When to Pay Capital Gains Tax on the Purchase of Real Property

I. Introduction

In the Philippines, the sale, exchange, or other disposition of real property may give rise to Capital Gains Tax, commonly called CGT. Despite its name, Philippine CGT on certain real property transactions is not always imposed on the actual gain realized. In many cases, it is imposed on the gross selling price, fair market value, or zonal value, whichever is higher.

In ordinary real estate transactions, CGT is one of the most important taxes because payment of this tax is generally required before the Bureau of Internal Revenue, or BIR, issues the Certificate Authorizing Registration, commonly called the CAR. Without the CAR, the Register of Deeds will not ordinarily allow transfer of title from the seller to the buyer.

This article discusses when CGT is due, who pays it, how it is computed, when it must be filed and paid, what documents are involved, and how CGT interacts with other taxes and registration requirements in Philippine real property transactions.


II. Legal Basis of Capital Gains Tax on Real Property

The primary legal basis is the National Internal Revenue Code of 1997, as amended, particularly provisions governing capital gains from the sale, exchange, or other disposition of real property classified as capital assets.

For individuals, estates, trusts, and domestic corporations, the law generally imposes a tax of 6% on the presumed capital gain from the sale, exchange, or disposition of certain real properties located in the Philippines.

The tax is commonly applied to:

  1. Sales of land;
  2. Sales of houses and lots;
  3. Sales of condominium units;
  4. Transfers treated as sales or dispositions;
  5. Certain exchanges or conveyances involving real property classified as capital assets.

The relevant BIR forms commonly involved include:

Transaction Common BIR Form
Capital gains tax return for individuals, estates, and trusts BIR Form 1706
Capital gains tax return for corporations BIR Form 1707
Documentary stamp tax declaration BIR Form 2000-OT
Application for Certificate Authorizing Registration BIR Form 1904, 1903, or applicable CAR processing documents depending on taxpayer status

III. What Kind of Real Property Is Subject to CGT?

CGT applies only if the real property sold is a capital asset.

Under Philippine tax law, real property may be classified either as a:

  1. Capital asset, or
  2. Ordinary asset.

This distinction is crucial.

IV. Capital Asset vs. Ordinary Asset

A. Capital Asset

A real property is generally considered a capital asset if it is not used in business and is not held primarily for sale to customers in the ordinary course of trade or business.

Examples:

  1. A residential house and lot owned by an individual for personal use;
  2. A vacant lot held as an investment by a person not engaged in real estate business;
  3. A condominium unit owned by an individual and later sold, where the seller is not habitually selling real estate;
  4. A family home sold by the owner;
  5. Land inherited by heirs and later sold, where the heirs are not real estate dealers or developers.

If the property is a capital asset, the sale is generally subject to 6% CGT.

B. Ordinary Asset

A real property is generally an ordinary asset if it is:

  1. Stock in trade of the taxpayer;
  2. Property included in inventory;
  3. Property held primarily for sale to customers in the ordinary course of business;
  4. Property used in business and subject to depreciation;
  5. Real property used in trade or business.

Examples:

  1. Subdivision lots sold by a real estate developer;
  2. Condominium units sold by a developer;
  3. Land held by a dealer in real estate for resale;
  4. A building used in business and recorded as a business asset;
  5. Property forming part of the inventory of a corporation engaged in real estate sales.

If the property is an ordinary asset, the transaction is generally not subject to the 6% CGT. Instead, it may be subject to:

  1. Ordinary income tax;
  2. Creditable withholding tax;
  3. Value-added tax or percentage tax, when applicable;
  4. Documentary stamp tax;
  5. Local transfer tax and registration fees.

The first question in any real property sale is therefore: Is the property a capital asset or an ordinary asset?


V. Who Pays Capital Gains Tax?

As a general rule, CGT is legally imposed on the seller, not the buyer.

The tax arises because the seller is the one who disposes of the property and realizes, or is presumed to realize, a gain.

However, in practice, the parties may agree that the buyer will shoulder CGT. This is common in Philippine real estate transactions.

Important distinction:

The parties may agree between themselves that the buyer will pay the CGT, but this private agreement does not change the nature of the tax. As far as the government is concerned, the tax remains connected to the seller’s transfer of the property.

Thus:

Legal taxpayer Usually seller
Party who may actually shoulder payment by agreement Seller or buyer
BIR concern Tax must be paid before CAR issuance
Register of Deeds concern CAR and tax clearances must be submitted before title transfer

If the buyer agrees to shoulder CGT, that agreement should be clearly stated in the Deed of Absolute Sale or related contract.


VI. When Does the Obligation to Pay CGT Arise?

The obligation to pay CGT generally arises upon the sale, exchange, or other disposition of real property classified as a capital asset.

In practical terms, the taxable event usually occurs upon the execution of the notarized Deed of Absolute Sale or equivalent conveyance document.

The important event is not merely the buyer’s payment of the price, but the legal transfer or disposition of ownership or rights over the real property.

Common triggering documents include:

  1. Deed of Absolute Sale;
  2. Deed of Assignment;
  3. Deed of Exchange;
  4. Deed of Transfer;
  5. Deed of Sale with Assumption of Mortgage;
  6. Extrajudicial Settlement with Sale;
  7. Judicial or court-approved sale;
  8. Dacion en pago involving real property;
  9. Certain compromises or conveyances transferring ownership.

The date of notarization is especially important because BIR deadlines are commonly counted from the date of notarization of the document evidencing the sale or transfer.


VII. When Must CGT Be Filed and Paid?

For sales of real property classified as capital assets, the CGT return is generally required to be filed and the tax paid within 30 days following each sale, exchange, or disposition.

In practice, this is usually counted from the date of notarization of the Deed of Absolute Sale or equivalent document.

General rule:

CGT must be filed and paid within 30 days from the date of notarization of the deed of sale or equivalent transfer document.

Example:

If the Deed of Absolute Sale is notarized on March 1, the CGT return should generally be filed and paid within 30 days from that date.

Late payment may result in:

  1. Surcharge;
  2. Interest;
  3. Compromise penalties;
  4. Delay in issuance of the CAR;
  5. Delay in title transfer.

VIII. Where Is CGT Paid?

CGT is generally paid through the BIR office having jurisdiction over the place where the property is located.

In practice, the transaction is processed with the Revenue District Office, or RDO, where the real property is situated.

