Safe Property Sale Process and Title Protection in the Philippines

A Philippine Legal Article

I. Introduction

In the Philippines, buying or selling real property is never just a matter of signing a deed and paying the price. A property sale involves a chain of legal acts affecting ownership, title, taxes, possession, registry records, family rights, and third-party risks. A transaction that looks simple on paper may later unravel because of a forged signature, unpaid estate taxes, double sale, fake title, unregistered claim, boundary problem, missing spousal consent, tenant issue, adverse possession claim, or fraud in the transfer process.

For that reason, a safe property sale process in the Philippines is really a discipline of title protection. It is about making sure that:

  • the seller truly has the right to sell;
  • the property being sold is the same property covered by the title and tax records;
  • all legally required consents and authorities exist;
  • the buyer’s money is released only under safe conditions;
  • taxes and fees are properly paid;
  • the deed is registrable and actually registered;
  • and the buyer’s ownership is protected against later attack.

Philippine property law gives strong importance to registration, but registration alone does not solve everything. A clean-looking certificate of title can still conceal risks if the buyer ignores due diligence. At the same time, a seller who carelessly releases possession or title documents without secure payment arrangements also exposes themselves to major loss.

This article explains the Philippine legal framework on safe property sale and title protection, the complete due diligence process, the legal significance of title verification, the role of contracts and deeds, tax and registry steps, family and corporate authority issues, common fraud patterns, and the best protective sequence for both buyers and sellers.


II. Why property sale in the Philippines is legally sensitive

Real property transactions in the Philippines are sensitive because several systems overlap:

  • civil law on sales and ownership;
  • land registration law;
  • family law;
  • estate and succession law;
  • tax law;
  • local government assessment rules;
  • notarial law;
  • corporate or agency authority rules;
  • possession and tenancy rules.

A sale may fail not only because the seller is dishonest, but because:

  • the property belongs to an estate not yet settled;
  • a spouse did not consent;
  • the title is real but the seller is not the proper owner;
  • taxes were never updated;
  • the description on the title does not match the actual land;
  • a court case or adverse claim exists;
  • the deed was signed but never properly registered.

So “safe sale process” means protecting against both fraud and legal defect.


III. Basic legal framework

A. Civil Code on sale

The Civil Code governs contracts of sale, delivery, obligations of buyer and seller, warranties, hidden defects, good faith, and transfers of ownership. In land sales, the sale is usually perfected by consent on the object and price, but perfection alone is not the same as full protection of ownership against the world.

B. Land registration law

For titled land, the registration system is central. The certificate of title and the Registry of Deeds structure are designed to promote stability of ownership and notice to third parties. But the registry system protects best when the transaction is properly documented and registered.

C. Family law

If the property is conjugal, community, inherited with co-heirs, or occupied as a family home, family-law issues can be decisive.

D. Tax law and local government regulation

Transfers trigger national and local tax consequences, including documentary and transfer-related requirements necessary before registration can proceed.

E. Notarial law

Because deeds of sale are usually notarized, defects in notarization can create serious risk. A notarized document becomes a public document, but fake or defective notarization can still later be attacked.


IV. The first crucial distinction: titled vs untitled property

A safe sale process depends heavily on whether the property is:

  1. titled property;
  2. untitled property;
  3. property with pending title issues;
  4. condominium unit with condominium certificate or related title structure.

A. Titled property

This is generally safer, but not automatically safe. A title must still be verified, and the seller’s authority must still be checked.

B. Untitled property

This is much riskier. The buyer may be acquiring only possessory rights, tax declaration-based claims, or imperfect title interests. Greater caution is required because there is no Torrens title providing the same level of registry protection.

C. Practical consequence

A buyer should never treat untitled property as though it were legally equivalent to titled land just because the seller says the property has “tax declaration only.”


V. The certificate of title is central, but not enough by itself

In the Philippines, one of the first things a buyer asks for is the title. That is correct, but insufficient.

The title should answer questions such as:

  • Who is the registered owner?
  • What is the title number?
  • What is the technical description?
  • Are there annotations?
  • Is there a mortgage, lien, adverse claim, notice of levy, lis pendens, or other encumbrance?
  • Does the area match the actual land shown by the seller?

