Considering real estate VAT rules
Commissions for real estate brokers are subject to withholding tax under Section 57(B) of the NIRC. As for VAT, brokers must pay a 12% tax on commissions, but only if their gross sales exceed the VAT threshold of PHP 3,000,000. This threshold stays at 3 million for services, but for the sale of residential properties, it's been adjusted to 3.6 million since 2021. If the gross receipts are below the threshold, brokers could be taxed at a lower rate or exempt.
Explaining VAT and CWT obligations
VAT obligations involve registration, billing, filing returns (using BIR Form 2550Q), and submitting a summary of sales/purchases. Payors can claim input VAT, though withheld VAT has exceptions, such as government purchases (5% final withholding). For property developers, they withhold VAT and creditable withholding tax (CWT) on commissions. Real estate brokers face varying rates, 5% or 10%, based on income and threshold. Changes occurred, with the TRAIN law adjusting rates and classifications for "professional fees" starting in 2018. Regular updates, including RR No. 11-2018, clarify rates.
Thought for 38 seconds
WITHHOLDING TAX AND VAT ON REAL-ESTATE COMMISSIONS IN THE PHILIPPINES (Everything You Need to Know in 2025)
1. Statutory Foundations
| Source | Key Provisions Relevant to Commissions |
|---|---|
| National Internal Revenue Code (NIRC), as amended | §57(B) (creditable withholding tax on income payments), §108 (VAT on services), §236 (registration); §247–255 (penalties) |
| Revenue Regulations (RR) 2-98 and endless amendments | Enumerates income payments subject to CWT; §2.57.2(A)(7) squarely covers “commissions of independent contractors such as real-estate brokers.” |
| RR 11-2018 | Re-works the CWT rate matrix after the TRAIN Law; introduces “top withholding agents” (TWAs). |
| RR 3-2022 | Consolidates filing deadlines and clarifies that VAT is excluded from the CWT base. |
| Republic Act 10963 (TRAIN) | Raises the VAT-registration threshold to ₱3 million aggregate gross receipts in any 12-month period. |
| Republic Act 11534 (CREATE) | Temporarily cut percentage tax to 1 % (01 Jul 2020 – 30 Jun 2023); back to 3 % thereafter. |
| Republic Act 9646 (RESA) | Professional regulation of real-estate service practitioners (brokers, appraisers, consultants, salespersons). |
(RMCs, BIR Opinions, SEC notices, and Professional Regulatory Board resolutions supply color but the backbone is above.)
2. Creditable Withholding Tax (CWT) on Commissions
| Who Withholds? | When? | Rate Schedule in 2025 | Forms/Certificates |
|---|---|---|---|
| • Property developers, project owners, lessors, or any person/corporation paying a commission. • Government offices if procuring brokerage services. • Top Withholding Agents (TWAs) designated by BIR. |
Upon payment or accrual, whichever comes first (cash or payable booking). | Individuals (including single-prop brokers) • 5 % – payee not VAT-registered or did not exceed ₱3 M receipts previous year. • 10 % – payee VAT-registered and exceeded ₱3 M. Corporations/Partnerships • Flat 10 %. (If payer is a TWA, add 5 percentage-points: 10 % → 15 %, 5 % → 10 %.) |
Monthly remittance: BIR Form 0619-E (electronically, within 10th day of following month; eFPS filers have staggered dates). Quarterly summary: BIR Form 1601-EQ (last day of month following quarter). Certificate to broker: BIR Form 2307 (within 20 days after end of quarter or upon request). |
The CWT base is always the net commission exclusive of VAT (if any). RR 3-2022 reiterated this longstanding rule to stop the common mistake of computing 5 %/10 % on a VAT-inclusive amount.
2.1 Practical Computation (illustrative)
| Particulars | Ordinary Payer | Top Withholding Agent |
|---|---|---|
| Gross commission due to individual broker (VAT-registered) | ₱100 000 | ₱100 000 |
| Output VAT @12 % | + 12 000 | + 12 000 |
| Amount billed | ₱112 000 | ₱112 000 |
| Creditable W/T (10 % or 15 % of ₱100 000) | 10 000 | 15 000 |
| Net cash released | ₱102 000 | ₱97 000 |
| Broker issues VAT Official Receipt for ₱112 000; payer issues Form 2307 showing withheld tax. |
The broker will claim:
- Input VAT (if any) vs. ₱12 000 output VAT;
- CWT credit of ₱10 000/₱15 000 against quarterly income-tax due.
3. Value-Added Tax (VAT) on Brokerage Services
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| VAT nature | Brokerage is a sale of service under §108(A) NIRC. |
| Standard rate | 12 % on gross receipts/commission. |
| Threshold for mandatory VAT registration | ₱3 million aggregate gross receipts in any 12-month span. The moment the threshold is breached (or expected to be breached within the next 30 days), the broker must secure VAT registration via BIR Form 1905 and start issuing VAT official receipts. |
| Non-VAT option | If gross receipts stay ≤ ₱3 million, the broker may remain “Non-VAT” and instead pay Percentage Tax (PT) at: • 1 % up to 30 Jun 2023 (CREATE relief) • 3 % beginning 01 Jul 2023 onward. |
| Filing & payment | VAT-registered: BIR Form 2550-Q (quarterly only since 2023), due within 25 days after each quarter. Non-VAT: BIR Form 2551-Q (percentage tax), due on the last day of the month following the quarter. |
| Input VAT credits | Allowed on purchases of goods/services “in the course of trade or business” and properly substantiated by VAT invoices/official receipts issued in the broker’s name and bearing TIN/VAT number. |
| Government final-withheld VAT | If the payor is a government entity, it withholds 5 % final VAT; broker recognizes only the 7 % difference as output VAT. |
4. Interaction Between CWT and VAT
Separate obligations. CWT is an income-tax pre-payment; VAT is a consumption tax on the service itself.