Payment may be made through authorized agent banks, Revenue Collection Officers, or electronic payment facilities, depending on BIR rules and availability.

For CAR processing, the BIR usually requires submission to the RDO having jurisdiction over the property.


IX. How Is CGT Computed?

The CGT on the sale of real property classified as a capital asset is generally 6% of the highest among the following:

  1. Gross selling price;
  2. Fair market value shown in the Tax Declaration;
  3. Zonal value determined by the BIR.

The formula is:

CGT = 6% × highest value among gross selling price, tax declaration value, or BIR zonal value

Example 1: Selling price is highest

Basis Amount
Selling price ₱5,000,000
Tax declaration value ₱3,000,000
BIR zonal value ₱4,500,000

Highest value: ₱5,000,000 CGT: ₱5,000,000 × 6% = ₱300,000

Example 2: Zonal value is highest

Basis Amount
Selling price ₱4,000,000
Tax declaration value ₱3,500,000
BIR zonal value ₱5,000,000

Highest value: ₱5,000,000 CGT: ₱5,000,000 × 6% = ₱300,000

Even if the actual selling price is only ₱4,000,000, the CGT is based on ₱5,000,000 because the zonal value is higher.


X. Meaning of Gross Selling Price

The gross selling price is the total consideration stated in the deed or contract.

It may include:

  1. Cash payment;
  2. Installment payments;
  3. Assumption of mortgage;
  4. Assumption of liabilities;
  5. Non-cash consideration;
  6. Other valuable consideration received by the seller.

If the buyer assumes the seller’s mortgage as part of the transaction, the amount of the assumed mortgage may be treated as part of the consideration.

Example:

Item Amount
Cash paid to seller ₱3,000,000
Mortgage assumed by buyer ₱2,000,000
Total selling price ₱5,000,000

The gross selling price may be treated as ₱5,000,000, not merely ₱3,000,000.


XI. Zonal Value

The zonal value is the value assigned by the BIR to real properties in a particular location or zone. It is used for tax purposes.

Zonal values may differ from:

  1. Actual market value;
  2. Assessor’s fair market value;
  3. Appraised value;
  4. Contract price;
  5. Bank valuation.

For CGT purposes, the BIR compares the zonal value against the gross selling price and the tax declaration value. The highest amount is used as the tax base.

Zonal value is especially important because parties sometimes state a lower selling price in the deed. The BIR may still compute the tax using the higher zonal value.


XII. Tax Declaration Value

The tax declaration value refers to the fair market value appearing in the local assessor’s records, usually shown in the latest Tax Declaration.

There may be separate tax declarations for:

  1. Land;
  2. Building;
  3. Improvements;
  4. Condominium unit;
  5. Parking slot.

For improved properties, the BIR may require the valuation of both the land and the improvements. If the property includes a house, building, or other improvements, the relevant values must be considered.


XIII. CGT on Land with Improvements

Where the property consists of land and improvements, such as a house and lot, the BIR may require separate valuation documents for:

  1. Land;
  2. Building or improvement.

The taxable base may consider the combined value of land and improvements, depending on the transaction documents and BIR valuation.

Example:

Component Selling Price Tax Declaration Value Zonal / BIR Value
Land ₱4,000,000 ₱3,000,000 ₱5,000,000
House ₱1,000,000 ₱1,500,000 ₱1,200,000

The BIR may determine the taxable base by considering the higher applicable value for the transferred property components.


XIV. CGT on Condominium Units

The sale of a condominium unit classified as a capital asset is generally subject to CGT.

The tax base may consider:

  1. Selling price of the unit;
  2. Zonal value of the unit;
  3. Fair market value in the tax declaration;
  4. Value of parking slot, if separately titled or separately valued;
  5. Value of appurtenant rights.

If a condominium unit and parking slot are covered by separate condominium certificates of title, each may need to be separately evaluated for tax purposes.


XV. CGT on Parking Slots

A parking slot may be treated as real property if it is separately titled or transferred with the condominium unit. If sold by an individual as a capital asset, it may be subject to CGT.

The taxable base may be the highest among:

  1. Selling price;
  2. Tax declaration value;
  3. Zonal or BIR value.

Where a parking slot is bundled with a condominium unit, the BIR may require the allocation of price between the unit and the parking slot.


XVI. Is CGT Due Upon Signing a Contract to Sell?

A Contract to Sell does not always immediately transfer ownership. In many Philippine real estate transactions, ownership is transferred only after full payment and execution of the Deed of Absolute Sale.

Therefore, CGT is generally not paid merely upon signing a Contract to Sell if ownership has not yet transferred.

However, the tax consequences may depend on the substance of the agreement. If the contract effectively transfers ownership, possession, benefits, and burdens of ownership, the BIR may examine whether a taxable disposition has already occurred.

Practical rule:

CGT is ordinarily paid upon execution and notarization of the Deed of Absolute Sale or equivalent conveyance, not merely upon signing a preliminary Contract to Sell.


XVII. Is CGT Due Upon Down Payment?

Generally, a mere down payment does not by itself trigger CGT if there is no completed sale, exchange, or transfer of ownership.

However, where the transaction is structured as a sale with deferred payment, installment payment, or assumption of obligations, the BIR may treat the sale as having occurred upon execution of the deed or transfer document.

Thus, the timing depends on the legal nature of the transaction:

Situation CGT usually due?
Reservation agreement only Generally no
Contract to Sell, ownership retained by seller Generally no
Down payment under Contract to Sell Generally no, if no transfer yet
Deed of Absolute Sale executed and notarized Yes
Deed of Sale with deferred payment Yes, generally upon sale
Deed of Assignment transferring rights Possible, depending on nature
Transfer of ownership despite unpaid balance Yes

XVIII. Is CGT Due on Installment Sales?

Yes, if the sale involves real property classified as a capital asset and the taxable event has occurred.

For purposes of the 6% CGT on real property classified as a capital asset, the tax is generally imposed on the gross selling price or fair market value, whichever is higher, and is not spread out merely because payment is made in installments.

Thus, even if the buyer pays over several months or years, CGT may be due within the applicable filing period from the sale or transfer document.

This is one reason sellers and buyers should plan carefully before executing a notarized deed of sale where the purchase price has not yet been fully paid.


XIX. CGT on Sale with Mortgage Assumption

If the buyer assumes an existing mortgage, the assumption may be part of the consideration for the sale.

Example:

Seller sells a house and lot to Buyer.