But title review alone does not answer:

  • whether the title is fake;
  • whether the owner is alive and capable;
  • whether the seller is the same person as the registered owner;
  • whether the title is already subject to a hidden dispute;
  • whether the property is under estate or family controversy;
  • whether the seller’s ID and authority are real.

So title review must be paired with broader due diligence.


VI. Verify the title directly with the Registry of Deeds

A safe property purchase requires independent verification of the title. The buyer should not rely only on:

  • a photocopy from the seller;
  • a screenshot;
  • a broker’s assurance;
  • a scanned image sent online.

The proper approach is to verify the title through the Registry of Deeds or the official title verification channels available within the land registration system.

This helps determine:

  • whether the title exists in the registry;
  • whether the title details match the seller’s copy;
  • whether annotations exist;
  • whether there are suspicious discrepancies.

This is one of the most important anti-fraud steps in Philippine real estate practice.


VII. Examine all annotations on the title

A clean title is not simply a title with the owner’s name. The buyer must read the annotations carefully.

Common annotations may include:

  • real estate mortgage;
  • notice of levy;
  • adverse claim;
  • notice of lis pendens;
  • easement;
  • attachment;
  • restrictions on transfer;
  • usufruct;
  • lease notices;
  • rights of way;
  • court orders;
  • reconstitution notes;
  • consolidation or subdivision references.

An annotation can drastically affect the value, transferability, or risk profile of the property. A buyer who ignores it may buy a lawsuit instead of safe ownership.


VIII. Confirm that the seller is the registered owner or is properly authorized

One of the biggest dangers in property sales is dealing with someone who looks like the owner but is not legally authorized.

The buyer must confirm:

  1. the identity of the registered owner;
  2. whether the seller is that same person;
  3. if not, what authority the seller has.

Possible valid seller situations include:

  • the registered owner personally selling;
  • a duly authorized attorney-in-fact under valid authority;
  • a corporation acting through authorized officers;
  • heirs selling after lawful estate settlement and title transfer or with proper authority;
  • co-owners selling only their share unless all co-owners join.

A buyer should never assume that “the caretaker,” “the eldest son,” “the broker,” or “the spouse” can validly sell on behalf of the owner without proof.


IX. Check the seller’s civil status and spousal consent issues

Family law is one of the most overlooked danger zones.

If the property is:

  • conjugal property;
  • community property under marriage;
  • acquired during marriage;
  • family-home related;
  • inherited but later mixed with marital regimes in certain ways;

then spousal consent issues may arise.

A. Why this matters

A sale by only one spouse of property requiring the other spouse’s consent can be void or voidable depending on the legal setting. A buyer who ignores this may later lose the property or enter costly litigation.

B. Practical due diligence

The buyer should examine:

  • seller’s civil status;
  • marriage certificate, where relevant;
  • title entries showing marital status;
  • basis of acquisition;
  • whether the spouse must sign the deed.

A property title showing one spouse’s name does not always mean only that spouse’s consent is enough.


X. If the owner is deceased: estate issues must be resolved

A very common and dangerous situation in the Philippines is where the titled owner is already dead, but the heirs are trying to sell as though they automatically stepped into full ownership.

That is not how safe conveyancing works.

A. Death does not automatically transfer registrable title to one heir

Upon death, rights pass through succession, but registry and conveyancing consequences must still be properly settled.

B. Risky situations include:

  • no extrajudicial settlement yet;
  • no judicial settlement yet;
  • multiple heirs not participating;
  • estate taxes or settlement issues unresolved;
  • title still in decedent’s name;
  • one heir pretending to sell the whole property.

C. Safe approach

If the owner is deceased, the buyer must carefully verify:

  • who the heirs are;
  • whether the estate has been settled;
  • whether all heirs are participating or properly represented;
  • whether the title can be validly transferred;
  • whether taxes and documentary requirements arising from succession have been addressed.

Buying from heirs without proper estate groundwork is one of the most common ways buyers inherit legal trouble.


XI. If the seller is acting under a Special Power of Attorney

A Special Power of Attorney (SPA) can be legitimate, but must be examined closely.

The buyer should check:

  • whether the SPA specifically authorizes sale of the exact property;
  • whether it is still valid and not revoked;
  • whether it was properly notarized;
  • whether the principal is alive;
  • whether the principal had capacity at the time;
  • whether the attorney-in-fact is acting within authority.

