Philippine legal context • for educational use

Big picture

A real estate mortgage (REM) is an accessory contract. It doesn’t create a debt by itself; it secures the performance of a principal obligation—usually a loan evidenced by a promissory note (PN) or a loan agreement. Because of this accessoriness, parties often ask:

Is an REM valid if it’s registered before the promissory note is executed?

Yes—provided the mortgage is constituted to secure present and/or future obligations and all formal and substantive requisites are met. Registration timing relative to the PN does not, by itself, invalidate the mortgage. What matters is that (i) there is, or will be, a valid principal obligation, and (ii) the mortgage instrument legally covers that obligation (e.g., via a “dragnet” or future-advances clause) up to an agreed cap.

Below is everything you need to know, step by step.

1) Legal foundations

1.1 Accessory nature and existence of a principal obligation

Civil Code (Arts. 2085, 2126). A mortgage is accessory to a principal obligation. It “directly and immediately subjects the property” to the fulfillment of that obligation.
Key consequence: A mortgage cannot stand alone. If no principal obligation exists and the REM does not secure future obligations, the mortgage lacks cause and is void.
But: The law allows mortgages to secure future debts. This is implemented through a valid dragnet/future-advances clause, often with a maximum secured amount.

1.2 Binding effect and registration

Civil Code (Art. 2125). The mortgage instrument should be recorded in the Registry of Deeds to bind third persons and establish priority.
Between the parties, an unregistered mortgage still produces obligations; registration primarily affects opposability and ranking against others.

1.3 Torrens registration and priority

Property Registration Decree (P.D. 1529). As a rule, priority of liens follows order of registration. An REM that is registered earlier enjoys priority over later registered encumbrances, up to the amount it validly secures.

2) Can the mortgage be registered before the promissory note?

2.1 The general rule (validity)

Yes, it can. The validity of the REM does not depend on the PN’s execution date. What matters:

Authority & ownership: The mortgagor owns the property (or is duly authorized).
Cause: There is a principal obligation existing or contemplated.
Coverage: The REM, by its terms, secures (a) an existing loan, or (b) future loans/credit accommodations (e.g., credit line), up to a stated maximum.
Form & registration: Properly executed (notarized) and registered to affect third persons and fix lien priority.

2.2 “Future advances” / dragnet clauses

A dragnet clause states that the mortgage secures “any and all obligations” of the mortgagor to the mortgagee—past, present, and future—up to a maximum amount.
This clause is what allows later promissory notes or drawdowns to be swept under the already-registered REM without re-registering each PN.
Best practice: State a clear maximum secured amount (“up to ₱X”), describe the credit facility (e.g., revolving line), and cross-reference related credit agreements.

3) Formal requirements for a valid real estate mortgage

3.1 Substantive requisites (Civil Code)

Capacity & consent of the parties (Art. 2085).
Ownership/authority over the property mortgaged.
Principal obligation: existing or future (if future, the REM must say so).
Definite description of the mortgaged property.

3.2 Form & notarization

Public instrument (notarized) for registrability. Notarization converts the document into a public instrument, facilitates entry in the Registry, and gives it evidentiary weight.

3.3 Registration with the Registry of Deeds

Original Certificate/Transfer Certificate of Title (OCT/TCT): describe the property exactly as per title.
Annotation of the mortgage on the title; issuance of an Owner’s Duplicate with the lien noted.
Effect: Establishes priority and binds third persons.

3.4 Special consents & capacity issues

Spouses / community property (Family Code): Disposition or encumbrance of conjugal/community property generally requires the written consent of both spouses; lack of consent risks void or voidable status and can cloud foreclosure.
Family home: Cannot be mortgaged without required spousal and, in some instances, beneficiary consents.
Corporate mortgagors: Require board authority; if the signatory is an officer/agent, a board resolution or SPA should be attached.
Trust/agency: Show authority to encumber.

3.5 Foreclosure power

For extrajudicial foreclosure (Act No. 3135), the REM must contain a “special power of attorney” (power-of-sale) clause. Without it, the mortgagee must resort to judicial foreclosure.

3.6 Taxes & fees (practice points)

Documentary Stamp Tax (DST) on mortgages is typically based on the amount secured; for future-advances structures, the maximum secured amount drives DST at execution.
Transfer/registration fees per Registry schedules.

4) The promissory note vs. the mortgage

4.1 Do we need a promissory note at all?

The loan may be evidenced by a PN or a loan/credit agreement. A PN is not a prerequisite to a mortgage’s validity. What’s crucial is that the REM secures a real obligation.

4.2 Sequence scenarios

REM first, PN later (with dragnet clause):
- Valid. The later PN/drawdown is automatically covered up to the cap.
- No re-registration needed for each PN.
- Priority traces to the REM’s registration date.
REM first, PN later (no dragnet; no reference to future credit):
- Risky/invalid as to later PN. If the REM only secures a specified existing loan and says nothing about future obligations, a later PN may not be covered.
- Fix by amending the REM (with re-annotation) before extending new credit.
PN first, REM later:
- Common and valid. The REM then secures the existing debt; priority runs from the REM’s registration date (not the PN date).