Item Amount
Cash paid to Seller ₱2,000,000
Existing bank loan assumed by Buyer ₱3,000,000
Total consideration ₱5,000,000

The selling price may be considered ₱5,000,000.

CGT would be computed using the highest among:

  1. ₱5,000,000 total consideration;
  2. Tax declaration value;
  3. BIR zonal value.

XX. CGT on Sale Below Market Value

Parties sometimes sell property below zonal value or below fair market value. This does not necessarily reduce CGT.

The BIR uses the highest among the selling price, fair market value in the tax declaration, and zonal value.

Example:

Basis Amount
Actual selling price ₱2,000,000
Tax declaration value ₱2,500,000
BIR zonal value ₱4,000,000

CGT is based on ₱4,000,000, not ₱2,000,000.

CGT: ₱4,000,000 × 6% = ₱240,000

A sale below market value may also raise other tax issues, especially if the transaction appears to involve a partial donation or transfer for inadequate consideration between related parties.


XXI. CGT on Sale Between Relatives

A sale between relatives may still be subject to CGT if it is a genuine sale for valuable consideration.

However, if the consideration is inadequate or the transaction is actually a donation disguised as a sale, the BIR may examine whether donor’s tax or other tax consequences apply.

Examples:

  1. Parent sells land to child for a fair price: generally CGT applies.
  2. Parent transfers land to child for no consideration: donor’s tax may apply.
  3. Parent sells land worth ₱10,000,000 to child for ₱100,000: BIR may scrutinize the transaction.

The legal form of the document is not always controlling. Substance matters.


XXII. CGT on Donation of Real Property

A donation is not a sale. Therefore, the 6% CGT on sale of capital asset real property generally does not apply to a pure donation.

Instead, donor’s tax may apply.

However, the transfer may still require:

  1. Donor’s tax filing and payment;
  2. Documentary stamp tax, when applicable;
  3. Local transfer tax;
  4. BIR CAR;
  5. Registration with the Register of Deeds;
  6. Transfer tax clearance from local government.

XXIII. CGT on Inheritance

The transfer of real property from a deceased person to heirs is generally subject to estate tax, not CGT.

However, if the heirs later sell the inherited property, that later sale may be subject to CGT if the property is a capital asset.

There are two separate events:

Event Tax
Death of owner and transfer to heirs Estate tax
Later sale by heirs to buyer CGT, if capital asset

If heirs sell inherited property, the BIR may require estate tax settlement first before issuing the CAR for the sale.


XXIV. CGT on Extrajudicial Settlement with Sale

An Extrajudicial Settlement with Sale usually involves two transactions:

  1. Settlement of the estate among heirs; and
  2. Sale of the property to a buyer.

Accordingly, the BIR may require payment of:

  1. Estate tax on the estate transfer;
  2. CGT on the sale by the heirs;
  3. Documentary stamp tax;
  4. Local transfer tax;
  5. Registration fees.

The deadlines and required documents may vary depending on the date of death, estate tax status, and date of sale.


XXV. CGT on Dacion en Pago

A dacion en pago occurs when a debtor transfers property to a creditor in payment of a debt.

For tax purposes, dacion en pago may be treated as a sale, exchange, or disposition of property. If the property transferred is a capital asset, CGT may apply.

The consideration may be the amount of debt extinguished or the fair market value, depending on the applicable valuation rules.


XXVI. CGT on Foreclosure Sales

Foreclosure of real property may also have tax implications.

In foreclosure proceedings, CGT may become relevant upon the sale or consolidation of ownership, depending on whether the debtor redeems the property and the applicable rules governing foreclosure transactions.

The timing can be more technical because foreclosure involves:

  1. Auction sale;
  2. Certificate of sale;
  3. Redemption period;
  4. Final deed of sale or consolidation of ownership;
  5. Transfer of title.

The tax treatment may depend on whether the sale becomes final and whether ownership is consolidated in the purchaser.

Because foreclosure rules are technical, parties should carefully examine the foreclosure documents and BIR requirements before payment and title transfer.


XXVII. CGT on Judicial Sales

A judicial sale may trigger CGT if it results in the disposition of real property classified as a capital asset.

The taxable event may be tied to the execution or finality of the sale document, court order, sheriff’s certificate, deed, or other instrument evidencing transfer.

The BIR will usually require documents proving the authority and finality of the sale before issuing the CAR.


XXVIII. CGT on Expropriation

When the government expropriates private property, the owner receives just compensation. Tax consequences may arise because the owner disposes of real property in exchange for compensation.

Depending on the circumstances and applicable tax rules, the transaction may be treated as a sale or disposition. The tax treatment may depend on whether the property is a capital asset or ordinary asset and whether special exemptions apply.


XXIX. CGT on Sale of Principal Residence

Philippine tax law provides a special exemption from CGT for certain sales of a taxpayer’s principal residence, subject to strict conditions.

A natural person may be exempt from CGT on the sale or disposition of a principal residence if the proceeds are fully utilized in acquiring or constructing a new principal residence within the period required by law.

The common requirements include:

  1. The seller is a natural person;
  2. The property sold is the seller’s principal residence;
  3. The proceeds are fully used to acquire or construct a new principal residence;
  4. The acquisition or construction occurs within the prescribed period;
  5. The BIR is properly notified;
  6. The exemption is availed of only once every ten years;
  7. The historical cost or adjusted basis of the old residence is carried over to the new residence;
  8. If the proceeds are not fully utilized, the unused portion may become taxable.

This exemption does not automatically apply. It must be properly claimed and documented.


XXX. Meaning of Principal Residence

A principal residence is generally the main home where the taxpayer actually resides.

Evidence may include:

  1. Address in government IDs;
  2. Utility bills;
  3. Barangay certification;
  4. Tax declarations;
  5. Voter registration;
  6. Proof of occupancy;
  7. Affidavit of principal residence;
  8. Other documents showing actual residence.

A vacation house, rental property, investment condominium, or unused land is usually not a principal residence.


XXXI. When the Principal Residence Exemption Must Be Claimed

The exemption must be claimed with the BIR in connection with the sale. It is not enough for the seller to simply say that the property was a principal residence.

The taxpayer should notify the BIR and comply with documentary requirements. The BIR may require evidence that the proceeds are deposited or used for the acquisition or construction of a new principal residence.

If the proceeds are not fully used for the new principal residence within the prescribed period, the unused portion may become subject to CGT.