Very important rule

Agency ends upon death of the principal in ordinary cases. So an SPA signed by a person who later died may no longer support a later sale unless the legal setting clearly justifies otherwise. Buyers who ignore this can end up with a void transaction.


XII. If the seller is a corporation or partnership

If the registered owner is a corporation, it is not enough that a corporate officer says they are authorized.

The buyer should require proof of:

  • corporate existence;
  • board or corporate authority to sell;
  • authority of the signatory;
  • consistency between corporate records and title records.

Corporate property cannot be safely sold based on casual verbal assurances from a manager or broker.


XIII. Secure a certified true copy of the tax declaration and tax records

The title is not the only record that matters. A safe buyer should also examine:

  • tax declaration;
  • real property tax receipts;
  • assessment records;
  • payment status of local real property taxes.

Why this matters

These documents help reveal:

  • whether taxes are current or delinquent;
  • whether the property being shown matches the records;
  • whether the seller is hiding tax arrears;
  • whether there are area or classification inconsistencies.

Tax declaration is not title, but it is a useful due diligence document. Delinquent taxes can become a practical burden and warning sign.


XIV. Check if the property taxes are updated

Unpaid real property taxes do not always invalidate the sale itself, but they can create:

  • liens;
  • financial burden;
  • complications in transfer;
  • evidence of poor record maintenance;
  • warning signs about the seller’s reliability.

A prudent buyer should know before paying:

  • whether there are tax arrears;
  • who will shoulder them;
  • whether the contract clearly allocates responsibility.

This should be written into the sale documentation.


XV. Conduct an actual site inspection

A safe property sale process always includes physical inspection of the land or unit.

This is essential to verify:

  • actual possession;
  • occupancy status;
  • boundaries;
  • encroachments;
  • access roads;
  • easements;
  • whether the land shown is really the titled land;
  • whether someone else is living there, farming there, or claiming it.

Buyers should be wary of transactions conducted entirely on paper or online without site inspection. Fraudsters sometimes show one property but sell another.


XVI. Compare the technical description with the actual property

The title’s technical description should match the property being sold. A buyer should examine:

  • lot number;
  • subdivision plan references;
  • area;
  • boundaries;
  • adjoining lots;
  • survey markers where possible.

If necessary, a geodetic engineer or technical professional may be needed, especially when:

  • boundaries are unclear;
  • the land is large;
  • informal occupants exist;
  • the seller points vaguely to “around this area.”

A title is only as useful as its accurate connection to the actual land on the ground.


XVII. Verify possession and occupancy

A buyer should ask:

  • Who is in possession now?
  • Is the seller actually occupying the property?
  • Is there a tenant, lessee, caretaker, informal settler, borrower, or relative living there?
  • Is possession peaceful?

A title buyer can still face major post-sale difficulty if the property is occupied by people who resist turnover. Thus, possession terms must be addressed clearly in the contract:

  • when possession transfers;
  • who removes occupants;
  • what happens if turnover fails.

Title safety is incomplete without possession safety.


XVIII. Check for tenants, lease rights, and agrarian issues

A property may be subject to:

  • residential lease;
  • commercial lease;
  • agricultural tenancy;
  • occupancy rights;
  • agrarian reform complications.

These issues can survive the sale in ways the buyer did not expect. A buyer should not assume that ownership automatically means immediate vacant possession.

If the property is agricultural or appears to be farmed by others, the buyer must be especially cautious. Agrarian and tenancy issues can drastically alter what rights are actually being acquired.


XIX. Ask whether the property is mortgaged

Many properties are sold while still under mortgage. That is not automatically illegal, but it is risky if not managed correctly.

Safe questions include:

  • Is the title annotated with a real estate mortgage?
  • What bank or lender is involved?
  • How much is outstanding?
  • Will the sale proceeds pay off the mortgage?
  • At what stage will the title be released?

Safe process matters

A buyer should not simply hand over full payment and hope the seller later clears the mortgage. Mortgage release should be built into a controlled payment and document-release structure.


XX. Be alert to forged titles and forged deeds

Property fraud in the Philippines often involves:

  • fake owner’s duplicate titles;
  • forged signatures;
  • fake IDs;
  • forged notarization;
  • impersonation of absent owners, especially OFWs, elderly owners, or deceased owners.