5) “All there is to know”: special doctrines and pitfalls

5.1 The “dragnet rule” (future-advances doctrine)

Banks and lenders frequently rely on “all obligations” language. Courts uphold such clauses when clear and unequivocal, especially where a credit line is in place and a maximum secured amount is fixed.
Limits:
- If another specific security was intended by the parties for a particular loan, courts may treat that specific security as excluding dragnet coverage for that loan.
- Coverage still cannot exceed the annotated maximum.

5.2 Description and identifiability of the debt

While the REM can secure future obligations, the instrument should describe the facility broadly enough (e.g., “loans, discounts, bills, overdrafts, guarantees, and all other obligations… whether now existing or hereafter incurred”), plus the cap.
For transparency and auditability, lenders keep an obligation schedule mapping PNs/drawdowns to the REM.

5.3 Third-party mortgages and surety/guaranty issues

A third-party mortgage (someone else’s property secures the borrower’s debt) is valid if the owner consents.
Distinguish from surety/guaranty (which are personal securities and may trigger Statute of Frauds writing requirements). The mortgage is a real right over property; its validity hinges on mortgage formalities, not on suretyship rules.

5.4 Renewals, restructurings, and substitutions

Renewal PNs or restructurings are typically covered if the REM secures “any and all obligations” and the cap isn’t exceeded.
Substitutions of debtors (assumption of mortgage) require consent of the mortgagee and proper documentation/annotation.

5.5 Partial releases and re-advances

The mortgagee may partially release parcels or lower the cap by annotated instruments.
Re-advances under a credit line continue to be covered within the availability period and cap.

5.6 Assignment of mortgage/loan

Lenders can assign the loan and the REM together; the assignee should record an Assignment of Mortgage to bind third persons.

5.7 Good faith purchasers/encumbrancers

Buyer or subsequent mortgagee in good faith and for value takes subject only to prior-registered liens and adverse annotations. Proper due diligence (CENOMAR of title, certified true copy, latest tax dec, etc.) is essential.

6) Checklist: making a mortgage-before-PN structure enforceable

Use a robust dragnet clause: “secures all obligations, present and future…”
State a clear maximum secured amount (the cap).
Reference the facility (credit line/omnibus credit agreement) and allow for multiple drawdowns/PNs.
Insert power-of-sale for extrajudicial foreclosure (Act No. 3135).
Get all required consents (spousal, corporate board, beneficial owner).
Precisely describe the property (per TCT/OCT) and attach a technical description.
Proper notarization and registration with the Registry of Deeds; ensure annotation on the title.
Pay DST and fees based on the maximum secured amount.
Keep an internal ledger mapping each PN/drawdown to the REM; don’t exceed the cap.
For changes (cap increases, property substitutions, releases), execute and annotate amendments.

7) FAQs

Q1: If we registered the REM last month and sign the PN next week, is the PN covered? A: If your REM has a future-advances/dragnet clause and a cap, the later PN will be covered up to the cap without re-registration.

Q2: Do we need to register each PN? A: No. The REM (not the PN) is the registrable encumbrance. The PN evidences the debt; the REM secures it.

Q3: What if there was no debt when we executed the REM and the instrument did not mention future obligations? A: The REM likely fails for lack of cause as to later-incurred loans. Execute an amended REM with a dragnet clause, then register the amendment before funding.

Q4: Can we foreclose if default is only on a later PN? A: Yes, if the later PN is within the REM’s coverage (dragnet) and cap, foreclosure can proceed on that default.

Q5: If the property is conjugal/community, can one spouse alone sign? A: Generally no. Obtain written consent of both spouses, or risk invalidity and foreclosure challenges.

8) Practical drafting tips (sample building blocks)

Secured obligations clause: “This Mortgage secures the prompt and full payment and performance of any and all obligations of Mortgagor to Mortgagee, whether now existing or hereafter incurred, direct or indirect, absolute or contingent, due or to become due, including without limitation all loans, credit accommodations, promissory notes, renewals, restructurings, and expenses, up to the maximum principal amount of ₱[CAP], plus interest, penalties, fees, and costs.”
Power-of-sale / extrajudicial foreclosure: “Mortgagor hereby grants to Mortgagee a special power of attorney to sell the Mortgaged Property at public auction in accordance with Act No. 3135 and applicable rules, upon occurrence of an Event of Default.”
Cross-default/cross-collateralization: “Any default under any obligation of Mortgagor to Mortgagee shall constitute a default under this Mortgage; and this Mortgage shall secure all such obligations on a cross-collateralized basis within the stated cap.”
Cap mechanics & amendments: “The Maximum Secured Amount may be increased or decreased only by a written amendment to this Mortgage, duly notarized and annotated on the title.”

9) Key takeaways

A mortgage registered before the PN is valid if it is drafted to secure future obligations and meets all formalities.
Registration fixes priority and binds third persons; the PN itself need not be registered.
Avoid defects: ensure dragnet language + cap, proper consents, notarization, and annotation.
For enforcement, include a power-of-sale clause to enable extrajudicial foreclosure.

If you want, I can turn this into a clause pack (with a model REM and PN) tailored to your use case and risk appetite.