XXXII. Sale of Property by a Corporation

If a corporation sells real property, the tax treatment depends on whether the property is a capital asset or an ordinary asset.

A domestic corporation may be subject to 6% CGT on the sale of land or buildings classified as capital assets.

However, if the property is an ordinary asset used in business or held primarily for sale to customers, the transaction is generally subject to ordinary corporate income tax rules and withholding tax, not the 6% CGT.

Examples:

Seller Property Likely treatment
Real estate developer Subdivision lots Ordinary asset
Manufacturing corporation Old factory land used in business Ordinary asset
Holding company Investment land not used in business Possibly capital asset
Individual homeowner Family home Capital asset
Individual real estate dealer Inventory lots Ordinary asset

XXXIII. Sale by a Real Estate Dealer or Developer

Real estate dealers and developers usually sell ordinary assets. Their sales are generally not subject to 6% CGT.

Instead, the transaction may be subject to:

  1. Income tax on actual taxable income;
  2. Creditable withholding tax;
  3. VAT, if applicable;
  4. Documentary stamp tax;
  5. Local transfer tax;
  6. Registration fees.

The buyer in these transactions often receives a BIR withholding tax form rather than a CGT return.


XXXIV. CGT vs. Creditable Withholding Tax

CGT and creditable withholding tax are different.

CGT Creditable Withholding Tax
Applies to sale of real property classified as capital asset Applies to certain sales of ordinary assets
Usually 6% of highest value Rate depends on classification and seller
Final tax Creditable against income tax
Seller is taxpayer Buyer may withhold and remit
Usually BIR Form 1706 or 1707 Usually withholding tax forms

A common mistake is assuming every real estate sale is subject to CGT. That is not correct. Sales of ordinary assets are usually subject to withholding tax and income tax, not CGT.


XXXV. CGT vs. Documentary Stamp Tax

CGT is different from Documentary Stamp Tax, or DST.

CGT is imposed on the presumed gain from the sale or disposition of a capital asset.

DST is imposed on the document or instrument transferring property.

For a real estate sale, both CGT and DST may be due.

Usual treatment:

Tax Usually paid by Tax base
CGT Seller, unless agreed otherwise Highest among selling price, zonal value, or tax declaration value
DST Buyer, unless agreed otherwise Consideration or fair market value, depending on rules

In practice, the parties often agree as follows:

Expense Common party paying
CGT Seller
Broker’s commission Seller
DST Buyer
Transfer tax Buyer
Registration fees Buyer
Notarial fees Buyer or shared
Association dues clearance Seller
Real property tax up to sale date Seller

These allocations are contractual and may be changed by agreement.


XXXVI. CGT vs. Local Transfer Tax

Local transfer tax is imposed by the city or municipality where the property is located. It is separate from CGT.

CGT is paid to the BIR. Local transfer tax is paid to the local treasurer.

The usual sequence is:

  1. Execute and notarize deed;
  2. Pay CGT and DST to BIR;
  3. Secure CAR from BIR;
  4. Pay local transfer tax;
  5. Secure tax clearance;
  6. Register documents with Register of Deeds;
  7. Transfer tax declaration with Assessor’s Office.

Some local government offices may require BIR documents before accepting transfer tax payment, while others allow earlier payment. Practice may vary by locality.


XXXVII. Role of the Certificate Authorizing Registration

The Certificate Authorizing Registration, or CAR, is a BIR-issued document confirming that the necessary taxes for the transfer have been paid or that the transaction is exempt.

The Register of Deeds generally requires the CAR before transferring the title.

Without the CAR, the buyer may have paid the seller but still be unable to transfer title.

This is why CGT payment and CAR processing are central to real estate conveyancing in the Philippines.


XXXVIII. Documents Commonly Required for CGT and CAR Processing

The BIR commonly requires documents such as:

  1. Notarized Deed of Absolute Sale or equivalent document;
  2. Owner’s duplicate certificate of title;
  3. Certified true copy of title;
  4. Latest Tax Declaration for land;
  5. Latest Tax Declaration for improvements;
  6. Real property tax clearance;
  7. Valid government IDs of parties;
  8. Tax Identification Numbers of seller and buyer;
  9. BIR forms;
  10. Proof of payment of CGT;
  11. Proof of payment of DST;
  12. Secretary’s Certificate, if a corporation is involved;
  13. Articles of Incorporation and corporate documents, if applicable;
  14. Special Power of Attorney, if a representative signs;
  15. Marriage certificate or proof of civil status, where relevant;
  16. Certificate of No Improvement, if the land is vacant;
  17. Location plan or vicinity map, if required;
  18. Condominium documents, if the property is a condominium unit;
  19. Estate settlement documents, if inherited property is involved.

Requirements vary by RDO and by transaction type.


XXXIX. Deadline for Documentary Stamp Tax

In real property sales, DST is also time-sensitive.

DST is generally required to be filed and paid within the applicable statutory deadline, commonly within the first few days of the month following the notarization or execution of the taxable document, depending on the tax type and applicable BIR rules.

Because CGT and DST deadlines may differ, both must be monitored carefully.

A common practical approach is to pay both CGT and DST as soon as possible after notarization of the deed.


XL. What Happens If CGT Is Paid Late?

Late payment of CGT may result in:

  1. Surcharge;
  2. Interest;
  3. Compromise penalty;
  4. Delay in CAR issuance;
  5. Delay in title transfer;
  6. Possible reassessment;
  7. Additional administrative burden.

The amount of penalties depends on how late the payment is and the applicable BIR rules.

The BIR may compute penalties before accepting payment or issuing the CAR.


XLI. Can the Buyer Pay CGT Directly?

Yes. The buyer may physically pay the CGT if the parties agree.

However, because the tax is associated with the seller’s disposition of property, the CGT return and transaction documents must properly identify the seller and the property.

Buyers often insist on controlling or directly paying the tax to ensure that the CAR is processed and the title can be transferred.

A common arrangement is for part of the purchase price to be withheld by the buyer and used to pay CGT and other taxes.


XLII. Should CGT Be Deducted from the Purchase Price?

This depends on the parties’ agreement.

If the seller is responsible for CGT, the buyer may pay the seller the net amount after withholding the CGT for payment to the BIR, but this should be clearly documented.

Example:

Item Amount
Purchase price ₱5,000,000
CGT to be shouldered by seller ₱300,000
Net amount released to seller ₱4,700,000

The parties should avoid vague arrangements. The deed and payment schedule should state who shoulders each tax and when payment will be made.


