How to Demand a Refund or Replacement for Defective Goods or Unperformed Services

Quick answer

Send the seller or service provider a written demand. Say what you paid for, what went wrong, and what you want the business to do. Attach proof of the transaction and give a specific date for a written response.

For defective consumer goods, you can generally demand correction of the defect. If it remains uncorrected after 30 days under Article 100 of the Consumer Act, you can choose a replacement, reimbursement, or a proportionate price reduction. You can seek one of those remedies immediately if replacing the defective parts would compromise the product’s quality or characteristics and reduce its value. A warranty claim can follow different rules. Supreme Court E-Library

For poorly performed consumer services, Article 102 allows you to choose performance at no extra charge where applicable, reimbursement, or a proportionate price reduction. If the provider never performed the service, a substantial breach of the agreement can support a demand to end the contract and recover what you paid. The contract, the agreed date, and any work already delivered matter. Supreme Court E-Library

What you can demand for defective goods

Article 100 of Republic Act No. 7394 applies to quality problems that make a consumer product unfit for its intended use, reduce its value, or make it inconsistent with the label, packaging, or advertising. You can ask the supplier to replace the defective parts. If the problem remains uncorrected within the applicable period, you can choose among these remedies. Supreme Court E-Library

  • Replacement with a product of the same kind in proper working condition.
  • Reimbursement of the amount paid, with the monetary adjustment provided by law. A claim for proven losses or damages may also be available.
  • A proportionate price reduction if you are willing to keep the item at a lower price.

The default correction period is 30 days. The parties may agree to a different period of 7 to 180 days. The immediate-remedy exception depends on what replacing the defective parts would do to the product. If you invoke it, explain the specific effect on quality, characteristics, and value, and include a technician’s report if you have one. If an equivalent replacement is unavailable, the law allows a different kind, brand, or model with an adjustment for the price difference. Supreme Court E-Library

If you are claiming under a warranty

For a consumer product warranty claim covered by Article 68, present the item to the immediate seller with either the warranty card or the official receipt. Article 68 allows you to elect repair or a purchase-price refund from the warrantor when an express warranty is breached. If you elect repair, the warranty work generally must be completed within 30 days, subject to an extension for circumstances beyond the warrantor’s or its representative’s control. If you elect a refund under this provision, the amount attributable to your use before discovering the problem is deducted. A full warranty must also let you choose refund or replacement without charge when the defect persists after a reasonable number of attempts. Supreme Court E-Library

If the store says “No Return, No Exchange”

A store policy cannot take away a remedy the law gives you for a covered defect. If the item is sound and you simply changed your mind, check the store’s voluntary return policy. Buyer-caused damage, a disclosed flaw, an as-is sale, or a secondhand purchase can change the analysis. For a used item, keep the listing and any messages about its condition, especially if the seller made a specific promise or the defect was concealed. Fair Trade Enforcement Bureau

What you can demand for an unperformed or poorly performed service

If the provider did some work, but it was deficient, identify the part that was unusable, incomplete, or different from what was advertised. Under Article 102, you can ask for the work to be done properly at no extra charge where applicable, reimbursement, or a proportionate reduction. The 30-day correction rule for goods in Article 100 does not govern Article 102. Supreme Court E-Library

If the provider did no work, identify what was due, when it was due, and how much you paid. Under Civil Code Article 1191, a substantial breach of reciprocal obligations can support a demand for performance or for resolution of the contract and return of the payment. A missed event date can be decisive if performance on that date was the purpose of the booking. For a delay, partial performance, or an advance payment marked “non-refundable,” the outcome depends on the contract, who caused the failure, and what you received. A written demand helps establish when you called for performance or repayment. Supreme Court E-Library

The Consumer Act’s warranty provisions exclude professional services rendered by covered professionals in their respective fields. If your dispute concerns professional work, check the engagement agreement, applicable professional rules, and Civil Code remedies. Supreme Court E-Library

How to make a written demand

  1. Identify the business. Use the legal name and address on the invoice, contract, or order record. For an online purchase, save the merchant’s profile and open a dispute through the platform’s return or complaint process.
  2. Write a short timeline. Include the purchase or booking date, amount paid, promised delivery or completion date, when you discovered the problem, and any inspection or repair dates.
  3. Ask for a specific remedy. Give the refund amount and explain how you calculated it, or identify the replacement or service you want. Set a reasonable date for a written response. If the business needs to inspect or collect the item, ask for written instructions.
  4. Keep proof of delivery and handover. Save the email, platform ticket, courier tracking, or signed receiving copy. If you leave the item for inspection, get a job order or acknowledgment showing the serial number, condition, accessories handed over, and reported defect.

You can adapt this wording.

I paid ₱[amount] on [date] for [product or service], under [invoice, order, or booking number]. The agreement or listing stated [what was promised]. On [date], [describe the defect or what the provider failed to do]. I reported the problem on [date], and [briefly describe the response or repair history].

I request [refund of ₱___, replacement, or completion at no extra charge] because [brief reason]. Please confirm your response by [date]. If the item needs to be inspected or returned, please confirm the arrangements in writing. I have attached copies of [supporting records].

