Transfer of Voter Registration Requirements in the Philippines

Introduction

The transfer of voter registration is the process by which a registered voter changes the place where they are registered to vote. In the Philippine context, this usually happens when a voter moves residence from one city, municipality, district, or barangay to another and wishes to vote in the new place of residence.

Voter registration and transfer are governed principally by the Voter’s Registration Act of 1996, or Republic Act No. 8189, together with the rules and resolutions issued by the Commission on Elections, commonly known as COMELEC.

Transfer of registration is important because a voter may vote only in the place where they are duly registered, subject to election law and COMELEC rules. A person who has moved residence but has not transferred their registration may remain registered in their old voting place and may be unable to vote conveniently or properly in their new locality.


I. Nature of Voter Registration in the Philippines

Voter registration in the Philippines is a continuing administrative process conducted by the COMELEC. It is not merely a listing of names. It determines who may vote, where they may vote, and under which precinct, barangay, city, municipality, legislative district, or electoral jurisdiction they belong.

A voter’s registration record contains identifying information such as the voter’s name, address, date of birth, civil status, biometrics, precinct assignment, and other details required by COMELEC.

When a registered voter changes residence, the voter does not register as a new voter again. Instead, the voter files an application for transfer of registration record.


II. Meaning of Transfer of Voter Registration

Transfer of voter registration means the movement of a voter’s registration record from one voting jurisdiction to another.

It may involve:

  1. Transfer within the same city or municipality

    This happens when a voter changes residence from one barangay to another within the same city or municipality.

  2. Transfer from one city or municipality to another

    This happens when a voter moves to a different city or municipality.

  3. Transfer from one district to another

    In cities with multiple legislative or councilor districts, a voter may need to transfer registration when moving to another district.

  4. Transfer from overseas voting registration to local registration

    A Filipino registered overseas may later return to the Philippines and apply to transfer their registration to a local voting jurisdiction, subject to COMELEC rules.

  5. Transfer from local registration to overseas voting registration

    A Filipino voter who moves abroad may apply for overseas voting registration or transfer through the proper overseas voting process.


III. Legal Basis

The principal law on voter registration is Republic Act No. 8189, known as the Voter’s Registration Act of 1996.

COMELEC is constitutionally empowered to enforce and administer all laws and regulations relating to the conduct of elections, plebiscites, initiatives, referenda, and recalls. This includes prescribing the forms, documentary requirements, filing periods, procedures, and modes for registration and transfer.

Other relevant legal and regulatory sources include:

  • The 1987 Philippine Constitution
  • The Omnibus Election Code
  • Republic Act No. 8189
  • COMELEC resolutions on voter registration
  • COMELEC rules on biometrics, deactivation, reactivation, transfer, and correction of entries
  • Laws and rules on overseas voting, where applicable

Because COMELEC issues specific resolutions for each registration period, filing schedules and procedural details may vary depending on the election cycle.


IV. Who May Apply for Transfer of Registration

A person may apply for transfer of voter registration if they are:

  1. A registered voter in the Philippines or, where applicable, a registered overseas voter;
  2. A Filipino citizen;
  3. At least eighteen years of age on or before election day;
  4. A resident of the Philippines for at least one year;
  5. A resident of the place where they propose to vote for at least six months immediately preceding election day;
  6. Not otherwise disqualified by law; and
  7. Able to establish that they have moved residence to the new address.

The key point is that transfer presupposes an existing registration. A person who has never registered before must apply for new registration, not transfer.


V. Residency Requirement

Residency is central to the transfer of voter registration.

Under Philippine election law, a voter must be a resident of:

  • the Philippines for at least one year, and
  • the city or municipality where they intend to vote for at least six months immediately preceding the election.

For transfer purposes, the voter must be able to show that their residence has changed to the new city, municipality, district, or barangay.

In election law, “residence” is generally understood as domicile. Domicile means the place where a person has a fixed permanent home and to which they intend to return whenever absent. It is not always the same as temporary physical presence.

Thus, a person temporarily staying in a place for school, work, medical treatment, or short-term employment may not automatically be considered a resident for voting purposes unless there is an intention to make that place their domicile.


VI. Types of Transfer Applications

A. Transfer Within the Same City or Municipality

A voter who moves to another barangay within the same city or municipality may apply for transfer within the same locality.