XLIII. Can the Parties State a Lower Selling Price to Reduce CGT?

This is legally risky and may be unlawful if it misrepresents the true consideration.

In any event, understating the price may not reduce CGT because the BIR uses the highest among the selling price, zonal value, and tax declaration value.

False declarations may expose parties to penalties, tax assessments, and potential legal consequences.

The deed should reflect the true consideration.


XLIV. CGT and Escrow Arrangements

In higher-value transactions, the parties may use escrow to ensure that:

  1. The seller receives payment only upon compliance with agreed conditions;
  2. Taxes are paid on time;
  3. Documents are released properly;
  4. The CAR is obtained;
  5. Title transfer is completed.

An escrow arrangement may help reduce risk where:

  1. There is an unpaid mortgage;
  2. The title is still subject to cancellation of encumbrance;
  3. The seller is abroad;
  4. The property is inherited;
  5. There are multiple heirs;
  6. The buyer is financing the purchase through a bank.

XLV. CGT and Bank-Financed Purchases

In bank-financed purchases, the bank may impose requirements before loan release, such as:

  1. Signed and notarized deed;
  2. Updated title;
  3. Tax declarations;
  4. Real property tax clearance;
  5. Appraisal;
  6. Mortgage documents;
  7. Insurance documents;
  8. Proof of tax payments;
  9. CAR or undertaking to process CAR.

The timing can be sensitive because CGT may become due after notarization of the deed even if the bank loan proceeds are not yet fully released.

Parties should coordinate the deed signing, loan release, tax payment, and title transfer schedule to avoid late CGT payment.


XLVI. CGT and Sale by Overseas Filipinos

If the seller is overseas, the sale may be executed through:

  1. Consularized Special Power of Attorney;
  2. Apostilled Special Power of Attorney, where applicable;
  3. Philippine notarization if the seller returns to the Philippines;
  4. Authorized representative.

CGT remains due if the sale involves Philippine real property classified as a capital asset.

The BIR may require identification documents, taxpayer information, and properly authenticated authority of the representative.


XLVII. CGT and Married Sellers

If the seller is married, the spouse’s consent may be required depending on:

  1. Property regime;
  2. Date of marriage;
  3. Whether the property is conjugal, community, or exclusive;
  4. How the title is registered;
  5. Whether the property is the family home.

CGT is not avoided simply because only one spouse signed the deed. However, failure to secure proper spousal consent may affect validity, registration, and future disputes.

The BIR and Register of Deeds may require marital information and signatures of spouses.


XLVIII. CGT and Co-Owned Property

If several persons co-own real property and sell it, CGT is generally computed on the sale of the property or the share being sold.

If only one co-owner sells their undivided share, the taxable transaction concerns that share.

Example:

Three siblings co-own land equally. One sibling sells their 1/3 share.

CGT may apply to the sale of that 1/3 interest, using the applicable valuation rules.

If all co-owners sell the entire property, the CGT applies to the entire transferred property.


XLIX. CGT on Sale of Rights

The sale of rights involving real property can be more complex.

Examples include:

  1. Sale of rights under a Contract to Sell;
  2. Assignment of buyer’s rights in a condominium project;
  3. Transfer of rights before title issuance;
  4. Sale of possessory rights;
  5. Sale of beneficial rights in property.

The tax treatment depends on the nature of the right transferred. If the transaction is treated as a disposition of real property or a real property interest, taxes may apply. If it is an assignment of contractual rights, different tax rules may be involved.

BIR practice may vary depending on the documents and the stage of ownership.


L. CGT and Unregistered Land

Unregistered land may still be subject to CGT upon sale or transfer.

Even without a Torrens title, the transaction may require:

  1. Deed of sale;
  2. Tax declaration;
  3. Proof of ownership;
  4. Real property tax clearance;
  5. BIR tax payment;
  6. CAR;
  7. Local transfer tax;
  8. Assessor’s transfer of tax declaration.

The absence of a title does not automatically exempt the transaction from CGT.


LI. CGT and Tax Declaration-Only Property

Some properties are covered only by tax declarations. A sale of such property may still be taxable.

However, buyers should be cautious because a tax declaration is not the same as a Torrens title. A tax declaration may be evidence of possession or claim of ownership, but it is not conclusive proof of ownership.

For tax purposes, the BIR may still require payment of applicable taxes before issuing a CAR or allowing transfer of tax declaration records.


LII. CGT and Agricultural Land

The sale of agricultural land by an individual not engaged in real estate business may be subject to CGT if the land is a capital asset.

However, additional laws may affect the transaction, including:

  1. Agrarian reform restrictions;
  2. Department of Agrarian Reform clearance;
  3. Zoning restrictions;
  4. Land use conversion requirements;
  5. Tenancy or farmer-beneficiary rights;
  6. Retention limits;
  7. Local government requirements.

CGT is only one part of the legal analysis.


LIII. CGT and Sale to the Government

A sale of real property to the government may have special tax considerations depending on whether the sale is voluntary, expropriatory, exempt under special law, or subject to withholding or other tax treatment.

Not all transfers to government are automatically tax-free.

The parties should examine:

  1. The legal basis of the acquisition;
  2. Whether the sale is voluntary or compulsory;
  3. Whether the property is capital or ordinary asset;
  4. Whether a special exemption applies;
  5. Required BIR rulings or certifications.

LIV. CGT and Tax-Free Exchanges

Certain exchanges may qualify as tax-free or tax-deferred under Philippine tax law, such as qualifying transfers to a corporation in exchange for shares under specific statutory conditions.

However, not every exchange of property is tax-free.

To qualify, the transaction must meet strict requirements, such as:

  1. Transfer of property to a corporation;
  2. Exchange for shares;
  3. Control requirements;
  4. Compliance with statutory and BIR documentation;
  5. Proper reporting.

If the exchange does not qualify, CGT or other taxes may apply.


LV. CGT in Corporate Reorganizations

Real property transfers in mergers, consolidations, or corporate reorganizations may be exempt, tax-deferred, or taxable depending on the structure and compliance with law.

The parties should not assume that the absence of cash consideration means no tax.

A transfer of real property may still require:

  1. BIR review;
  2. Documentary proof;
  3. CAR or tax clearance;
  4. SEC documents;
  5. Corporate approvals;
  6. Valuation documents.