Red flags include:

  • rush sale at a suspiciously low price;
  • refusal to meet at proper offices;
  • insistence on cash without documentation;
  • inconsistent IDs;
  • inability of the seller to explain title history;
  • title that looks physically irregular;
  • reluctance to allow registry verification.

A buyer should assume fraud is possible until careful due diligence proves otherwise.


XXI. Use a written preliminary agreement when appropriate

Before full sale, parties may use:

  • letter of intent;
  • reservation agreement;
  • contract to sell;
  • earnest money agreement;
  • option agreement.

The correct instrument depends on the structure of the transaction.

Why this matters

A preliminary agreement can define:

  • price;
  • due diligence period;
  • documentary conditions;
  • who pays taxes and fees;
  • deadline for title verification;
  • consequences if defects are found;
  • when earnest money becomes refundable or forfeitable.

A buyer should avoid paying “reservation” or “earnest money” based only on verbal assurances.


XXII. Deed of Absolute Sale vs Contract to Sell

This distinction is important.

A. Deed of Absolute Sale

Usually used when ownership is intended to transfer upon execution and delivery, subject to registration and other legal consequences.

B. Contract to Sell

Often used where full payment or conditions must first be completed before the seller becomes bound to convey ownership fully.

Using the wrong instrument can create confusion. For example, parties sometimes sign a deed of absolute sale before the buyer is ready, before the mortgage is cleared, or before taxes are understood. That can create avoidable risk.


XXIII. Never release full payment casually

For buyers, the most dangerous mistake is releasing the full purchase price before:

  • title is verified;
  • seller authority is confirmed;
  • taxes and obligations are clearly allocated;
  • transfer documents are complete;
  • the deed is properly signed and notarized;
  • title transfer pathway is secured.

For sellers, the reverse danger is releasing the signed deed and original title without secure payment.

Safe principle

Payment and document release should be structured so neither side becomes helpless. Serious transactions often use staged payment, controlled release, escrow-like arrangements, or coordinated closing procedures.


XXIV. Use controlled payment arrangements

A safe Philippine property sale often benefits from a structured closing process, such as:

  • earnest money only after initial due diligence;
  • balance payable only upon presentation of complete documents;
  • payment partly retained pending tax clearance or mortgage release;
  • bank-to-bank or manager’s check delivery at closing;
  • release conditioned on simultaneous deed signing and title turnover;
  • escrow-style handling in more complex cases.

The goal is to avoid the two worst outcomes:

  1. buyer pays but cannot transfer title;
  2. seller signs away documents but does not get paid.

XXV. Original owner’s duplicate title must be handled carefully

For titled property, the owner’s duplicate certificate is a crucial document. The buyer should confirm:

  • that it exists;
  • that it is physically in the seller’s control or lawfully with a lender if mortgaged;
  • that it matches registry records;
  • that it will be delivered under safe conditions.

A sale where the seller cannot produce the owner’s duplicate title is high-risk unless there is a legally satisfactory explanation and controlled process to deal with it.


XXVI. The deed must be accurate and complete

A safe Deed of Absolute Sale should accurately state:

  • names and personal details of parties;
  • marital status;
  • authority of representatives, if any;
  • exact title number and property description;
  • purchase price;
  • tax and expense allocation;
  • possession terms;
  • warranties;
  • signatures of proper parties.

Errors in the deed can delay transfer, create tax issues, or support later attacks on validity.


XXVII. Notarization is essential, but notarization alone is not enough

Real property sale documents are generally expected to be notarized so they can become public documents and be registrable.

Why notarization matters

  • it supports authenticity;
  • it is usually required for registry purposes;
  • it upgrades the document’s formal character.

But notarization is not magic

A notarized forged deed is still a forged deed. A fake appearance before a notary can still later be challenged. Buyers should therefore not rely blindly on notarization without identity and authority checks.


XXVIII. Pay the proper taxes and fees

After execution of the sale, transfer-related taxes and fees must be paid. These commonly include tax and registration obligations necessary before transfer can be recorded.

Why this matters

Without proper tax compliance:

  • transfer cannot usually be fully completed in the registry;
  • penalties may accrue;
  • the buyer may hold only paper rights without completed registry protection.

Contract clarity is essential

The contract should clearly state who shoulders:

  • transfer taxes;
  • documentary taxes;
  • registration fees;
  • unpaid real property taxes, if any;
  • broker’s commission, if any.