This is common when a voter moves house but remains within the same local government unit. The voter’s city or municipal registration remains under the same Election Officer, but the precinct, barangay, or district assignment may change.

B. Transfer to Another City or Municipality

A voter who moves from one city or municipality to another must file an application for transfer with the Office of the Election Officer having jurisdiction over the new residence.

The voter’s registration record will be transferred from the old locality to the new locality after approval.

C. Transfer With Correction of Entries

A voter may also request transfer and correction at the same time if there are errors or outdated entries in the voter record, such as:

  • misspelled name;
  • incorrect birth date;
  • incorrect civil status;
  • wrong address;
  • change of surname due to marriage, annulment, declaration of nullity, or court order;
  • clerical or typographical errors.

COMELEC forms usually allow applications for transfer and correction of entries, subject to supporting documents.

D. Transfer With Reactivation

If a voter’s registration has been deactivated, the voter may need to apply for reactivation, and if they have moved residence, they may also apply for transfer.

Deactivation may occur when a voter fails to vote in two successive regular elections, is declared disqualified by final judgment, or falls under other grounds provided by law.

A deactivated voter is not a new voter. Their record exists but is inactive. They must apply for reactivation before they can vote again.


VII. Basic Requirements for Transfer of Voter Registration

The usual requirements include:

  1. Personal appearance before the Office of the Election Officer

    The applicant must generally appear personally at the COMELEC office of the city or municipality where they seek to transfer.

  2. Accomplished application form

    The applicant must fill out the prescribed COMELEC voter registration application form.

  3. Valid identification document

    The applicant must present valid ID showing identity and, where possible, address.

  4. Proof of residence or address

    COMELEC may require or consider documents showing the applicant’s new residence.

  5. Biometrics capture or verification

    The applicant’s photograph, fingerprints, and signature may be captured or updated.

  6. Oath or attestation

    The applicant signs the application under oath, certifying the truth of the information provided.

  7. Approval by the Election Registration Board

    The application is subject to approval by the Election Registration Board.


VIII. Valid Identification Documents

COMELEC generally requires proof of identity. Valid IDs may include government-issued or recognized identification documents.

Commonly accepted IDs include:

  • Philippine passport;
  • driver’s license;
  • national ID or Philippine Identification card;
  • postal ID;
  • UMID;
  • SSS ID;
  • GSIS ID;
  • PRC ID;
  • Integrated Bar of the Philippines ID;
  • student ID, where accepted;
  • employee ID;
  • senior citizen ID;
  • PWD ID;
  • NBI clearance;
  • police clearance;
  • barangay certification or barangay ID, where accepted;
  • other government-issued IDs bearing the applicant’s photo and signature.

COMELEC rules may specify which IDs are acceptable for a given registration period. Some documents may be accepted only when they sufficiently establish identity.

A community tax certificate, or cedula, is generally not treated as a primary proof of identity for voter registration purposes.


IX. Proof of Residence

Although COMELEC primarily requires the applicant to state and swear to their residence, proof of residence may be requested or useful, especially when the applicant’s address is questioned.

Possible proof of residence may include:

  • barangay certificate of residency;
  • lease contract;
  • utility bill;
  • property title;
  • tax declaration;
  • homeowner association certification;
  • employer certification showing local assignment;
  • school records showing residence;
  • government correspondence addressed to the applicant;
  • affidavit of residence;
  • other documents showing actual residence in the area.

The exact requirements may depend on COMELEC’s current rules, the local Election Officer’s implementation, and whether the applicant’s residency is challenged.


X. Procedure for Transfer of Voter Registration

Step 1: Determine the Correct COMELEC Office

The voter must file the application in the city or municipality where they now reside or intend to vote.

For example, a voter formerly registered in Quezon City who moved to Cebu City must file the transfer application with the Office of the Election Officer in Cebu City, not in Quezon City.

Step 2: Prepare Identification and Supporting Documents

The voter should bring a valid ID and documents showing the new residence, especially if the ID still reflects the old address.

Step 3: Personally Appear at the COMELEC Office or Authorized Registration Site

The voter appears before the Election Officer or authorized registration personnel.

COMELEC may also conduct satellite registration in malls, barangay halls, schools, universities, or other public venues. If satellite registration is available, transfer applications may be accepted there, subject to COMELEC instructions.