LVI. CGT and Annulled or Rescinded Sales

If a sale is later annulled, rescinded, cancelled, or judicially declared void, the tax consequences depend on the timing and basis of cancellation.

If CGT has already been paid, refund or tax credit may be difficult and subject to strict procedural requirements and prescriptive periods.

The BIR may require proof that:

  1. The transaction was actually cancelled;
  2. Title was not transferred or was reconveyed;
  3. No taxable gain should be recognized;
  4. The refund claim was timely filed;
  5. Documentary requirements are complete.

Parties should avoid premature notarization of deeds if the transaction remains conditional or uncertain.


LVII. CGT and Failed Transactions

A failed transaction may still create tax complications if the deed was notarized and submitted, or if the BIR considers a taxable sale to have occurred.

For example:

  1. Buyer fails to pay after deed notarization;
  2. Bank loan is not released;
  3. Seller refuses to deliver title;
  4. Title has defects;
  5. Parties cancel after tax payment.

A better structure may be to use a Contract to Sell, escrow agreement, or conditional documents until the parties are ready for final conveyance.


LVIII. CGT and Notarization

Notarization is important because it gives the deed the character of a public document and is commonly used as the reference date for tax filing deadlines.

A notarized deed is also generally required for registration with the Register of Deeds.

For BIR purposes, the date of notarization is usually the practical starting point for counting the CGT deadline.

Therefore, parties should not notarize the deed until they are prepared to pay taxes and proceed with transfer.


LIX. CGT and Possession

Transfer of possession is not always the same as transfer of ownership.

A buyer may take possession under a lease, Contract to Sell, or preliminary agreement without immediate CGT consequences if ownership has not transferred.

However, if possession is transferred together with ownership rights, benefits, burdens, and a notarized deed, the BIR may consider the sale completed.

The legal documents and actual conduct of the parties must be consistent.


LX. CGT and Deed of Conditional Sale

A Deed of Conditional Sale may be treated differently depending on its terms.

If ownership is reserved by the seller until full payment, the transaction may resemble a Contract to Sell.

If ownership transfers immediately subject only to a resolutory condition, the BIR may treat the sale as already consummated.

Labels are not conclusive. The substance of the agreement controls.


LXI. CGT and Absolute Sale with Deferred Payment

If the parties execute a Deed of Absolute Sale but agree that the buyer will pay later, CGT may still become due because the deed already evidences a completed transfer.

This is risky for sellers because they may become liable for CGT before receiving full payment.

A seller who wants to retain ownership until full payment should consider using a properly drafted Contract to Sell rather than an immediate absolute sale.


LXII. CGT and BIR CAR Processing Timeline

Payment of CGT does not itself transfer title. It is only part of the process.

The general flow is:

  1. Parties execute notarized deed;
  2. CGT and DST are filed and paid;
  3. Documents are submitted to the BIR;
  4. BIR reviews valuation and compliance;
  5. BIR issues CAR;
  6. Local transfer tax is paid;
  7. Documents are submitted to Register of Deeds;
  8. Old title is cancelled;
  9. New title is issued;
  10. Tax declaration is transferred to new owner.

The buyer should monitor every stage until both the title and tax declaration are transferred.


LXIII. Can Title Transfer Without CGT Payment?

Generally, no.

The Register of Deeds typically requires the BIR CAR before registration of the deed and transfer of title. Since the CAR is issued only after the BIR is satisfied that applicable taxes have been paid or that the transaction is exempt, CGT compliance is usually necessary before title transfer.


LXIV. CGT and Real Property Tax

Real property tax, or RPT, is separate from CGT.

RPT is a local annual tax on real property. It is paid to the local government.

In real estate sales, the seller commonly pays RPT up to the date of sale, while the buyer pays after acquisition. The parties may agree otherwise.

The BIR and local government may require a real property tax clearance before transfer.


LXV. CGT and Broker’s Commission

Broker’s commission does not usually reduce the CGT base for the 6% CGT on capital asset real property.

Because the tax is based on gross selling price or fair market value, whichever is higher, deductions such as broker’s commission, repairs, and acquisition cost generally do not reduce the CGT.

This is why CGT can apply even where the seller has little or no actual economic gain.


LXVI. CGT Even Without Actual Gain

Philippine CGT on capital asset real property is often described as a tax on presumed gain.

The tax may apply even if the seller:

  1. Sold at a loss;
  2. Sold below acquisition cost;
  3. Used the proceeds to pay debt;
  4. Paid substantial broker’s commission;
  5. Made no actual profit.

Example:

Seller bought land for ₱6,000,000 and sells it for ₱5,000,000.

Even though the seller has an economic loss, CGT may still be due based on the highest applicable value.


LXVII. CGT and Improvements Not Declared

If there are improvements on the land that are not declared for real property tax purposes, the BIR may require clarification.

The parties may need:

  1. Certificate of No Improvement, if vacant;
  2. Updated tax declaration for improvements;
  3. Appraisal or valuation;
  4. Inspection or verification;
  5. Assessor’s certification.

Undeclared improvements may delay CAR processing.


LXVIII. CGT and Multiple Titles

If a sale involves several titles, CGT computation and CAR issuance may involve each title.

The BIR may require:

  1. Separate valuation per title;
  2. Separate tax declarations;
  3. Allocation of selling price;
  4. Separate CARs or eCARs;
  5. Separate local transfer tax payments;
  6. Separate registration fees.

The deed should clearly identify each title and the allocated consideration, especially if values differ.


LXIX. CGT and Partial Sale of Property

If only a portion of a titled property is sold, CGT may be computed on the portion sold.

However, practical complications arise because the title may need subdivision, survey approval, and issuance of new titles.

Documents may include:

  1. Subdivision plan;
  2. Technical descriptions;
  3. Approved survey;
  4. Deed of sale over portion;
  5. Tax declaration allocation;
  6. BIR valuation of portion sold.

The BIR may require a reasonable allocation of value.


LXX. CGT and Sale of Undivided Interest

A co-owner may sell an undivided share in real property. CGT may apply to the sale of that share if it is a capital asset.

Example:

A owns 50% of land and sells the 50% undivided share to B.

The CGT base may be the value attributable to the 50% share, using the highest applicable valuation basis.


LXXI. CGT and Assignment of Condominium Rights Before Title

Buyers sometimes assign rights to a condominium unit before the condominium certificate of title is issued.