Never leave this to assumption.


XXIX. Secure the tax clearance and transfer requirements needed for registration

The Registry of Deeds will require documentary compliance before title transfer can be completed. These requirements often depend on tax and local government compliance.

The buyer and seller should make sure that:

  • all supporting documents are complete;
  • taxes are paid on time;
  • the deed and title details match;
  • no documentary inconsistency blocks issuance of a new title.

A sale is not truly safe until the transfer becomes registrable and is actually registered.


XXX. Registration is the decisive step for title protection

This is one of the most important rules in Philippine property law.

A signed deed by itself is not the full end of the process. For titled property, the buyer’s strongest protection comes when the conveyance is registered and a new certificate of title is issued in the buyer’s name.

Why this matters

Until registration:

  • third parties may not be bound in the same way;
  • double sale risks can materialize;
  • the seller may still appear as owner in registry records;
  • the buyer’s rights may be vulnerable against later registrants in bad situations.

A buyer who pays but does not register promptly is leaving the transaction dangerously incomplete.


XXXI. Double sale risk

One classic Philippine property danger is double sale: the seller sells the same property to more than one buyer.

In such cases, issues of:

  • good faith,
  • possession,
  • and especially registration

can become decisive depending on the legal setting.

The safest practical defense against double sale is:

  1. verify title first,
  2. transact in good faith,
  3. register promptly.

Delay in registration can turn a valid purchase into a litigation nightmare.


XXXII. Title transfer after registration: obtain the new title in the buyer’s name

The process is not complete until the buyer obtains the new title or registry-issued ownership record reflecting the transfer.

The buyer should confirm:

  • the old title has been cancelled where appropriate;
  • the new title has issued correctly;
  • annotations are accurate;
  • names, status, and technical details are correct.

Clerical or documentary errors should be corrected immediately before they become future problems.


XXXIII. Turnover of possession and keys, documents, and improvements

A safe sale should also include formal turnover of:

  • possession of the land or unit;
  • keys and access devices;
  • tax declarations;
  • building plans or permits, where relevant;
  • association clearances or condominium documents, where relevant;
  • utility account coordination.

Possession turnover should not be left vague. The contract should say when and in what condition turnover happens.


XXXIV. Condominium-specific concerns

For condominium sales, the buyer should also check:

  • condominium certificate or title details;
  • condominium corporation or association records;
  • dues and arrears;
  • house rules and transfer requirements;
  • actual unit boundaries and parking rights;
  • whether the seller really owns the parking slot if separately titled or assigned.

A condo sale is still a property sale, but with building-management and common-area consequences layered on top.


XXXV. Buy from developers or brokers carefully

Even when dealing with a developer, broker, or sales agent, the buyer should verify:

  • authority to sell;
  • project legality;
  • title basis of the project;
  • existence of licenses or permits relevant to the project type;
  • exact unit or lot identification;
  • payment schedule and refund consequences.

Buyers should not assume that a polished sales office eliminates due diligence. Developer transactions have their own regulatory and documentary issues.


XXXVI. Brokers and agents are not substitutes for due diligence

A licensed or experienced broker can help, but the buyer should still independently verify:

  • title;
  • seller authority;
  • encumbrances;
  • taxes;
  • possession.

A broker’s role is helpful, but legal responsibility for a careless purchase can still fall heavily on the buyer. Trust is not a substitute for registry verification and documentation.


XXXVII. Family home and occupant sensitivity

Even if the title is clean, a buyer should be cautious where the property is clearly:

  • the seller’s family home;
  • occupied by elderly parents or children;
  • under domestic conflict;
  • under marital breakdown.

These situations may signal:

  • hidden family disputes;
  • unconsented sale;
  • emotional resistance to turnover;
  • possible court action later.

Legal safety includes social and possession realism, not only paper review.


XXXVIII. Safe seller practices

Title protection is not only for buyers. Sellers also need safe process.

A safe seller should:

  • verify the buyer’s capacity to pay;
  • avoid signing incomplete documents;
  • avoid handing over the owner’s duplicate title before secure arrangements are in place;
  • require traceable payment;
  • keep copies of all signed documents;
  • state clearly who handles taxes and fees;
  • make turnover conditional on the agreed payment stage;
  • avoid letting brokers control original title documents casually.