Step 4: Fill Out the Application Form

The voter fills out the prescribed application form and indicates that the application is for transfer of registration record.

The form normally asks for:

  • full name;
  • date and place of birth;
  • sex;
  • civil status;
  • citizenship;
  • current address;
  • previous address;
  • previous registration details, if known;
  • period of residence;
  • contact details;
  • type of application;
  • declaration under oath.

Step 5: Biometrics Capture or Update

The applicant’s photograph, fingerprints, and signature may be captured. If biometrics already exist, COMELEC may verify or update them.

Biometrics are important because voters without biometrics may be unable to vote under applicable registration rules.

Step 6: Posting and Hearing by the Election Registration Board

Applications are not automatically approved upon filing.

They are submitted to the Election Registration Board, which acts on applications for registration, transfer, reactivation, correction, and related matters.

The Election Registration Board may approve or disapprove the application after the required process.

Step 7: Approval and Transfer of Record

Once approved, the voter’s record is transferred to the new locality, barangay, district, or precinct, as applicable.

The voter should later verify their status and precinct assignment through COMELEC’s official channels or with the local Election Office.


XI. The Election Registration Board

The Election Registration Board, often called the ERB, is the body that acts on applications for voter registration and related changes.

It generally consists of:

  • the Election Officer as chairperson;
  • the public school official designated by law or rule;
  • the local civil registrar or city/municipal treasurer, as provided by law and COMELEC rules.

The ERB determines whether applications should be approved or disapproved. It may act on applications for:

  • new registration;
  • transfer of registration;
  • reactivation;
  • correction of entries;
  • inclusion;
  • exclusion;
  • other voter record matters.

A transfer application becomes effective only after approval by the ERB.


XII. Filing Period

Transfer of registration may be filed only during the voter registration period set by COMELEC.

Registration is generally continuing, but it is suspended during certain periods before an election. Under election law, registration is usually prohibited within a specified period before election day. COMELEC announces the exact dates for each election cycle.

A voter should not wait until the campaign period or election day. Transfer applications must be completed and approved before the registration deadline.

Failure to file within the registration period means the voter will remain registered in the old locality for that election, unless other lawful arrangements apply.


XIII. Transfer During Election Period

A voter cannot simply transfer registration shortly before election day if registration has already closed.

COMELEC imposes registration deadlines to allow time for:

  • processing of applications;
  • publication and posting;
  • ERB hearings;
  • approval or disapproval;
  • precinct assignment;
  • preparation of the certified list of voters;
  • printing and distribution of election documents.

Once registration closes, late applications are generally not accepted for the upcoming election.


XIV. Transfer and the Six-Month Residence Rule

A voter who transfers must satisfy the six-month residence requirement in the new locality before election day.

For example, if election day is May 12, the voter must generally have been a resident of the new city or municipality for at least six months immediately preceding that date.

A voter who moved only shortly before the election may not qualify to transfer to the new locality for that election, even if they genuinely intend to live there.

The voter may still remain registered in the old locality if their registration has not been transferred, but issues may arise if they no longer reside there. The facts of domicile and residence are important.


XV. Transfer and Change of Barangay

When the move is only from one barangay to another within the same city or municipality, the voter may still need to file a transfer or change of address so that the precinct assignment matches the new barangay.

This matters because barangay elections, local contests, district contests, and precinct assignments depend on the voter’s address.

Failure to update the barangay address may result in the voter being assigned to the wrong barangay or precinct.


XVI. Transfer and Change of Legislative District

Some cities are divided into multiple legislative districts or councilor districts. A change of address within the same city may still affect the voter’s district.

For example, if a voter moves from one district of a highly urbanized city to another district, the voter may need to update their registration record to vote for the correct district representative or local council candidates.

The voter should disclose the exact new address to allow COMELEC to determine the proper precinct and district.


XVII. Transfer and Deactivated Registration

A voter whose record has been deactivated cannot vote unless the record is reactivated.

Common grounds for deactivation include:

  • failure to vote in two successive regular elections;
  • loss of Filipino citizenship;
  • disqualification by final judgment;
  • declaration of insanity or incompetence by competent authority;
  • other grounds provided by law.

If a deactivated voter has also changed residence, the voter should file for reactivation and transfer. The application may be processed under the appropriate COMELEC form or procedure.