The tax treatment may depend on whether the assignment is treated as:

  1. Sale of contractual rights;
  2. Sale of real property rights;
  3. Transfer of beneficial ownership;
  4. Cancellation and reissuance by developer;
  5. Ordinary business transaction.

BIR requirements may vary. Developers may also impose transfer fees and documentary requirements.


LXXII. CGT and Sale by Non-Resident Aliens

A non-resident alien selling real property located in the Philippines may be subject to Philippine tax on the sale.

If the property is classified as a capital asset, the 6% CGT may apply.

Practical issues include:

  1. TIN registration;
  2. Consularized or apostilled documents;
  3. Authorized representative;
  4. Foreign identification;
  5. Proof of ownership;
  6. Tax treaty questions in unusual cases;
  7. Repatriation of proceeds;
  8. Bank compliance requirements.

The location of the property in the Philippines gives the Philippines taxing jurisdiction over the transaction.


LXXIII. CGT and Sale by Foreign Corporations

A foreign corporation selling Philippine real property may have Philippine tax obligations. The tax treatment depends on the corporation’s status, the nature of the property, and the applicable provisions of Philippine tax law.

Special care is needed because corporate sellers may involve:

  1. Capital asset or ordinary asset classification;
  2. Withholding tax;
  3. Income tax;
  4. Possible branch or permanent establishment issues;
  5. Documentary stamp tax;
  6. BIR registration requirements;
  7. SEC or corporate authority documents.

LXXIV. CGT and Property Used for Business

If an individual sells a property used in business, such as a rental apartment or commercial building, the classification may require closer analysis.

A property used in business and subject to depreciation may be considered an ordinary asset, not a capital asset. If so, the 6% CGT may not apply.

Instead, the sale may be subject to ordinary income tax and withholding tax rules.

The taxpayer’s accounting records, tax filings, depreciation claims, business registration, and use of the property are relevant.


LXXV. CGT and Rental Property

A rental property may or may not be a capital asset, depending on the facts.

If the taxpayer treats the property as part of a rental business, reports rental income, claims depreciation, and uses the property in business, the BIR may classify it as an ordinary asset.

If the property is merely held passively and not treated as a business asset, the analysis may differ.

Classification should be resolved before filing taxes.


LXXVI. CGT and Property Held for Investment

Investment property held by an individual who is not engaged in real estate business is often treated as a capital asset.

Example:

An individual bought a vacant lot ten years ago as an investment and later sells it. The individual is not a real estate dealer or developer.

The sale will likely be subject to 6% CGT.


LXXVII. CGT and Sale by a Person Engaged in Buy-and-Sell of Real Estate

A person who regularly buys and sells real estate may be considered engaged in real estate business.

Properties held primarily for sale to customers may be ordinary assets.

The sale may therefore be subject to ordinary income tax, withholding tax, and VAT or percentage tax where applicable, rather than 6% CGT.

Relevant facts include:

  1. Frequency of sales;
  2. Nature of business;
  3. Registration with BIR;
  4. Advertising of properties;
  5. Development activities;
  6. Subdivision of lots;
  7. Intent at acquisition;
  8. Treatment in books and tax returns.

LXXVIII. CGT and VAT

CGT and VAT usually do not apply to the same capital asset sale by an individual not engaged in business.

VAT is generally associated with sales in the course of trade or business.

A one-time sale of a personal residential property by an individual is usually not subject to VAT.

However, sale of real property by a real estate developer or dealer may be subject to VAT if applicable thresholds and conditions are met.


LXXIX. CGT and Percentage Tax

Percentage tax may apply to certain business taxpayers not subject to VAT. It is generally relevant to ordinary business transactions, not isolated sales of personal capital assets.

A sale subject to 6% CGT is generally treated differently from a sale subject to business tax.


LXXX. CGT and Withholding by Buyer

For capital asset sales subject to CGT, the buyer does not usually withhold creditable withholding tax because CGT is a final tax paid through the CGT return.

For ordinary asset sales, the buyer may be required to withhold creditable withholding tax and remit it to the BIR.

Thus, the buyer must determine whether the seller’s property is capital or ordinary asset.


LXXXI. Who Should File the CGT Return?

The seller is generally responsible for filing the CGT return.

However, in practice:

  1. The buyer may prepare and file it;
  2. A broker may assist;
  3. A lawyer may prepare documents;
  4. An accountant may compute taxes;
  5. A representative may transact with the BIR through a Special Power of Attorney.

The return must correctly identify the taxpayer, property, transaction, and valuation basis.


LXXXII. Importance of Tax Identification Number

Both seller and buyer usually need TINs for BIR processing.

If a party has no TIN, registration or updating may be required.

For estates, corporations, foreign persons, or non-residents, additional registration steps may be necessary.

Incorrect TIN information may delay CAR issuance.


LXXXIII. CGT and eCAR

The BIR has used electronic Certificates Authorizing Registration, commonly called eCARs, in many transactions.

An eCAR allows the Register of Deeds to verify BIR authority electronically.

The eCAR generally identifies:

  1. Property;
  2. Seller or transferor;
  3. Buyer or transferee;
  4. Tax type;
  5. Transaction details;
  6. Authorized registration.

The Register of Deeds relies on this authority for transfer of title.


LXXXIV. Common Mistakes in CGT Transactions

Common mistakes include:

  1. Assuming buyer always pays CGT;
  2. Assuming CGT is based only on actual profit;
  3. Using the selling price even when zonal value is higher;
  4. Missing the 30-day filing deadline;
  5. Not checking whether the property is capital or ordinary asset;
  6. Not verifying tax declarations for improvements;
  7. Not settling estate tax before sale by heirs;
  8. Executing a notarized deed before loan approval;
  9. Understating the selling price;
  10. Ignoring DST deadline;
  11. Failing to secure spouse consent;
  12. Failing to update TIN or taxpayer information;
  13. Assuming donation is subject to CGT instead of donor’s tax;
  14. Assuming inheritance is subject to CGT instead of estate tax;
  15. Not budgeting for local transfer tax and registration fees.