Sequence at billing:
- Compute commission;
- Add 12 % VAT (if applicable);
- Compute CWT on the net commission (excluding VAT).
Bookkeeping entries must reflect:
- Debit Accounts Receivable (Commission + VAT)
- Credit Output VAT and Service Income (Commission)
- Recognize Withholding Tax Receivable (CWT) upon receipt of Form 2307.
Reconciliation: At income-tax filing (Form 1701/1702RT), CWT certificates are matched against Alpha List; at VAT return the output less input equals VAT payable.
5. Special Situations & Frequently Confusing Points
| Scenario | Treatment |
|---|---|
| In-house salespersons paid purely on commission | If they are employees (w/ employer–employee relationship, with 13th-month pay, etc.), amounts form part of wages → Withholding Tax on Compensation, not CWT; no VAT. |
| Referral fees / finder’s fees | Same CWT and VAT rules—distinction is nomenclature only. |
| Split commissions among co-brokers | Each broker reports only the share actually earned; whoever invoices the developer collects and remits VAT/CWT on full amount, then issues secondary ORs/2307s as appropriate. |
| Foreign real-estate brokers marketing PH projects | Unless licensed locally under RESA, they cannot legally earn commissions; if service is actually rendered abroad and paid abroad, NIRC source-of-income rules may exempt Philippine tax, but BIR often asserts situs because property is located in the Philippines. Practical result: Philippine payer will still withhold 25 % FWT on income of non-resident alien or 30 % branch-profit tax on non-resident foreign corporation. |
| Lease commissions | Same CWT/VAT mechanics; VAT base is commission, not monthly rent. |
| Installment-based commissions | CWT and VAT are triggered per installment as and when the commission becomes due/paid. |
| Commission claw-back | If commission is reversed (e.g., buyer defaults), issuer may amend VAT & CWT by credit memo and adjust subsequent returns; keep documentary trail. |
| Electronic invoicing (EIS) | Large Taxpayers & selected pilot entities must issue VAT ORs via EIS; printed Form 2307 remains the CWT proof. |
6. Compliance Road Map for Brokers (2025 Edition)
Register/Update with BIR (1901/1905), DTI/SEC, PRC (for brokers).
Books of Accounts – CAS or loose-leaf; ensure VAT segregation.
Issue Official Receipts (or Electronic Invoices) that separately state Commission, VAT, and withheld tax.
File & Pay:
- 0619-E (monthly CWT)
- 1601-EQ (quarterly CWT)
- 2550-Q (quarterly VAT) or 2551-Q (percentage tax)
- Annual ITR 1701/1702 with SAWT attachment.
Give/Collect Certificates: 2307 from payors; 2306 to payees if the broker also withholds (e.g., office rent).
Reconcile ledgers vs. BIR’s Alphalist Validation & Matching System (AMVMS) to avoid “tax deficiency” letters.
Retain records for at least 10 years (TRAIN extended the period when returns are filed electronically).
7. Penalties for Non-Compliance
| Violation | Basic Penalty | Surcharges & Interest |
|---|---|---|
| Failure to withhold/remit CWT | Deficiency tax + 25 % surcharge | 12 % interest p.a. (daily) until full payment |
| Late VAT filing | ₱1,000 per return + 25 % surcharge on VAT payable | Same interest |
| Failure to issue VAT OR or incorrect information | Criminal liability (§264 NIRC): fine ₱1,000–₱50,000 and/or 2–4 years imprisonment | |
| Failure to register for VAT despite exceeding threshold | Pay uncollected output VAT plus 25 %–50 % surcharge, interest, compromise penalty; possible closure under Oplan Kandado. |
8. Contract & Process Tips
- State the tax clause clearly: “The developer shall withhold tax in accordance with RR 2-98 and shall issue BIR Form 2307; the commission is VAT exclusive; VAT shall be for the account of the broker.”
- Ask whether the payer is a TWA (affects the rate).
- Attach a copy of PRC License & BIR Certificate of Registration to each invoice to avoid vatable/non-vatable confusion.
- Use spreadsheets (or BIR’s e-RELIEF) to track CWT, VAT, receipts, and reference numbers.
- Schedule quarterly internal audits before filing 2550-Q/1601-EQ to catch mismatches.
9. Bottom Line
If you remember only three things:
- VAT first, CWT second—never compute CWT on a VAT-inclusive commission.
- Cross the ₱3 million line and you are automatically a VAT taxpayer (you may not un-register later just because business slows).
- Your Form 2307 is gold: it is your official credit against income tax and your first line of defense in any BIR audit.
Handled properly, the VAT you collect and the CWT withheld from you are not costs; they are pass-throughs and tax credits. Handled sloppily, they turn into penalties, disallowed deductions, and sleepless nights.
Stay registered, segregate VAT, withhold correctly, file on time—and your real-estate commission income will be as solid as the title on your client’s property.