XVIII. Transfer and Double or Multiple Registration

A voter must not register again as a new voter in the new locality if already registered elsewhere.

Double or multiple registration is prohibited. A voter who moves residence must apply for transfer, not new registration.

Multiple registration may expose a person to cancellation of registration and possible election offense liability, depending on the facts.

COMELEC maintains voter databases and may identify duplicate records through biometrics and other verification methods.


XIX. Transfer and Correction of Personal Details

A voter may request correction of entries together with transfer. This is useful when the voter’s record contains outdated or incorrect information.

Common corrections include:

  • typographical errors in name;
  • change of surname after marriage;
  • reversion to maiden name;
  • correction of birth date;
  • correction of sex or civil status;
  • update of address;
  • correction of place of birth.

Supporting documents may be required, such as:

  • birth certificate;
  • marriage certificate;
  • court order;
  • certificate of finality;
  • PSA-issued civil registry document;
  • valid ID;
  • other relevant proof.

XX. Transfer and Overseas Voters

Filipino citizens abroad may register as overseas voters under overseas voting laws and COMELEC rules.

A registered local voter who moves abroad may apply for overseas voting registration or transfer through the appropriate Philippine embassy, consulate, or designated registration venue.

Conversely, an overseas voter who returns to the Philippines and resumes residence locally may apply to transfer registration to the local voter registry.

The procedure for overseas voters has separate rules, forms, schedules, and documentary requirements. The applicant must follow the specific overseas voting regulations in force for the election period.


XXI. Transfer and Persons Deprived of Liberty

Persons deprived of liberty may have special voting arrangements depending on COMELEC rules. A registered voter who is detained but not disqualified may still be allowed to vote under certain conditions.

Transfer of registration for persons deprived of liberty may depend on residence, detention facility rules, special polling arrangements, and COMELEC resolutions.

A person convicted by final judgment of certain crimes may be disqualified from voting, subject to constitutional and statutory rules.


XXII. Transfer and Persons with Disabilities, Senior Citizens, and Indigenous Peoples

Persons with disabilities, senior citizens, and members of indigenous cultural communities have the same right to apply for transfer of registration.

COMELEC may provide accessible registration sites, express lanes, satellite registration, or other accommodations.

A voter with disability may also update their record to indicate the type of assistance or accessibility accommodation needed. This can help COMELEC assign the voter to an accessible polling place or provide assistance during election day.


XXIII. Grounds for Denial of Transfer Application

A transfer application may be denied if:

  1. The applicant is not a qualified voter;
  2. The applicant is not actually a resident of the new locality;
  3. The applicant fails to meet the residence period required by law;
  4. The applicant is disqualified from voting;
  5. The applicant submits false information;
  6. The applicant has no valid existing voter registration record;
  7. The application is incomplete or defective;
  8. The applicant fails to appear personally where required;
  9. The applicant is attempting double or multiple registration;
  10. The application is filed outside the registration period;
  11. The applicant fails to comply with COMELEC requirements.

A denial by the ERB may be subject to remedies under election law and COMELEC rules.


XXIV. Remedies if Transfer Is Denied

If the Election Registration Board disapproves the application, the applicant may have remedies under election law, such as filing a petition for inclusion or other appropriate action before the proper court, depending on the nature of the denial and the governing rules.

The remedy must be pursued within the period allowed by law or COMELEC rules. Election registration cases are time-sensitive because the list of voters must be finalized before election day.


XXV. Challenges to Transfer Applications

Other voters, political parties, or concerned persons may challenge registration applications, including transfers, when they believe the applicant is not qualified.

A common ground for challenge is lack of residence.

Challenges may arise in localities where mass transfers are suspected, especially before local elections. COMELEC and the courts may scrutinize whether the applicants genuinely reside in the locality or whether the transfers are politically motivated and fictitious.


XXVI. Election Offenses Related to Transfer

False statements in a voter registration or transfer application may constitute an election offense.

Possible unlawful acts include:

  • giving false information under oath;
  • using a false address;
  • claiming residence in a place where one does not actually reside;
  • applying for registration in more than one place;
  • impersonating another voter;
  • falsifying documents;
  • inducing or assisting fraudulent transfers;
  • engaging in schemes to manipulate local voter lists.