LXXXV. Practical Timeline for a Standard Sale

A standard sale of a residential property classified as a capital asset often follows this sequence:

  1. Buyer conducts due diligence;
  2. Parties agree on price and tax allocation;
  3. Seller secures title, tax declaration, and clearances;
  4. Parties sign Contract to Sell or reservation agreement, if needed;
  5. Buyer arranges financing;
  6. Parties execute and notarize Deed of Absolute Sale;
  7. CGT is filed and paid within the applicable deadline;
  8. DST is filed and paid within the applicable deadline;
  9. BIR CAR or eCAR is processed;
  10. Local transfer tax is paid;
  11. Documents are submitted to Register of Deeds;
  12. New title is issued;
  13. Tax declaration is transferred to buyer;
  14. Buyer updates real property tax records and association records.

LXXXVI. Sample CGT Computation

Assume the following:

Item Amount
Contract price ₱8,000,000
BIR zonal value ₱9,000,000
Tax declaration value ₱6,000,000

Highest value: ₱9,000,000 CGT rate: 6%

CGT = ₱9,000,000 × 6% CGT = ₱540,000

Even though the buyer pays only ₱8,000,000, the CGT is computed on ₱9,000,000.


LXXXVII. Sample Contract Clause on CGT

A deed or contract may include a tax allocation clause such as:

The Seller shall be responsible for the payment of capital gains tax arising from the sale of the Property. The Buyer shall be responsible for documentary stamp tax, local transfer tax, registration fees, and expenses for the issuance of the new certificate of title, unless otherwise agreed in writing by the parties.

Another possible clause:

The Buyer shall advance the payment of capital gains tax for the account of the Seller, and the amount so paid shall be deducted from the purchase price payable to the Seller. The parties agree to cooperate in the filing of tax returns and submission of documents required for the issuance of the Certificate Authorizing Registration.


LXXXVIII. Due Diligence Before Paying CGT

Before paying CGT, parties should verify:

  1. Title authenticity;
  2. Registered owner;
  3. Encumbrances;
  4. Liens and annotations;
  5. Real property tax status;
  6. Tax declaration details;
  7. Zonal value;
  8. Whether improvements are declared;
  9. Seller’s civil status;
  10. Authority of representatives;
  11. Estate settlement, if applicable;
  12. Corporate approvals, if applicable;
  13. Possession issues;
  14. Tenants or occupants;
  15. Homeowners’ association dues;
  16. Developer restrictions for condominiums;
  17. Agrarian or zoning restrictions.

Payment of CGT does not cure defects in ownership or title.


LXXXIX. Relationship Between CGT and Transfer of Ownership

CGT payment is a tax compliance step. It does not, by itself, transfer ownership.

Ownership transfer requires a valid sale or conveyance, compliance with legal formalities, and registration when dealing with registered land.

In registered land transactions, the buyer obtains stronger protection when the deed is registered and a new title is issued.

Thus, the complete process requires both:

  1. Tax compliance with the BIR; and
  2. Registration with the Register of Deeds.

XC. Prescription and Refund Issues

If CGT is incorrectly paid, a taxpayer may consider filing a claim for refund or tax credit.

However, tax refunds are subject to strict rules, documentary requirements, and prescriptive periods.

A refund claim may be denied if:

  1. Filed late;
  2. Unsupported by documents;
  3. Transaction was actually taxable;
  4. Taxpayer lacks standing;
  5. There is no proof of erroneous payment;
  6. Procedural requirements were not followed.

It is better to classify the transaction correctly before payment than to rely on a refund later.


XCI. Legal Effect of Private Agreements on Tax Liability

Parties may agree who will shoulder taxes, but such agreement generally binds only the parties.

For example, if the deed states that the buyer will shoulder CGT, the seller may still be the taxpayer for CGT purposes. The BIR will still evaluate the seller’s disposition of property.

If the buyer fails to pay CGT despite agreeing to do so, the seller may have a contractual claim against the buyer. But tax compliance may still be required before title transfer.

Thus, tax allocation clauses should be clear and enforceable.


XCII. Best Practices

Parties should observe the following best practices:

  1. Determine whether the property is capital or ordinary asset before signing;
  2. Verify BIR zonal value before finalizing price;
  3. Determine who will pay CGT, DST, transfer tax, and registration fees;
  4. Avoid notarizing the deed before funds and documents are ready;
  5. Use escrow for complex or high-value transactions;
  6. Confirm whether improvements are properly declared;
  7. Secure real property tax clearance;
  8. Check if estate tax or donor’s tax issues exist;
  9. Use accurate selling price in the deed;
  10. File and pay CGT within the deadline;
  11. Monitor CAR issuance;
  12. Complete title and tax declaration transfer;
  13. Keep copies of all returns, receipts, CAR, title, and tax declarations.

XCIII. Key Rules to Remember

  1. CGT usually applies to the sale of real property classified as a capital asset.
  2. The legal taxpayer is generally the seller.
  3. Parties may agree that the buyer will shoulder CGT.
  4. CGT is generally 6%.
  5. The tax base is generally the highest among selling price, tax declaration value, and BIR zonal value.
  6. CGT is generally due within 30 days from the sale, commonly counted from notarization of the deed.
  7. CGT is generally required before the BIR issues the CAR.
  8. Without the CAR, title transfer usually cannot proceed.
  9. A Contract to Sell does not usually trigger CGT if ownership has not transferred.
  10. A Deed of Absolute Sale usually triggers CGT even if the purchase price is payable later.
  11. Donation is generally subject to donor’s tax, not CGT.
  12. Inheritance is generally subject to estate tax, not CGT.
  13. Sale by heirs after inheritance may be subject to CGT.
  14. Sale of ordinary assets is generally subject to ordinary income tax and withholding tax, not CGT.
  15. Late CGT payment results in penalties and delay.

XCIV. Conclusion

In Philippine real property transactions, Capital Gains Tax is usually paid after the sale, exchange, or disposition of real property classified as a capital asset and before the transfer of title to the buyer. The practical trigger is commonly the execution and notarization of the Deed of Absolute Sale or equivalent conveyance document.

The tax is generally paid within 30 days from the sale or notarization of the deed and is computed at 6% of the highest among the gross selling price, BIR zonal value, and fair market value in the tax declaration. Although the seller is generally the taxpayer, the buyer may agree to shoulder the tax as part of the purchase arrangement.

The timing of CGT payment is critical because the BIR will generally not issue the Certificate Authorizing Registration unless the required taxes are paid or the transaction is proven exempt. Without the CAR, the Register of Deeds will ordinarily not transfer the title.

The safest approach is to determine the property classification, verify the zonal value, settle the parties’ tax allocation, prepare documents, and coordinate payment before notarizing the final deed of sale.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.