Transferring Philippine Property to US-Born Child

Introduction

The transfer of property in the Philippines to a child born in the United States involves a complex interplay of Philippine constitutional law, civil law principles, tax regulations, and citizenship rules. This is primarily because the Philippine Constitution restricts land ownership to Filipino citizens or entities with majority Filipino ownership. A US-born child may or may not qualify as a Filipino citizen, depending on their parents' citizenship status at the time of birth and subsequent actions. This article explores all aspects of such transfers, including eligibility, methods of transfer, legal requirements, potential restrictions, tax implications, and procedural steps, within the Philippine legal framework. It assumes the property in question includes real property (land and buildings), as this raises the most significant issues, though personal property transfers are also addressed briefly.

Determining the Citizenship Status of the US-Born Child

The cornerstone of any property transfer to a US-born child is establishing their eligibility to own property under Philippine law. The 1987 Philippine Constitution (Article XII, Section 2) mandates that private lands shall be transferred or conveyed only to individuals who are citizens of the Philippines or to corporations or associations at least 60% of whose capital is owned by such citizens.

Philippine Citizenship by Birth

  • Under the 1935, 1973, and 1987 Constitutions, citizenship is primarily acquired by blood (jus sanguinis). A child born to at least one Filipino parent is considered a natural-born Filipino citizen, regardless of birthplace.
  • For a US-born child:
    • If both parents were Filipino citizens at the time of the child's birth, the child is a natural-born Filipino citizen (Philippine Citizenship Law, as derived from Commonwealth Act No. 473 and the Constitution).
    • If only one parent was Filipino, the child may still acquire Philippine citizenship, but this could require election upon reaching the age of majority (typically 18 years old) under Republic Act No. 9225 (Citizenship Retention and Re-acquisition Act of 2003).
  • US citizenship is acquired by birth on US soil (jus soli), so the child is likely a dual citizen (US and Philippine) if born to Filipino parents.

Dual Citizenship and Re-acquisition

  • Republic Act No. 9225 allows natural-born Filipinos who have lost Philippine citizenship through naturalization in a foreign country to re-acquire it by taking an oath of allegiance before a Philippine consulate or the Bureau of Immigration.
  • For US-born children of former Filipinos: If the parents naturalized as US citizens before the child's birth, the child is born a US citizen only and is not automatically Filipino. However, if the parents re-acquire Philippine citizenship under RA 9225, the minor child (under 18) can derivatively acquire it without a separate oath.
  • Adult children (18 and over) must personally take the oath to acquire or re-acquire citizenship.
  • Once dual citizenship is established, the child is treated as a full Filipino citizen for property ownership purposes, with no restrictions on owning land (Supreme Court rulings, e.g., Republic v. Magallanes, G.R. No. 190918, affirm this).

Implications for Non-Citizens

  • If the US-born child is solely a US citizen (e.g., parents had already naturalized before birth and did not re-acquire Philippine citizenship), they are considered a foreigner under Philippine law.
  • Foreigners cannot own land but may own condominium units (up to 40% of the total units in a project under Republic Act No. 4726, the Condominium Act) or lease land for up to 50 years, renewable for another 25 years (Investors' Lease Act, Republic Act No. 7652).
  • Attempts to transfer land to a non-citizen child could be void ab initio (from the beginning) under the Constitution, leading to escheat proceedings where the state claims the property.

Methods of Property Transfer

Philippine law recognizes several modes of transferring property rights, governed by the Civil Code of the Philippines (Republic Act No. 386). The choice depends on whether the transfer is inter vivos (during lifetime) or mortis causa (upon death).

Inter Vivos Transfers

  1. Sale

    • Governed by Articles 1458-1637 of the Civil Code.
    • Requirements: A Deed of Absolute Sale must be executed, notarized, and registered with the Registry of Deeds in the property's location.
    • For real property: Pay Capital Gains Tax (6% of the selling price or zonal value, whichever is higher) and Documentary Stamp Tax (1.5%). The buyer (child) pays transfer tax (0.5-0.75% depending on locality).
    • If the child is a minor, a guardian ad litem or the parents must act on their behalf, with court approval if necessary (Family Code, Article 225).
    • Restriction: If the child is not a Filipino citizen, the sale of land is invalid; only buildings or improvements may be sold separately if the land is leased.

  2. Donation

    • Articles 725-773 of the Civil Code apply.
    • Types: Inter vivos donation (irrevocable gift) requires a Deed of Donation, notarized and accepted by the donee (child).
    • For immovable property valued over PHP 5,000, the donation must be in a public instrument and registered.
    • Tax: Donor's Tax (6% for relatives, including children, on the fair market value exceeding PHP 250,000 exemption per year under Republic Act No. 10963, the TRAIN Law).
    • If the child is a minor, acceptance can be by parents (Article 737).
    • Caveat: Donations to non-citizens are subject to the same ownership restrictions; land cannot be donated to foreigners.