Election offenses may carry penalties such as imprisonment, disqualification from public office, deprivation of the right of suffrage, or other penalties provided by law.


XXVII. Transfer and Political “Flying Voters”

The term “flying voter” is commonly used in the Philippines to refer to a person who registers or votes in a place where they are not legally qualified to vote, often for political purposes.

A transfer of registration is legitimate when based on actual residence and lawful qualification. It becomes suspect when a person claims residence in a locality merely to influence election results.

COMELEC may investigate suspicious mass transfers, and affected parties may file objections or petitions.


XXVIII. Practical Documents to Bring

Although requirements may vary, a voter applying for transfer should ideally bring:

  • one or more valid government-issued IDs;
  • proof of new address;
  • barangay certificate of residency;
  • old voter information, if available;
  • marriage certificate, if changing surname;
  • birth certificate, if correcting name or date of birth;
  • court order, if applicable;
  • authorization or special documents only if allowed by COMELEC rules.

Personal appearance is generally required, so another person cannot ordinarily file the transfer application on behalf of the voter.


XXIX. Voter’s Certification and Voter’s ID

The old voter’s ID system has largely been overtaken by other identification systems and voter verification methods. A voter may request a voter’s certification from COMELEC when needed, but possession of a voter’s ID is not the controlling requirement for transfer.

The essential issue is whether the person has an existing voter registration record and whether the transfer application is approved.


XXX. Effect of Approved Transfer

Once approved, the voter’s registration is moved to the new jurisdiction. The voter will be assigned to the appropriate:

  • city or municipality;
  • barangay;
  • precinct;
  • legislative district;
  • polling place;
  • clustered precinct, if applicable.

The voter will then vote in the new assigned precinct during the next election for which the transfer is effective.


XXXI. Effect of Pending Transfer

Filing an application does not automatically mean that the transfer is effective.

Until approved by the Election Registration Board, the transfer remains pending. A voter should verify approval and precinct assignment before election day.

If the application is disapproved, the voter may remain registered in the old locality unless the registration is otherwise deactivated, cancelled, or affected by another legal action.


XXXII. Verification of Transfer Status

After the ERB acts on the application, the voter should verify registration status.

Verification may be done through:

  • the local COMELEC Office;
  • official COMELEC precinct finder or voter verification facility, when available;
  • voter information services made available during the election period;
  • official COMELEC announcements.

The voter should check early to avoid discovering issues only on election day.


XXXIII. Common Mistakes

Common mistakes in transfer applications include:

  1. Filing as a new voter despite being previously registered;
  2. Waiting until after the registration deadline;
  3. Using an old address;
  4. Failing to update barangay or district details;
  5. Assuming that moving residence automatically transfers registration;
  6. Failing to reactivate a deactivated record;
  7. Not bringing valid ID;
  8. Giving incomplete or inconsistent information;
  9. Not verifying approval before election day;
  10. Assuming that a voter’s ID is required when other valid proof may suffice.

XXXIV. Frequently Asked Questions

1. Can I transfer my voter registration online?

COMELEC has used online systems for accomplishing forms or setting appointments in some periods, but personal appearance is generally required for identity verification, oath, and biometrics. The availability of online pre-filing, appointment systems, or digital forms depends on COMELEC’s current rules.

2. Can I transfer registration on election day?

No. Transfer must be filed during the voter registration period and must be approved before it becomes effective.

3. Can I vote in my new city if I moved but did not transfer?

Generally, no. A voter votes where they are registered. Moving residence alone does not automatically transfer the voter’s registration.

4. Can I still vote in my old precinct after moving?

That depends on the facts. A voter’s registration may still be listed in the old precinct if no transfer was made, but election law requires residency qualifications. A person should not falsely claim residence in a place where they are no longer domiciled.

5. Do I need my old voter’s ID to transfer?

Usually, no. A valid ID and existing voter registration record are more important. COMELEC can verify prior registration.

6. What if my registration was deactivated?

You must apply for reactivation. If you also moved residence, you should apply for reactivation with transfer.

7. What if I moved within the same barangay?

If the move does not affect precinct assignment, district, or voter record details, the effect may be minimal, but the voter should still update the address if required.

8. What if I moved to another barangay in the same city?

You should apply to update or transfer your registration record within the city or municipality so your barangay and precinct assignment are correct.

