Can a Contractor Demand More Than a Fixed Contract Price?

Quick answer

Generally, no. Under Article 1724 of the Philippine Civil Code, a contractor who agreed to build according to specified plans for a fixed price cannot unilaterally raise the price or walk away because labor or materials became more expensive. For extra payment based on a change to the agreed plans or specifications, the owner must authorize the change in writing, and both parties must determine the additional price in writing. Supreme Court E-Library

If you received a higher bill, ask the contractor to identify the work that changed, who approved it, and where both parties agreed to the price. If the work stayed the same and the only explanation is that cement, steel, or wages cost more than expected, Article 1724 generally leaves that cost with the contractor. Check the signed contract for any applicable price-adjustment provision. Government infrastructure contracts have separate procurement rules. Supreme Court E-Library

When a contractor can charge for a change

Start with the scope the parties actually agreed to. Read the signed contract with the incorporated drawings, specifications, inclusions, exclusions, and any bill of quantities. A task can be part of the original lump-sum scope even if the contractor left it off a costing sheet. An expressly excluded item, a provisional allowance, or a quantity payable at agreed unit rates calls for a closer look at the contract’s pricing terms. Supreme Court E-Library

For a change to the original plans or specifications, Article 1724 requires both of the following:

  1. The owner authorizes the change in writing. If an architect, engineer, or project manager gave the instruction, check whether that person had authority to bind the owner for that change.
  2. Both parties determine the additional price in writing. The documents should show the agreed amount or an agreed written basis from which the amount can be determined. A contractor’s estimate or invoice by itself shows what the contractor is asking to be paid. Supreme Court E-Library

A signed change order stating the scope, price, and schedule impact is the clearest record. Several writings can also satisfy the law. In Filinvest Alabang, Inc. v. Century Iron Works, Inc., the Supreme Court found that written site instructions and a valuation based on a previously agreed bill of quantities, documented in written breakdowns, satisfied Article 1724. In Shangri-La Properties, Inc. v. BF Corporation, the Court read the owner’s written instruction together with the specific variation orders carrying the owner’s approval. Supreme Court E-Library

For example, if the owner requests a larger kitchen window after signing, record the revised dimensions and the agreed additional charge or credit before the contractor orders materials. If the contractor simply underestimated the cost of the window already specified, that is a cost overrun on the original work. Supreme Court E-Library

Price adjustments and unexpected site conditions

A price-adjustment clause. A contract described as fixed price may contain a specific adjustment mechanism. Check whether it covers the item claimed, what event triggers it, how the adjustment is calculated, and what notices and approvals are required. A contractor relying on the clause should identify the exact provision and show the calculation. Ordinary price increases alone do not establish extraordinary inflation under Article 1250 of the Civil Code. Supreme Court E-Library

Unexpected site conditions. Buried obstructions, unsuitable soil, or hidden damage can require a change in the work. Whether the owner must pay extra depends on the original scope, who assumed the risk under the contract, and how the revised work was authorized and priced. Document the condition as soon as it is discovered, notify the other party as required by the contract, and obtain the necessary written approvals before proceeding with the disputed work if the site can safely wait. Supreme Court E-Library

Government infrastructure projects follow separate rules

For projects governed by Republic Act No. 12009, the New Government Procurement Act, bid prices are fixed for the awarded scope. Section 89 permits consideration of escalation for extraordinary increases in specific infrastructure components, subject to prior Government Procurement Policy Board (GPPB) approval. The law provides for possible escalation on a no-loss, no-gain basis when the component cost increase exceeds 10% of the unit price of the work item, measured against the applicable Philippine Statistics Authority indices and using the prescribed GPPB formula. Crossing the threshold alone creates no entitlement to payment. lawphil.net