Evidence to keep

  • Proof of payment and terms. Keep the invoice or e-receipt, order confirmation, bank or e-wallet transaction record, warranty, contract, and cancellation terms.
  • Proof of what was promised. Save the full listing or quote, product specifications, service scope, agreed date, and relevant messages.
  • Proof of the problem. Keep dated photos or videos, model and serial numbers, packaging and batch details where relevant, diagnostic reports, repair orders, and delivery records. For an unperformed service, save booking confirmations, missed appointments, and messages about cancellations or rescheduling.
  • Proof of your efforts and losses. Save complaint numbers, written replies, settlement offers, and receipts for expenses you claim resulted from the problem.

If the seller refuses or stops responding

For an online purchase, use the internal dispute process first

For transactions covered by the Internet Transactions Act, use the internal complaint mechanism of the digital platform, marketplace, or e-retailer before filing with a government agency or court, or resorting to alternative dispute resolution. The mechanism is deemed exhausted if the complaint remains unresolved seven calendar days after filing. Save the ticket and filing date. The merchant is primarily liable under the Act, while platform liability depends on the statutory conditions. The Act excludes consumer-to-consumer transactions. Supreme Court E-Library

If you obtain a refund or replacement, make the original item available for return. The Act generally provides for return within a reasonable period at no cost to you, subject to any applicable agreement. Keep proof of pickup or delivery. Supreme Court E-Library

File with DTI or the agency that handles the product or service

The Department of Trade and Industry handles many consumer complaints involving defective products, deficient services, warranties, and deceptive sales. File through the DTI Consumer Care portal, email consumercare@dti.gov.ph, or check the Fair Trade Enforcement Bureau’s instructions for the appropriate DTI office. Submit the initial complaint form, proof of the transaction, a short timeline, supporting evidence, and the specific remedy you want. For a regulated product or service, check which agency handles the issue. Product-safety concerns involving FDA-regulated goods can be reported to the FDA. Fair Trade Enforcement Bureau

DTI consumer complaints go through mediation first. If there is no settlement, the mediation officer issues a Certificate to File Action. To pursue DTI adjudication, submit the certificate, a verified complaint, the required certification against forum shopping, and your evidence. DTI’s guidance gives 15 days from receipt of the decision to appeal on the prescribed grounds. Fair Trade Enforcement Bureau

Consider small claims if you are asking for money

A claim for money owed under a contract for services or the sale of personal property may qualify for small claims in a first-level court if it is ₱1 million or less, exclusive of interest and costs. Use the Supreme Court’s Form 01-SCC and attach your supporting documents. If you want an order compelling the seller to replace the item or the provider to finish the work, check which procedure fits that remedy. Barangay conciliation may be required first if the dispute falls within its authority, as it generally does for disputes between individuals actually residing in the same city or municipality, subject to statutory exceptions. Supreme Court of the Philippines

Deadlines and common mistakes

  • Distinguish the time to correct a defect from the time to file a claim. Consumer Act claims generally prescribe after two years from consummation of the transaction or commission of the specified deceptive, unfair, or unconscionable practice. For a hidden defect, the period runs from discovery. A claim based on the Civil Code’s specific hidden-defect provisions can have a six-month period from delivery. Warranty, platform, and sector-specific deadlines can differ. Supreme Court E-Library
  • Save the records before a listing or chat disappears. Follow up phone calls in writing. Keep originals and provide copies where accepted.
  • Document the item before sending it back. Use the authorized return channel and keep the tracking number or receiving copy. Avoid unauthorized repairs or alterations that could make the cause of the defect harder to establish.
  • Read any settlement before accepting it. Check whether a voucher, partial refund, or replacement closes the complaint or releases any further claim. Disclose related proceedings when filing a formal complaint. Fair Trade Enforcement Bureau

When to get help promptly

Stop using a product that poses a safety risk. If someone is injured or becomes ill, seek medical care, preserve the product and packaging if safe, and keep medical records and receipts. Report the hazard to the appropriate regulator. Get legal help promptly if the loss is substantial, the business disputes responsibility for an injury, or a filing deadline is close. The Consumer Act has separate provisions for harm caused by unsafe products or services. Supreme Court E-Library

If the seller appears to have used a fake identity, disappeared after payment, or obtained access to your account, contact your bank or e-wallet provider promptly and preserve the payment and account records. DTI’s complaint guidance also lists law-enforcement channels for suspected fraud. Fair Trade Enforcement Bureau

Frequently asked questions

Can I complain if I lost the receipt?

Yes. DTI accepts other proof of the transaction, such as an invoice, delivery receipt, or job order. An order confirmation and a payment record can also help connect the purchase to the seller. For a product warranty claim under Article 68, the law specifies either the warranty card or the official receipt, presented with the product. Fair Trade Enforcement Bureau

Does a seven-day store return policy end my rights?

A store’s return window cannot cut off a remedy that still applies under the Consumer Act. Report the defect promptly and keep the date you first raised it. For covered online transactions, the separate seven-calendar-day rule measures when an unresolved internal complaint is deemed exhausted. Supreme Court E-Library

What if the defective item is a brand-new car?

The Philippine Lemon Law applies to covered brand-new motor vehicles if the nonconformity is reported within 12 months from original delivery or 20,000 kilometers of operation after delivery, whichever comes first. Invoking that law generally requires at least four separate repair attempts for the same complaint, written notice, and a final repair opportunity. The Supreme Court has held that the Lemon Law is one available remedy and that a buyer may pursue an applicable Consumer Act remedy. Supreme Court E-Library

Official sources

This article provides general Philippine legal information. The remedy and filing deadline for a specific dispute depend on the facts, documents, and applicable rules. Sources checked on November 20, 2026.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.