9. Can students transfer their registration to where they study?

Only if they meet the legal residency requirement and have established domicile there. Temporary stay for schooling alone may not be enough.

10. Can workers transfer registration to where they work?

Only if they actually reside and intend to make that place their domicile, and they meet the required residence period.


XXXV. Legal Importance of Domicile

The concept of domicile is often decisive in voter registration disputes.

A person may have many residences in the ordinary sense, but only one domicile for election purposes. Domicile includes:

  1. physical presence in the place;
  2. intention to remain there;
  3. intention to return there when absent.

Temporary absence does not necessarily abandon domicile. Likewise, temporary presence does not automatically create domicile.

For transfer of registration, the applicant must genuinely establish the new place as the legal residence for voting purposes.


XXXVI. Mass Transfers and Local Election Controversies

In local elections, mass transfer of voters can become controversial because a small number of transferred voters may affect the outcome, especially in barangay, municipal, or district contests.

COMELEC may scrutinize unusual registration patterns, especially where:

  • many voters transfer to one address;
  • applicants cannot identify their residence;
  • claimed residences are vacant lots, commercial spaces, or non-residential structures;
  • applicants are politically coordinated;
  • applicants return to another locality after registration;
  • local residents challenge the transfers.

Fraudulent transfers undermine the integrity of elections and may result in exclusion proceedings, cancellation, or prosecution.


XXXVII. Best Practices for Voters

A voter intending to transfer registration should:

  1. Transfer early during the registration period;
  2. Bring valid ID and proof of residence;
  3. Use the exact and complete new address;
  4. Disclose previous registration accurately;
  5. Avoid filing as a new voter if already registered;
  6. Ask whether reactivation is also needed;
  7. Update personal information at the same time;
  8. Keep proof or acknowledgment of filing;
  9. Verify approval and precinct assignment;
  10. Monitor COMELEC announcements for deadlines.

XXXVIII. Best Practices for Local Election Officers

Election officers handling transfer applications should:

  • verify identity;
  • ensure proper classification of the application;
  • check for existing registration;
  • capture or update biometrics;
  • require complete address information;
  • inform applicants of ERB hearing and approval process;
  • screen for duplicate or suspicious records;
  • ensure accessibility for vulnerable voters;
  • observe uniform application of COMELEC rules;
  • protect the applicant’s personal data.

XXXIX. Data Privacy Considerations

Voter registration involves sensitive personal information. COMELEC and its personnel are expected to handle voter data in accordance with election law and data privacy principles.

Information such as biometrics, address, birth date, and identification details must be protected from unauthorized disclosure or misuse.

Applicants should provide truthful information but should also transact only with authorized COMELEC personnel or official registration sites.


XL. Consequences of Not Transferring

Failure to transfer registration may result in:

  • being assigned to the old precinct;
  • inability to vote conveniently;
  • inability to vote for officials in the new locality;
  • confusion during election day;
  • risk of challenge if residence qualification is questioned;
  • possible deactivation in the future if the voter repeatedly fails to vote.

A voter who has permanently moved should update their registration record as soon as registration opens.


XLI. Summary of Requirements

For ordinary local transfer of voter registration, the usual requirements are:

Requirement Explanation
Existing voter registration Transfer applies only to registered voters
Filipino citizenship Only Filipino citizens may vote
Age qualification At least 18 years old on or before election day
Residence qualification Resident of the Philippines for at least one year and of the locality for at least six months before election day
Personal appearance Usually required before COMELEC
Application form Prescribed COMELEC form for transfer
Valid ID Proof of identity
Proof of residence Useful or required depending on circumstances
Biometrics Capture, verification, or update
ERB approval Transfer is effective only after approval

XLII. Conclusion

Transfer of voter registration in the Philippines is a formal legal process that protects both the voter’s right of suffrage and the integrity of local elections. It is not automatic upon moving residence. A registered voter must personally apply with COMELEC, establish identity and residence, comply with biometrics and documentary requirements, and obtain approval from the Election Registration Board.

The most important legal requirement is genuine residence or domicile in the place where the voter seeks to vote. Transfer is lawful when it reflects a real change of residence. It becomes unlawful when used to create artificial voting strength in a locality.

A voter who has moved should treat transfer of registration as an essential civic step, to be completed early within the registration period and verified before election day.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.