
False. A woman may resign during maternity leave.
2. “You must return to work first before resignation can take effect.”
False. No general rule requires a token physical return.
3. “If you resign, you automatically lose all maternity benefits.”
False. Benefits that have already accrued or vested are not automatically forfeited by resignation.
4. “The employer can refuse to accept your resignation.”
False in the ordinary sense. The employer may regulate notice and clearance, but not abolish the employee’s right to resign.
5. “If the employee does not come back after leave, the employer can always recover the maternity benefit.”
Generally false. Resignation alone does not justify reimbursement of a lawful maternity benefit.
6. “Any resignation during maternity leave is suspicious.”
Not necessarily. Many are entirely voluntary and valid.
7. “Any resignation letter proves voluntariness.”
Also false. A resignation letter can still be challenged if obtained through coercion, pressure, deceit, or discriminatory treatment.
XXX. Best legal analysis by scenario
Scenario 1: Employee gives birth, starts maternity leave, then submits a 30-day resignation notice during leave
This is generally valid. The resignation is ordinarily effective after the notice period. The fact that the notice period runs while she is on leave does not invalidate it. Maternity benefits for the covered leave event should not be defeated merely by the resignation.
Scenario 2: Employee resigns immediately during maternity leave because she wants to focus on childcare
The resignation is likely still effective, but absent employer waiver, the lack of 30-day notice may be raised as a notice issue. That does not usually erase vested maternity benefits, though administrative and monetary disputes can arise.
Scenario 3: Employer tells employee during leave not to come back and asks her to sign a resignation letter
This is highly suspect. The issue may be coercion or constructive dismissal, not valid resignation.
Scenario 4: Employee resigns after receiving maternity pay, and the employer demands reimbursement because she did not return
As a rule, reimbursement is not justified merely because she resigned, unless there was overpayment, fraud, or some other lawful basis.
Scenario 5: Employee’s contract naturally expires during maternity leave
This is not necessarily resignation. The issue becomes whether the contract end was genuine and lawful, and what maternity entitlements remain due.
XXXI. Practical legal guidance for employees
An employee who plans to resign during maternity leave should ideally do the following:
1. Resign in writing
Use a clear resignation letter. Ambiguity creates disputes.
2. State the effective date
Make the timeline definite.
3. Mention notice compliance
If the 30-day period is being served during maternity leave, say so.
4. Keep proof of transmission
Email trail, courier receipt, HR acknowledgment, or screenshot.
5. Preserve maternity-related documents
Medical records, notice to employer, benefit computations, payslips, SSS-related records.
6. Document any pressure or discrimination
If resignation was not truly voluntary, evidence matters.
7. Request final pay computation and certificate of employment
These should be processed despite maternity status.
XXXII. Practical legal guidance for employers
Employers should approach resignation during maternity leave carefully and lawfully.
1. Do not pressure resignation
This is where many employers create legal exposure.
2. Separate maternity entitlement from retention concerns
The employee’s statutory maternity rights should be honored even if she later separates.
3. Process resignation professionally
Treat it like any other resignation, with sensitivity to medical recovery and remote coordination.
4. Avoid automatic clawback assumptions
Do not demand return of maternity benefits without a specific lawful basis.
5. Release final pay and COE properly
Resignation during maternity leave is not misconduct.
6. Watch for discrimination risk
Pregnancy- and maternity-related comments can become powerful evidence against the employer.
XXXIII. Bottom-line legal conclusions
Under Philippine labor law, the following principles are the safest and strongest:
- A woman may validly resign during maternity leave.
- She generally remains bound by the 30-day written notice rule unless she has just cause for immediate resignation or the employer waives the notice.
- She does not need to physically return to work just to make the resignation valid.
- Resignation does not automatically cancel maternity benefits that have already accrued or vested.
- An employer generally cannot demand reimbursement of maternity benefits simply because the employee chose not to return after leave.
- If the resignation was forced, pressured, or tied to pregnancy or maternity discrimination, it may be challenged as involuntary or as constructive dismissal.
- The resigning employee remains entitled to final pay components that are legally due, including prorated 13th month pay and other accrued benefits, subject to law and policy.
- A certificate of employment must still be issued, and maternity status cannot be used as a pretext to withhold lawful dues.
Final legal point
Maternity leave is a shield, not a trap. Philippine law protects a woman’s right to become a mother without losing her dignity as a worker. That protection includes both her right to take maternity leave and her freedom to decide, for personal or lawful reasons, whether she will continue the employment relationship after childbirth. Where the decision to resign is real and voluntary, the law respects it. Where resignation is extracted through pressure, prejudice, or punishment for motherhood, the law may treat it as something very different.