  3. Other Modes

    • Exchange or Barter: Similar to sale, with tax implications under Revenue Regulations.
    • Assignment: For personal property or rights, less formal but still requires documentation.

Mortis Causa Transfers (Succession)

  1. Testate Succession (With a Will)

    • Governed by Articles 774-1105 of the Civil Code.
    • The parent can execute a holographic will (entirely handwritten) or notarial will (witnessed and notarized).
    • Legitime (compulsory share): Legitimate children are entitled to at least half of the estate (Article 888), divided equally.
    • The US-born child, if legitimate, has the same rights as Philippine-born siblings.
    • Probate: The will must be probated in Philippine courts (Regional Trial Court) if the property is in the Philippines, even if the testator dies abroad.
    • Extrajudicial settlement is possible if all heirs agree and there are no debts (but not for wills).

  2. Intestate Succession (Without a Will)

    • Articles 960-1014 apply.
    • Order of succession: Legitimate children and descendants inherit the entire estate if no spouse; otherwise, children get 1/2, spouse 1/2 (Article 996, as amended by the Family Code).
    • Illegitimate children receive half the share of legitimate ones (Family Code, Article 176).
    • The US-born child's citizenship does not affect inheritance rights per se, but ownership restrictions apply post-inheritance. If not Filipino, they may need to sell the land within a reasonable time or face escheat.

  3. Settlement of Estate

    • File for estate tax (6% on net estate over PHP 5 million exemption under TRAIN Law) within one year of death.
    • Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) clearance required before transfer.
    • If the child is abroad, they can appoint a representative via Special Power of Attorney, authenticated by a Philippine consulate.

Tax Implications

  • Capital Gains Tax (CGT): 6% on gains from sale or disposition of real property.
  • Donor's Tax: 6% for gifts to relatives.
  • Estate Tax: 6% on worldwide estate for Filipino citizens; only Philippine-situs property for non-residents.
  • Value-Added Tax (VAT): May apply if the transfer is considered a business transaction.
  • Local Transfer Tax: Varies by city/municipality.
  • Exemptions: Transfers to legitimate children may qualify for deductions; consult BIR Revenue District Office.
  • Double Taxation: US-Philippine Tax Treaty (1982) provides relief for dual citizens to avoid double taxation on inheritance or gains.

Procedural Steps for Transfer

  1. Verify Citizenship: Obtain a Certificate of Philippine Citizenship from the Bureau of Immigration or Philippine consulate if needed.
  2. Title Verification: Secure a Certified True Copy of the Title from the Registry of Deeds; ensure no liens or encumbrances.
  3. Execute Document: Notarize the deed (sale/donation/will).
  4. Pay Taxes: Secure BIR Certificate Authorizing Registration (CAR).
  5. Register: File with Registry of Deeds; new title issued in child's name.
  6. For Minors: If child under 18, involve Department of Social Welfare and Development (DSWD) or court for guardianship.
  7. If Abroad: Use apostille (Hague Convention) for US documents or consular authentication.

Special Considerations

  • Agrarian Reform Lands: Subject to Comprehensive Agrarian Reform Law (RA 6657); cannot be transferred without DAR approval.
  • Ancestral Domains: Indigenous peoples' lands under IPRA (RA 8371) have additional restrictions.
  • Conjugal Property: If property is conjugal, both spouses must consent (Family Code, Article 124).
  • Disputes: Resolved in Philippine courts; jurisdiction over property is in rem (where the property is located).
  • Renunciation: The child can renounce inheritance if citizenship issues arise, allowing redistribution.
  • Trusts: Philippine law recognizes trusts (Civil Code, Article 1440), but land trusts for foreigners are scrutinized to prevent circumvention of ownership rules.
  • Personal Property: Fewer restrictions; movable property (e.g., shares, vehicles) can be transferred to foreigners freely.

Potential Challenges and Remedies

  • Citizenship Disputes: File a petition for recognition of citizenship with the Office of the Solicitor General.
  • Tax Audits: BIR may audit transfers to prevent undervaluation.
  • Fraudulent Transfers: Void if intended to evade laws (e.g., sham sales).
  • International Aspects: Comply with US laws on reporting foreign assets (FATCA, FBAR for US citizens).
  • COVID-19 and Modern Updates: Electronic filing options via BIR e-services; remote notarization under Supreme Court rules during emergencies.

Conclusion

Transferring Philippine property to a US-born child is feasible if the child qualifies as a Filipino citizen, enabling full ownership rights. Otherwise, alternatives like leases or sales of improvements must be considered. Parents should consult a Philippine lawyer specializing in property and immigration law to navigate these complexities, ensure compliance, and minimize tax liabilities. Proper planning, including citizenship affirmation and tax settlements, is essential to avoid legal pitfalls and secure the child's interests.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Lawyer Login

 
 
Privacy Policy         Terms of Use         Lawyer Login