A careless seller can lose both the property and the price.


XXXIX. Red flags that should stop the deal

A prudent buyer or seller should pause or stop if any of these appear:

  • seller refuses registry verification;
  • title copy and registry records do not match;
  • seller cannot produce valid ID or authority;
  • spouse is absent without explanation in a married-owner sale;
  • owner is deceased and heirs have no settlement documents;
  • price is far below market without credible explanation;
  • rushed demand for immediate cash payment;
  • unclear boundaries or mismatched lot description;
  • property is occupied by hostile third parties;
  • mortgage exists but no clear release plan is presented;
  • documents are inconsistent or suspiciously recent.

Many bad transactions can be avoided simply by refusing to proceed when red flags appear.


XL. Due diligence checklist for a buyer

A safe buyer in the Philippines should generally do the following:

  1. get a copy of the title;
  2. verify it with the Registry of Deeds;
  3. examine annotations;
  4. verify seller identity and authority;
  5. check civil status and spousal consent issues;
  6. inspect tax declarations and tax payments;
  7. conduct site inspection;
  8. verify possession and occupants;
  9. check mortgage, liens, or pending disputes;
  10. confirm estate settlement if owner is deceased;
  11. use a proper written contract;
  12. structure payment safely;
  13. execute an accurate notarized deed;
  14. pay transfer-related taxes and fees properly;
  15. register promptly;
  16. secure issuance of the new title;
  17. complete possession turnover cleanly.

This is the core of title protection through process discipline.


XLI. Due diligence checklist for a seller

A safe seller should generally:

  1. confirm readiness and authority to sell;
  2. prepare clean title and supporting records;
  3. disclose known encumbrances honestly;
  4. coordinate clearly on taxes and fees;
  5. insist on documented, traceable payment;
  6. avoid surrendering original title too early;
  7. sign only complete and accurate deeds;
  8. verify buyer identity and payment instrument;
  9. keep copies of all documents;
  10. document turnover of possession.

A seller who treats the transaction casually may later face unpaid balance disputes, forged insertions, or title misuse.


XLII. Key legal principles

  1. A safe property sale in the Philippines requires more than a signed deed; it requires full due diligence, secure payment structure, tax compliance, and registration.

  2. The certificate of title is central but not self-sufficient. Title verification must be paired with seller identity, authority, tax, possession, and family-law checks.

  3. Buyers must verify the title directly with the Registry of Deeds and read all annotations carefully.

  4. Spousal consent, estate settlement, co-ownership, and agency authority can make or break the validity of a sale.

  5. Site inspection and possession verification are essential. Paper ownership does not automatically mean clean physical turnover.

  6. Mortgage, tenant, tax delinquency, and occupant issues must be addressed before payment is fully released.

  7. Notarization is necessary for most sale documentation, but notarization alone does not cure forgery or lack of authority.

  8. Prompt registration is one of the strongest protections against later disputes, including double sale.

  9. Original title documents and purchase money should be exchanged only under controlled, documented conditions.

  10. Untitled property, inherited property, and rushed bargain sales require much greater caution than ordinary clean titled sales.


XLIII. Conclusion

In the Philippines, the safest property sale process is not a single document or a single office visit. It is a sequence of protective legal acts designed to ensure that the buyer acquires valid, registrable, and defensible ownership, and that the seller receives secure and properly documented payment. Title protection begins before the deed is signed—through verification of title, authority, identity, taxes, possession, and family or estate issues—and continues after signing through tax compliance, registration, and actual issuance of a new title.

The most important practical truth is this: real estate risk usually enters through shortcuts. Buyers get into trouble when they skip registry verification, ignore annotations, trust undocumented heirs, or pay too early. Sellers get into trouble when they sign incomplete deeds, release original title documents without secure payment, or rely on verbal promises. A safe property sale in the Philippines therefore depends on discipline, documentation, and proper sequencing.

In legal terms, the decisive questions are always these: Is the seller truly authorized? Is the title genuine and clean? Are all necessary consents present? Is the payment structure safe? And will the transfer be properly registered so the buyer’s ownership is protected against the world? If those questions are answered carefully and correctly, the sale becomes far safer. If they are ignored, the transaction can quickly turn from investment into litigation.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.