A variation order addresses changes in the work. Under Section 71.2.1 of the approved implementing rules, cumulative additive variation orders are generally capped at 10% of the original contract price. Separable work beyond that threshold must be procured separately. In exceptional cases where an addition is urgently necessary to complete the original scope, the Head of the Procuring Entity may, upon the required recommendation, authorize cumulative additive variations above 10% and up to 20%. The rules also govern when work may begin and when payment may be made. For older projects, check the procurement dates and applicable transition rules because Republic Act No. 9184 and its implementing rules may still govern. Supreme Court E-Library

What to do when a higher bill arrives

  1. Ask for an itemized written claim. For each charge, request the relevant contract clause or change order, the original and revised scope, the quantities and rates, and the written approvals. Ask the contractor to identify any effect on the completion date.
  2. Respond in writing and follow the notice clause. Identify which items you accept, which you dispute, and why. Check who must receive the notice, how it must be served, and when it is due. Handle undisputed amounts according to the contract, including any applicable certification, retention, or payment conditions.
  3. Preserve the project record. Keep the signed contract and annexes, original and revised plans, site instructions, change orders, dated photos, site logs, inspection reports, invoices, and proof of payment or delivery of notices. Save full email and chat threads with attachments and sender details.
  4. Put any agreement into a signed document. Record the exact work, the price or credit, any time extension, and when payment is due. Identify the people signing and confirm their authority.

Common mistakes include agreeing to the work while leaving the price “to follow,” relying on a verbal instruction from someone whose authority is unclear, treating a signed delivery receipt as approval of a surcharge, and missing a contractual notice deadline while negotiations continue.

Deadlines, dispute resolution, and urgent help

Check the contract immediately for deadlines to notify a claim, dispute a billing, or challenge a certification. For an action based on a written contract, Article 1144 of the Civil Code generally provides 10 years from accrual of the right of action. Article 1155 provides for interruption of prescription by filing the action in court, making a written extrajudicial demand, or obtaining a written acknowledgment of the debt by the debtor. The date a claim accrues depends on the facts, and contractual notice deadlines can arise much sooner. Supreme Court E-Library

If the parties are bound by an arbitration agreement covering the Philippine construction dispute, the Construction Industry Arbitration Commission (CIAC) generally has original and exclusive jurisdiction, including over changes in contract cost and payment disputes. Check the contract for any required preliminary steps, then consult CIAC’s rules, Request for Arbitration procedure, and fee requirements. If there is no applicable arbitration agreement, the appropriate court process depends on the claim and the relief sought. Supreme Court E-Library

Get legal help promptly if either side threatens to stop work or terminate, a formal notice or bond demand arrives, a filing deadline is close, or you are being asked to sign a waiver or final settlement. If unfinished work creates an immediate safety hazard, restrict access and get a qualified building professional to assess it promptly.

Frequently asked questions

Can a contractor stop work until I pay the increase?
Rising labor or material costs alone do not give the contractor the right to withdraw under Article 1724. Nonpayment of an amount actually due, unsafe conditions, or another asserted ground for suspension requires a separate review of the contract, the facts, and any required notices. Supreme Court E-Library

Can a text message or email count as written approval?
Potentially. The Electronic Commerce Act recognizes electronic documents subject to requirements including integrity, reliability, and authentication. The record must still show that the owner or an authorized representative approved the change and that both parties agreed on the price or its written basis. A message saying “go ahead” may leave the price unresolved. Supreme Court E-Library

Do I owe for extra work simply because it is already installed?
Completion, use, or a unilateral invoice does not by itself establish the two writings Article 1724 requires for a change to agreed plans. Review the full record for written authorization and pricing before deciding whether the amount is due. Supreme Court E-Library

Can the owner cancel the project over the disputed bill?
Check the termination clause and the grounds for ending the contract before acting. Article 1725 allows an owner to withdraw at will, but requires indemnifying the contractor as provided in that article. Termination for an alleged breach raises separate questions about the breach, notice, and remedies. Supreme Court E-Library

Official sources

This article provides general Philippine legal information. A specific claim depends on the contract, the project records, and any special rules that apply. Official sources were checked on 16 November 2026.

Disclaimer: This content is not legal advice and may involve AI assistance. Information may be inaccurate.